Shaw has discontinued its luxury vinyl plank (LVP) product line named Prodigy HDR MXL Plus. The irony is that this product contained no vinyl. It was not actually LVP. Shaw used a novel core chemistry that combined wood with magnesium oxide. Without vinyl in the core, it's hard to call this an LVP product. This no-vinyl design allowed them to use very high temperatures to apply a melamine, laminate-like surface with high-quality lithography. The surface of these boards looks like a quality laminate flooring, not LVP.
So why did they discontinue the product? They had problems with the core cracking. Without a flexible vinyl layer surrounding the wood core, an uneven surface could easily put tension on the wood fibers and crack them. Like concrete, this product performed well under compression loads but poorly under tension loads.
If you installed this product five years ago, how has it held up for you over time? In reviewing the many reports of failure I have been reading on Internet threads, I see three types of installs:
1) Some people simply install the boards without leveling the floor. These installs seem to fail within months.
2) Some people install the boards professionally, and there is some leveling of the subfloor, but the boards still seem to show cracking in places where the subfloor is not level.
3) Maybe 25% of the installs report perfect outcomes, with no cracking, but all of the benefits of a laminate-like surface: hard to scratch, visually more like wood, and easier to clean. But none of these reports give long-term outcomes, since they were within two years of the initial install.
Many people report hearing noises as the padding under the boards rubs against a wood subfloor. This seems to be fixed by using the Shaw Bravo thin underlayment.
So, has anyone here installed this product and not had a floor fail after 4+ years?
westes Zone 9b California SF BayOriginal Author
Platinum Realty
Related Professionals
Brainerd Basement Remodeling · San Diego Basement Remodeling · Jackson Bathroom Remodelers · Stockton Bathroom Remodelers · Hobbs Home Remodeling · Tallahassee Kitchen Remodelers · Owensboro Kitchen Remodelers · Lafayette Kitchen Remodelers · York Kitchen Remodelers · Gulfport Flooring Contractors · Buffalo Flooring Contractors · Spanish Fork Flooring Contractors · Coos Bay Tile and Stone Contractors · Wenatchee Tile and Stone Contractors · Jamestown Kitchen Remodelers