Software
Houzz Logo Print
reneeholzman1

48" Built-in refrigerators - which brand?

5 days ago

I am working on a kitchen remodel. I currently have a KitchenAid 48" side-by-side built in which works fine, but was installed in 2014, so 12 years old. I'm having trouble making a decision! Do I keep the KA and hope it lasts another 12 years? Or do I replace it? I'm considering the Thermador 48" Freedom with French doors and bottom freezers or a Sub Zero Classic with French Doors and bottom freezer. If I replace it I would go for a panel ready option for the aesthetics. Any reviews or experiences to share that might help me with my decision?

Comments (21)

  • 5 days ago

    SZ French Doors bottom freezer. Have one since 2015 and wouldn't go any other way. Stainless steel for me, I don't get the whole panel thing to hide the fact that it's an appliance.

  • 4 days ago

    I don't have a 48" but I installed a SubZero last year to replace an awkwardly placed freestanding fridge that wouldn't open all the way due to the adjacent angled pantry wall. I pondered it for a long time but finally went with it because I didn't want a fridge with a peeling print proof finish that might last 7-8 years if I was lucky. I did go with a cabinet panel - not to hide the fridge (mine is obviously a fridge) but because I prefer the appearance over a big silver blob. I had a great cabinet maker who matched my 20 year old cabinets perfectly. If you're doing built-in, I wouldn't do anything other than SZ as long as it's within your budget. We put a 42" built-in KA in a previous house when we remodeled our kitchen - saved a few thousand over SZ. There is no comparison and I would not make that choice again.

  • PRO
    4 days ago

    If the KitchenAid is running fine, the real question is whether the remodel is your one shot to change the opening. A 48 inch built-in is a pretty standard cutout, so you're usually not locked in later, but panel ready plus new cabinetry is way easier to do once. Between the two you named, Sub-Zero is the one I see clients stick with long term, mainly for the dual compressor setup and service network. Thermador gives you a lot of fridge for the money. Either way, check the exact cutout specs and who services that brand in your area before you order.

    reneeholzman1 thanked Boss Design Center
  • 4 days ago

    Keep the KitchenAid. That Thermador T48BT110NS spreads the food over six compartments. How could a design be less convenient? My sister replaced a 36" side-by-side with a French door model. It's the dumbest design: you open the refrigerator door and you can only see half the food. With the old side-by-side, you could see everything.

    The Thermador energy guide says it costs $94/year to operate. Let's suppose your 2014 model costs twice that. The Thermador costs $16,800. At $94/year savings, it would cost 178 years to recover the difference!

    reneeholzman1 thanked wdccruise
  • 4 days ago

    I did a 42" SZ french door when we built in 2021. I would have gone with the 48", but they hadn't introduced that model at that time. I like my appliances paneled as I hate cleaning stainless steel, so well worth it to me.

    (missing the white baseboard beneath the fridge in this photo)


  • 4 days ago
    last modified: 4 days ago

    If you would like to integrate the frig and freezer fully into cabnetry 1/8" teveal for integrated vs 1/2" reveal for panel ready, you have options with the SZ Designer line. 30" all frig and an 18" or 24" all freezer are a couple ways. Tou can seperate the units for layout benefits.

  • 4 days ago

    "So if you’re leaning toward replacing it eventually, the remodel is the cheapest time to do it."

    That Sub-Zero refrigerator lists for $15,000. It will cost far less to modify the cabinets if the KitchenAid fails in the future. An don't forget the time value of money; at a 5% interest rate, the future value of a $15,000 investment in, say 10 years, is $24,434.

  • 3 days ago

    And in 10 years the SZ will be $24k. Maybe only $20l

  • 3 days ago

    Sub Zero, hands down. Like @chispa, I prefer my fridge paneled.


  • 3 days ago
    last modified: 3 days ago

    darbuka: "Sub Zero, hands down."

    You mean, "Sub Zero, hands up!"


  • 2 days ago

    @wdccruise, it’s been well documented over the years, how adverse you are to spending $$$ on high end appliances. Until you’ve experienced the superiority of SubZero refrigeration, your opinion is nothing but bias against the cost.

  • 2 days ago

    Two different kitchens, one with a KA (10 years old) and the other with a SZ (9 years old).


    The freezer handle on the KA has come off several times, to the point the underlying support seems to be failing. A plastic piece associated with a wide drawer broke and the cost to replace is over $400. I am living with it for now.....


    The SZ is still perfect.

  • 2 days ago

    We moved to a home 13 years ago that had a subzero 36 in wide fridge that was installed in 2000.

    I never had expensive high end appliances in the past and I usually chose mid range quality appliances.

    The Subzero is great and had one switch go bad wich we replaced ourselves. I love that the food seems to last a little longer and that the layout really makes it easy to load a lot into the fridge and not loose anything.

    They are expensive, but I would replace this with the same if it fails.

    If you can afford it, it is great luxury to have.

    Make sure that if you are short, you can reach the top shelf on some of the newer styles.


  • 2 days ago
    last modified: 2 days ago

    Of course, @wdccruise, it’s you that does the disparaging and finger wagging…at those of us who have purchased and extol the virtues of SubZero fridges…or Miele wall ovens, etc.

    I don’t give a hoot what low to mid range appliances you buy. However, it really seems to bug you that so many people deem spending our hard earned money on expensive, higher performing appliances, worthwhile. It’s your problem.

  • yesterday

    Before Whirlpool bought the American competitors and then built their business plan around their one year warranty, refrigerators were built to last in order to compete. 20 years and more was no problem. If we still had that competitive marketplace very few would see a strong need to pay for SZ.

    We need true quality competition and the korean products are not that. In Japan Hitachi, Panasonic and others produce quality that lasts because of competition. We need products from those manufacturers in our market.

  • yesterday

    Sub Zero. We had a 36" Refrigerator and the 36" Freezer in our previous home and the freezer was still working when we moved 29 years later. We did replace the Refrigerator after 25" years because we were re-doing the cabinets and decided to buy a new one so that we could add a custom panel. The freezer was in the pantry so it was not noticeable..

    In our new home we bought a 42" French Door SZ. That was 9 years ago and trouble-free.

  • yesterday

    @maire_cate, my story is similar. SZ over/under 36” fridge purchased in 1990, was still going strong in 2015 when we sold that home. For the new home, which we moved to in 2016, we purchased the 42” FD fridge. 10 yo, completely trouble free.

  • yesterday

    Thanks everyone! Lots of information to ponder, particularly the cabinet box size if I'm going panel ready. I did notice in the showroom that if you want the 48" SZ fridge door to not be proud of the cabinet, you have to leave a gap on either side of the unit presumably to allow for the door clearance. Or go with the Designer Series.

  • yesterday

    There is cometition for SZ. Miele. Which also offers lasting dishwashers and ComboSteamOvens. Plus a just released full surface induction cooktop. Any magnetic pan or griddle anywhere you want.

  • 23 hours ago
    last modified: 23 hours ago

    The door can be flush with the Classic model - there is an option for that. I don't recall the details - if I had to order the fridge that way or if it just involved the specs for the cabinet.