I agree, the first set.

I ended up going with the first set of pictures and I got 2 white "fur" pillows, a chocoalte brown pillow, a grey pillow, and a burnt orange/red color pillow. With all the pillows being different colors, other than the 2 white, is this too much?

All those colors might be too much. How does it look to you? If you think "too much" scale back…

The white furry pillows sound like a great idea for your chocolate room.

And, first set of pictures was the way to go.

Happy Decorating!

What color pillows would you put with this picture. Maybe just chocolate and white?

The first one looks great on the brown walls. Just makes it pop so well!

First set.

Two questions, how large is the room? I think the second set if it is a larger room.
Were you planning on framing them? if so, that might make a difference for you.

I guess the first set. OK.