Why not mimic the pattern from the door

I would not fill in the entire space with mirror tiles. I would get a nice wide console table with 2 lamps and a large framed mirror in between. You can find hundreds of examples here on houzz.

Hi Sunny, I totally agree, but I'm running out of money for the framed mirror.
I looked at large mirrors in my price range 1500.00, but they were 1/8" depth (fun house quality) where as I can buy a 1/4" quality beveled mirror for the same amount. Here's my inspiration photo. I like the tailored look of the wall of mirrors.

mocreidhl, you're awesome and we did play with that idea, but the general consensus was a no....the circle was at eye level making it awkward.
We would love to hear your choice since we now know you have an eye for design!

Do a larger circle-maybe 18-22" diameter. Or I prefer the 1st. I would consider an antiqued mirror to avoid it looking too 80's.

Do you have a Home Goods near you? You can find amazing things for great prices.

I am no help on a mirrored wall. Good luck!

Mirrored walls always remind me of when someone does it to make a small condo look bigger...possibly a cool wallpaper or a beautiful accent color is also worth considering