Kitchen of the Week: A Family of 4 Loves to Cook Together Here
A multilevel island lies at the heart of an Illinois kitchen designed for a budding chef and her foodie family

Becky Harris
September 29, 2017
Houzz Contributor. Hi there! I live in a 1940s cottage in Atlanta that I'll describe as "collected."
I got into design via Landscape Architecture, which I studied at the University of Virginia.
Houzz Contributor. Hi there! I live in a 1940s cottage in Atlanta that I'll describe... More
Photos by Michael Alan Kaskel
Kitchen at a Glance
Who lives here: Kathleen Osta, Tony Smith and their daughters, Kaelan and Addison
Location: River Forest, Illinois
Size: 320 square feet (30 square meters) plus a butler’s pantry
Designer: Rebekah Zaveloff of KitchenLab | Rebekah Zaveloff Design
The backstory: This family of four had recently relocated from California to just outside of Chicago. While they loved their 1920s home, the kitchen could not accommodate a family who loves to cook together. So they opted to put on an addition to expand the kitchen and open it up to the living and dining rooms, in a more California modern kind of way.
The celebrity in the family: Osta and Smith’s daughter Addison won Fox TV’s MasterChef Junior competition in 2016. We need to get two things straight right away. One, her passion for cooking didn’t happen in a vacuum — the whole family loves to cook and loves to cook together. And two, her prize money is in a college fund — it did not pay for this kitchen renovation!
Kitchen at a Glance
Who lives here: Kathleen Osta, Tony Smith and their daughters, Kaelan and Addison
Location: River Forest, Illinois
Size: 320 square feet (30 square meters) plus a butler’s pantry
Designer: Rebekah Zaveloff of KitchenLab | Rebekah Zaveloff Design
The backstory: This family of four had recently relocated from California to just outside of Chicago. While they loved their 1920s home, the kitchen could not accommodate a family who loves to cook together. So they opted to put on an addition to expand the kitchen and open it up to the living and dining rooms, in a more California modern kind of way.
The celebrity in the family: Osta and Smith’s daughter Addison won Fox TV’s MasterChef Junior competition in 2016. We need to get two things straight right away. One, her passion for cooking didn’t happen in a vacuum — the whole family loves to cook and loves to cook together. And two, her prize money is in a college fund — it did not pay for this kitchen renovation!
Challenge: This family needed space so they could all cook together without getting in each other’s way. “They cook as a family and didn’t want to be on top of each other,” designer Rebekah Zaveloff says. “For example, they bake hundreds of cupcakes for events together.”
Solutions: Zaveloff laid out a kitchen where the whole family could cook together. As you’ll see in the following plan, she designed a large island as part of the work triangle. She was also able to split the refrigerator and freezer to free up important space. She created zones for other uses like a library nook and an eat-in area.
The inspiration: “This was a study in contrast,” Zaveloff says. For one thing, Tony is very tall and Kathleen is petite. For another, they were in a 1920s house outside Chicago but longed for some nods to the California style to make it feel more like home. Finally, the contrast included color — the cabinets are Sherwin-Williams Inkwell — a black with a bit of navy in it, which provides a strong contrast to the whites in the marble, backsplash tiles and bricks on the fireplace surround.
The flow: In order to adapt the open California modern plan to the 1920s home in a way that respected the existing architecture, Zaveloff had a vision — a large hearth wall that would provide separation and definition between rooms. The fireplace can be enjoyed from the family room (left), dining area (foreground) and kitchen (right). And it was a hit. “In the winter, the three-way fireplace is a favorite feature,” says homeowner Kathleen Osta. “It makes the kitchen, dining and family room feel cozy and homey, and it keeps us warm.”
Solutions: Zaveloff laid out a kitchen where the whole family could cook together. As you’ll see in the following plan, she designed a large island as part of the work triangle. She was also able to split the refrigerator and freezer to free up important space. She created zones for other uses like a library nook and an eat-in area.
The inspiration: “This was a study in contrast,” Zaveloff says. For one thing, Tony is very tall and Kathleen is petite. For another, they were in a 1920s house outside Chicago but longed for some nods to the California style to make it feel more like home. Finally, the contrast included color — the cabinets are Sherwin-Williams Inkwell — a black with a bit of navy in it, which provides a strong contrast to the whites in the marble, backsplash tiles and bricks on the fireplace surround.
The flow: In order to adapt the open California modern plan to the 1920s home in a way that respected the existing architecture, Zaveloff had a vision — a large hearth wall that would provide separation and definition between rooms. The fireplace can be enjoyed from the family room (left), dining area (foreground) and kitchen (right). And it was a hit. “In the winter, the three-way fireplace is a favorite feature,” says homeowner Kathleen Osta. “It makes the kitchen, dining and family room feel cozy and homey, and it keeps us warm.”
Floor plan: The family added on to the house, and Zaveloff came up with a plan to organize the family room, dining space, kitchen and butler’s pantry in a way that suited the home’s age and architecture but also gave the family the open California modern feeling. You can see how these rooms open out to the deck (on the right). “The deck off the kitchen and dining room was a priority for us. We lived in California, where we ate most meals outside, until four years ago. The deck gives us a great indoor-outdoor feel, and we spend a lot of time out there.”
Here you can see how the rooms open to one another, and the specific zones Zaveloff designed. To the left is the cookbook, library and household command central area, on the bottom right of that is the eat-in nook, on the top left is the butler’s pantry and to the right is the work triangle. If you squint you can also see that the freezer (left) and refrigerator (to the left of the range) are split up from one another — more on that in a bit.
Here you can see how the rooms open to one another, and the specific zones Zaveloff designed. To the left is the cookbook, library and household command central area, on the bottom right of that is the eat-in nook, on the top left is the butler’s pantry and to the right is the work triangle. If you squint you can also see that the freezer (left) and refrigerator (to the left of the range) are split up from one another — more on that in a bit.
Eating in: The hearth wall creates a cozy eat-in nook in the kitchen. The walls are brick but not just any brick — they are antique Chicago bricks. Zaveloff planned the length of the wall behind the sofa around one of her favorite tufted banquettes from Arhaus. Then she created a 1920s Paris cafe-inspired vibe. A large mirror flanked by sconces brightens the eat-in nook. And woven Paris cafe chairs round out the look.
“We all love our kitchen table nook for dinners with just the four of us,” Osta says.
“We all love our kitchen table nook for dinners with just the four of us,” Osta says.
A large mirror flanked by sconces brightens the eat-in nook.
Those hanging out in the nook can keep the cooks company while staying well out of the way of the work zone. Of course they can also pull up a stool on the social side of the island. The Tolix stools bring in some French cafe esprit.
“We all love to have friends here and love to put food and drinks out on the island so people can make their own plates and either stay in the kitchen, sit at the dining room table or go out on the deck,” Osta says.
Browse bar stools
“We all love to have friends here and love to put food and drinks out on the island so people can make their own plates and either stay in the kitchen, sit at the dining room table or go out on the deck,” Osta says.
Browse bar stools
Work zone: “This design was very chef-driven,” Zaveloff says. She suggested a BlueStar range. It was also a good pick aesthetically, as the family did not want stainless steel. This range is in a matte black. Zaveloff had the vent hood fabricated locally. It is powder-coated metal with brass straps. “This is more environmentally friendly than enamel,” she says.
To the left of the range is a counter-depth refrigerator, concealed by panels to match the cabinetry. Having the sink located off the end of the island helps the family spread out when they are cooking together.
To the left of the range is a counter-depth refrigerator, concealed by panels to match the cabinetry. Having the sink located off the end of the island helps the family spread out when they are cooking together.
Cabinets: The cabinets are classic Shaker style with a beaded inset. Glass doors on the upper cabinets keep this side of the kitchen looking lighter and more open. The cabinets have stained oak interiors that add warmth to the room.
Countertops and backsplash: These elements add strong contrast to the cabinetry’s dark color. The countertops are Carrara marble. The backsplash tiles are elongated subway tiles. “These are hand-painted terra-cotta tiles, which means they have a watery, uneven finish,” Zaveloff says. This adds age and patina to the new kitchen that suits the almost 100-year-old home.
Countertops and backsplash: These elements add strong contrast to the cabinetry’s dark color. The countertops are Carrara marble. The backsplash tiles are elongated subway tiles. “These are hand-painted terra-cotta tiles, which means they have a watery, uneven finish,” Zaveloff says. This adds age and patina to the new kitchen that suits the almost 100-year-old home.
Kitchen island: This is what it’s all about for the family — the size of the island and the way placed it in the room is what makes it possible for them all to work together. We’ll start here on the far end of it — this walnut chopping board table is lower, which works well with the heights of all the females in the family. This piece has freestanding furniture style. “I love the unfitted furniture thing,” Zaveloff says. “It helped balance out the location of the entrance to the butler’s pantry here.” (If you look at the plan you can see that the main island lines up with the end of the refrigerator wall while the chopping station is opposite the entry to the butler’s pantry.)
The drawers underneath the chopping board hold silverware.
The drawers underneath the chopping board hold silverware.
The main island holds two dishwashers, a galley sink, cabinets outfitted with tray dividers, double trash cans and a beverage refrigerator.
Pendants: Robert Abbey
Pendants: Robert Abbey
Lighting: Due to a few production flukes, the family waited 18 months for the pendant lights. You read that right — not 18 weeks, 18 months. “They were totally worth the wait,” Zaveloff says. They suit the home’s 1920 vintage and nods to Parisian cafe style to a T. Library fixtures light up the wall by the main sink.
Tip: Zaveloff recommends hiding outlets in the kitchen when possible. Here they are on the side of the island and tucked under cabinets whenever possible.
Tip: Zaveloff recommends hiding outlets in the kitchen when possible. Here they are on the side of the island and tucked under cabinets whenever possible.
Finishes: “They were wary of using brass at first,” Zaveloff says. “I told them it’s not like 1980s brass — it’s more like 1880s brass!” She mixed in polished nickel on the hardware and faucets to ease their worries about standing up to trends.
Faucets: She chose the faucets from the same series for a cohesive look.
Faucets: Artifact Series, Kohler; see other faucets
Faucets: She chose the faucets from the same series for a cohesive look.
Faucets: Artifact Series, Kohler; see other faucets
Freezer: To the right is the freezer. “The latest developments in separating the column refrigerator from the freezer has completely changed my job,” Zaveloff says. “You don’t need the freezer taking up that space inside the work triangle because you don’t use it that much. And by separating them, you don’t have to have these two massive units that don’t look good together because they are so huge. It’s totally changed the proportion game.”
Kitchen library: To the left of the freezer is home command central. It can also serve as the culinary research center, though Zaveloff says not all the books need to stick to a kitchen theme. “I love to put bookshelves in a kitchen, and it doesn’t have to be just for cookbooks,” Zaveloff says. It’s easy to grab a book and enjoy it over in the eat-in nook.
Refrigerator and freezer: Thermador; browse appliances
Kitchen library: To the left of the freezer is home command central. It can also serve as the culinary research center, though Zaveloff says not all the books need to stick to a kitchen theme. “I love to put bookshelves in a kitchen, and it doesn’t have to be just for cookbooks,” Zaveloff says. It’s easy to grab a book and enjoy it over in the eat-in nook.
Refrigerator and freezer: Thermador; browse appliances
Butler’s pantry: Here’s a glimpse into the walk-in pantry. This photo also shows how its entry relates to the chopping block table.
The walk-in pantry is 56 square feet (about 5 square meters). Zaveloff used a graphic encaustic cement tile floor in here. The space holds small appliances, including a coffee station. Having a sink here makes morning drinks easier to prepare. Shaker cabinets painted in Inkwell and brass brackets tie the shelves to the kitchen design.
See more encaustic cement tile
See more encaustic cement tile
Mudroom: You may have noticed this mudroom on the plans. Also part of the renovation, the mudroom is accessible through the pantry, and the tiles continue through this space.
The champ: Here’s MasterChef Junior winner Addison Osta Smith enjoying the new kitchen.
Her favorite activities include grilling meat on the indoor grill, stir-frying with the set-in wok feature and baking banana bread, cookies and cakes. Kaelen enjoys making big breakfasts, especially waffles. Osta loves grilling veggies on the outdoor grill, and Smith loves to cook for the kids and their friends every weekend. Two of the family’s favorite things to make together are pizzas and homemade pasta dishes.
More: Browse more Kitchens of the Week
Her favorite activities include grilling meat on the indoor grill, stir-frying with the set-in wok feature and baking banana bread, cookies and cakes. Kaelen enjoys making big breakfasts, especially waffles. Osta loves grilling veggies on the outdoor grill, and Smith loves to cook for the kids and their friends every weekend. Two of the family’s favorite things to make together are pizzas and homemade pasta dishes.
More: Browse more Kitchens of the Week
Related Stories
Transitional Homes
Houzz Tour: 1930s Home Becomes a Better Version of Itself
A thoughtful redesign with new built-ins, leaded glass, herringbone floors and loads of charm transforms an older home
Full Story
Remodeling Guides
Should You Stay or Should You Go for a Remodel? 10 Points to Ponder
Consider these renovation realities to help you decide whether to budget for temporary housing
Full Story
Kitchen Design
9 Ways to Add Color to a Kitchen
By dytecture
Give yourself permission to go with the colors you love in the heart of your home
Full Story
Life
10 Ways to Live With a Smaller Carbon Footprint
Take these simple steps to reduce your energy use and cut back on waste
Full Story
Kitchen Design
New Kitchen Takes Its Cue From the Home’s Traditional Style
Classic trim and millwork make this new kitchen a better fit for a Colonial Revival house in Minneapolis
Full Story
My Houzz
New Tudor-Inspired Family Home in Chicago
By Julie Sheer
See how a couple worked with their builder to mix traditional and modern elements for a comfortable and chic home
Full Story
Kitchen Design
Are Colorful Kitchen Appliances the Next Big Trend?
By Jennifer Ott
Move over, black, white and stainless steel — appliances in a variety of bright colors are starting to sizzle
Full Story
Houzz Tours
Houzz Tour: A Radical Reconstruction Raises an Austin Home
With a new second floor and some room swapping downstairs, this 1935 Texas bungalow now fits an architect and his family beautifully
Full Story
Kitchen Design
Before and After: 5 Open Kitchens That Work With Adjacent Spaces
By Erin Carlyle
Repeating colors, finishes and shapes helps these open-plan kitchens blend stylistically with the spaces nearby
Full Story
What an incredibly well thought out and creative space, it fits modern family life but works perfectly in an older house built in the late 19th century/early 20th century. I guess those are the perks of having the money to work with such an amazing designer!!!! Even down to the intimate little nook behind the hearth, and the butlers pantry and mudroom. Just beautiful.
Love the small appliance center and the books.
Beautiful! What is the color of the cabinets?