5 Tips for Mixing Kitchen Countertop Materials

Tired of the same old kitchen look? Follow these tips to create a kitchen with more personality and punch

Sam FerrisDecember 20, 2019

Houzz Contributor. I write about all things remodeling, interior design, and home improvement at tukasacreations.com/kasa-blog. I also design kitchen cabinets and am Marketing and Social Media Director for Tukasa Creations, Inc., a flooring, remodeling and design store.

The idea of combining two countertop styles in your kitchen might seem overwhelming at first, but it’s a relatively cut-and-dried process. It all boils down to balance, color coordination and effortlessly mixing different materials. Ready to start piecing together your design? Here are five strategies to put in your playbook.

Curran & Co. Architects

1. Pay Attention to Patterns

Take special note of patterns when you’re shopping for more than one countertop design. The last thing you want is two styles that clash. If two options both have significant movement or pattern, pairing them can overwhelm your kitchen design and distract the eye. If you find yourself drawn to busy designs, search for a complementary countertop that’s solid-colored or has minimal pattern. This will ensure that one counter material doesn’t compete with the other.

Andre Rothblatt Architecture

Marble, granite and other natural stones typically feature a lot of movement, though many engineered materials now mimic these natural stones. Try matching one of these materials with a toned-down quartz or solid surface for the perfect balance. If you’re set on an all-natural look, you can play with color instead of pattern.

Find kitchen designers on Houzz

Rasmussen Construction

2. Coordinate With Accent Colors

Accent colors can come from your favorite art piece, linens, furniture, plumbing fixtures, cabinet hardware and even your range hood. If there’s a shade you’re fond of, pick a countertop design that either matches or incorporates that tone in its pattern. The downside to this strategy is that your countertop may look out of place if you ever decide to change your kitchen’s accent colors. While that shouldn’t discourage you altogether, it’s something to know before you sign on the dotted line.

Shop for cabinet hardware

SINGLEPOINT DESIGN BUILD INC.

This transitional San Francisco kitchen built by Singlepoint Design Build features a dark island top that coordinates well with its inky lower cabinets, creating a cohesive aesthetic among the wood, stone, metal and painted finishes.

Don Tankersley & Co.

3. Balance Dark With Light

The age-old principle of yin and yang applies to countertop design too. If your first choice is on the lighter side, look for a darker second choice for contrast. You can go with a classic black-and-white motif as seen in this midcentury kitchen built by Don Tankersley & Co., or mix light and dark neutrals, pastels, primary colors and so on.

Walker Home Design

When creating a light-dark dynamic, there’s more than one approach. If you have mixed cabinet colors, you can use a light countertop with light-colored cabinets (and vice versa) for a more dramatic contrast between your two designs. You can also opt for balance by placing your darker selection on lighter cabinetry. If your cabinetry is the same color throughout, consider other factors, such as how well each countertop design stacks up to your backsplash material.

Buena Vista Development Corp

4. Create an Accent Piece on Your Island

Whether they feature bold color tones or unusual patterns, many designs are natural showstoppers. There’s no better spot to install them than the hub of your kitchen. Wrapping your island with dramatic patterns and sweeping veins, such as in this Toronto kitchen island designed by Lori Morris, will create a focal point that stands out, especially if the rest of your kitchen’s color scheme is neutral or muted.

Seaside Construction - Custom Home Builder

Accent pieces don’t have to be over-the-top. You can opt for styles that bring flair yet still mesh well with the rest of your space. This coastal kitchen island built by Seaside Construction features sparse veins amid a white background that pop next to the solid gray perimeter tops.

Sopher Sparn Architects LLC

5. Mix Materials

If you’re undecided between two polar-opposite materials, there’s good news: You can use both. It’s common to pair both engineered surfaces such as quartz and porcelain with natural surfaces like granite and soapstone. You can even mix two different types of stone (travertine with granite, for instance). The drawback? One cleaning agent won’t necessarily fit all. For example, you can use a product like Windex on engineered surfaces, but it isn’t recommended for natural stone. Read up on each surface’s cleaning guidelines before you start wiping it down.

North Fork Builders of Montana, Inc.

Other popular material options include a custom wood piece or butcher block. These can bring warmth and texture to your space, especially when mixed with a clean quartz or solid-surface style.

More on Houzz
What Countertop Color Should You Choose?
Houzz Quiz: What Kitchen Countertop Is Right for You?
Find kitchen designers
Shop for kitchen products

Comments (20)

See 17 more comments

teamaltese

We have a breakfast room open to the kitchen. When we decided to renovate that room, 3 years after renovating the kitchen, matching the kitchen granite was impossible. So we went with butcher block. The added cabinets tied in with the kitchen. Both spaces are now warm and inviting, and who doesn’t need extra storage?

Debi Wong

I mixed it up. Still a work in progress, have yet to add the backsplash. Going with a lighter color to pick up the lighter tones on the island. Counter surround is “leathered” granite. Very affordable due to using A/B grades and the leathering was not an up sell.

Lauren H

Wow, all of the examples are beautiful! Just completed my kitchen remodel and used Ceasarstone Raven on the main perimeter counters and Mountain White quartzite on the island and bar area.