
About Us
Carter Cabinet Company is a family run business in New Palestine, IN. We sell custom Amish made cabinetry. What makes our cabinets stick out from our competition is our attention to detail and the quality of workmanship. This father daughter team takes pride in their product. Everything is made of solid wood and the finish on the cabinets is a 4 step process to ensure quality over time. We measure to the 1/16''. NO fillers. NO particle board. We do everything from designing the dream kitchen you thought you would never have to building a functional and organized office for your new home. Basement bars, bathroom vanities, built in bookshelves or entertainment centers, laundry rooms, lockers for your mudroom- you name it and we can make it! Found a picture online that you want replicated? -we can do it. Once the design and details of each job have been worked out- we work with the Amish cabinet makers so they know exactly what needs to be built. There will be a lot of questions- but only because your options are unlimited and we want to make sure every customer understands and gets everything they are looking for in their new space! Once the cabinets are built- we will send a crew of Amish installers to put it all together and like the rest of our customers- you won't believe it's yours.
Services Provided
3D Rendering, Cabinet Installation, Custom Bathroom Vanities, Custom Bookcases, Custom Built-ins, Custom Cabinets, Custom Entertainment Centers, Custom Home Bars, Custom Kitchen Cabinets, Custom Pantries, Custom Shelving, Pantry Design
Areas Served
Beech Grove, Cumberland, Fairland, New Palestine
Awards
Angie's List Super Service Award Winner 2013 Angie's List Super Service Award Winner 2014
Credentials
4 Houzz Awards
2 Houzz Badges
Write a Review


























33 Reviews for Carter Cabinet Company
5.0|33 reviews
Work Quality5.0
Communication5.0
Value5.0

coutureclan5
Relationship
Client
We love our new bathroom cabinets! Josh was very patient and helpful with the planning process and thoughtfully provided different options to ensure that we were pleased with the final product. Theses cabinets are well-made- sturdy, functional and beautiful. It was a great experience from beginning to end.


January 9, 2021

cchmunsell
Relationship
Client
We are so pleased with our new cabinets! From my first phone call to installation, they were professional , knowledgable and courteous. High quality workmanship and beautiful. Was amazed at the amount of time spent on detailed planning. Only wish we’d had them do our kitchen cabinets!



December 30, 2020

Kevin S
Relationship
Client
For anyone in the market for new cabinets, I would highly suggest contacting Josh at Carter Cabinets. We could not have been more pleased with both our experience, and the finished product. Josh was involved with the project from start to finish. We did a full kitchen remodel including removing walls and relocating appliances, and Josh was an integral part of the process. He communicated clearly, consistently, and exceeding our expectations. It was outstanding working with Josh and his team as small business owners. They have a vested interest in every project, and it is truly custom to your space. Initially, we were intimidated by the cost of Amish cabinets, but we found they were competitive with big box stores with exceptionally higher quality. I have included both before and after pictures. We look forward to enjoying our cabinets for many years to come!






December 30, 2020Last modified:December 30, 2020

Mary Kate Gordon
Relationship
Client
We just completed a very large addition and reconfigured our entire first floor of our 1960’s colonial, including a new kitchen. Our contractor, Spivey Remodeling, connected us to Josh at Carter Cabinet Company to design our kitchen cabinets. In 10 months, we worked with countless vendors and Josh was AMAZING to work with. From the beginning, he really understood my vision. Over the months, we did go through many design changes and he was always patient with my new ideas and last minute changes and offered his expert opinion, which we really appreciated. I had a very specific vision for my cabinet style, color and layout. Josh ensured that his team would be able to create beautiful custom cabinets… he truly made my dream kitchen a reality. From design to install, every detail was executed perfectly. The installation team was friendly and professional, not to mention rock stars at installing cabinets. The cabinets themselves are top quality and more than I thought I could have. When you hear ‘custom’ I assume $$$, but these cabinets were very reasonably priced for the level of quality. After installation Tom (owner) and Josh came for a final walkthrough and checked every cabinet down to the hinge and made sure everything was absolutely perfect. We are thrilled with Carter Cabinet Company – so much so we already have plans to have them build a custom wine/wet bar in our dining room. We can’t wait to work with Josh again!!




December 29, 2020

Elizabeth K
Relationship
Client
Carter Cabinet Co was a pleasure to work with! We loved their attention to detail and the time, thought, and care they put into helping us design our dream kitchen/house! I can’t sing their praises enough! Their pricing for custom cabinets was so reasonable & was comparable to the cost of semi-custom cabinets at other competitors.
December 28, 2020

Kent
Relationship
Client
Great job in both assisting with the plan and our decision. Installation was professional completed and we are very satisfied with the new bookcases.
December 6, 2020

Jacqueline Bols
Relationship
Client
Josh was wonderful to work with! Vey pleasant ,kind and accommodating! The cabinets came out beautiful! Would highly recommend!
December 2, 2020

Howell Custom Homes
Relationship
Colleague
Carter provides cabinets for Howell Custom Homes clients and for our own personal home. The cabinets are reasonably-priced, well-made, and beautiful. Josh provides friendly, thoughtful service, and goes out of his way to take care of details.
November 30, 2020

HU-374109622
Relationship
Client
Everyone asks who did our cabinets on our kitchen remodel. The craftsmanship is gorgeous and they were very professional to work with. Beautiful work!
November 30, 2020

Natalie
Relationship
Client
We recently built a house and Carter Cabinet Co was hands down one of the best vendors we used. Josh did a great job explaining all of the options that were available. He was so helpful and patient with me for each decision. Carter Cabinet Co is very responsive with any questions you might have along the way, which made for a very smooth process. They are there for each stage--designing to selections to installing and even after if you have any questions once the cabinets are installed. I can't say enough good things about this company!
January 6, 2020

Sheila Benham
Relationship
Client
This is the second project we have hired Tom for. Excellent service and quality craftsmanship. We would definitely recommend him.
December 10, 2019

HU-247956940
Relationship
Client
Carter Cabinets did a fantastic job on our kitchen cabinets and Josh and Tom were wonderful to work with. The final product exceeded our expectations for a fair price. We highly recommend Carter Caninets!
December 6, 2019
5 Ideabooks
Contact Carter Cabinet Company
Find Cabinetry and Cabinet Makers to Help Get the Job Done
Tired of reading all the DIY tutorials? We are here to help. With over 1 million home professionals on Houzz, you’ll easily find the trusted Cabinet Professional for your next project in New Palestine, IN.
Read Reviews from New Palestine Homeowners Like You
Read homeowners reviews before hiring the Cabinet Professional to help with your project in New Palestine. If you have questions, read other homeowners’ reviews or our discussion forum for a second opinion.
Easily Contact Trusted Cabinetry and Cabinet Makers
If you’re browsing Houzz and have a contractor in mind, then you’ll quickly find that requesting a quote is easier than ever. From one simple dashboard, you can manage all the Cabinet Professional quotes you got.
Cabinets & Cabinetry near New Palestine
Shelby County Cabinets & Cabinetry · Greenwood Cabinets & Cabinetry · Greenfield Cabinets & Cabinetry · Beech Grove Cabinets & Cabinetry · New Whiteland Cabinets & Cabinetry · Cumberland Cabinets & Cabinetry · McCordsville Cabinets & Cabinetry · Whiteland Cabinets & Cabinetry · Bargersville Cabinets & Cabinetry · Fortville Cabinets & Cabinetry
Professional Categories in New Palestine
New Palestine Flooring Contractors · New Palestine Hot Tub & Spa Dealers · New Palestine Kitchen & Bath Fixtures · New Palestine Lighting · New Palestine Paint & Wall Coverings · New Palestine Siding & Exteriors · New Palestine Solar Energy Systems · New Palestine Staircases & Railings · New Palestine Stone, Pavers & Concrete · New Palestine Tile, Stone & Countertops