Software
Houzz Logo Print
ginnynichols

LED recessed can light

12 years ago
What is recommended for LED can lights whose purpose it is to illuminate 2-D artwork? The ceilings are 9' and sloped. There will be 6 cans with gimbal trim, 3 on each side of the room to lights parallel walls that have no windows. The artwork will vary in size depending on evolving desires of the occupants.

For one manufacturer, Halo, their LED bulbs not only range in Kelvin 2700,3000, 3500 and 4000 but they also vary in degrees: e.g. 25,35 and 50 degree reflector bulbs.(Will probably select the 3000K which is their closest to daylight) To make it more complex the photometry specs draw independent light cones: one for horizontal beam spread and a second for vertical beam spread instead of an integrated diagram that illustrates the combined beam spread for a given distance. I'm no stranger to specs but really, what the heck? Why make their understanding so convoluted?

Just to keep it mysterious, the specs provide various lens and dichroic color films and provide no images to see how they effects the light with the various potential combinations. Try to see it in the showroom. Ha! One is lucky to even see a working can with a 2700 K bulb let alone anything else.

With all the online media available instantly, one might reasonably expect to see a great demo "light show" featuring all the neat things one can do with these myriad options. So far I've only found basic installation info on YouTube...no light shows.

Also, given that the dimmers needed to control these light need to be 0-10 would you put all 6 on one dimmer or break them into 2 groups of 3? I understand that dimming these is more involved and they require 5 low voltage wires to each can.The current industry solution appears to be to use master/ slave control design for cans that are in series. Kachink kachink..wondering what the electrician will charge for all that extra wiring simply to dim the light?

For the record, Halo(Cooper Lighting) is IMPOSSIBLE to reach on their tech support line. Their customer service has little say. Retailers and wholesalers alike have no idea what to recommend and are less inclined to decipher their hodgepodge. They only sell the product..no one really knows what to use when and/or what is possible do beyond the minimum: having a light turn on. Even a pro from another dimmer company found it difficult to decipher let alone comprehend the details of the spec sheet.

Makes one wonder if they prefer it's lighting effects to be a carefully guarded secret. Please buy it and tell us how it works!

Must it be trial and error, buy and return to see what works? Hiring a lighting designer for such a small task seems ridiculous.

Okay product marketing and product management in light companies, time to revamp your collateral for today's customer....the tools are there, the customer awaits..where is our light show demo of your products? Not everyone is a lighting optics nerd.

Thanks in advance for sharing your LED gimbal trim can experience an

Comments (30)

  • 12 years ago
    Do you have a link to these specs? FWIW I don't think anybody really has a handle on these LEDs in that respect yet. With all the written information, it still comes down to some trial and error, and actual experience using them. If you are lighting framed art on a wall, it is always best to use 2 lights for each landscape and cross the beams, unless you intend to use inappropriately small pictures.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Starting with this link;

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/spec_sheets/halo-h4led-roundgimbal3000-adv131748-sss.pdf

    Horizontal beam spread means the light cast on a counter top, table, or floor.
    Vertical means light cast on a wall. You don't use both charts at the same time.
    The "30degree" picture next to the "0degree horizontal" chart is misleading, as evidenced by the equal length and width measurements on that chart. The length measurement is always the longer of the two measurements. The foot-candles are the more important part of the chart normally because that decreases exponentially as the distance from the light increases. The foot-candles are figured by the distance circled in the attached picture even though both charts list 'D' as 8 foot.
  • 12 years ago
    In the 30* vertical chart, 'L' is the vertical beam spread and 'W' is the horizontal beam spread when the light is tilted 30 degrees at the wall.
  • 12 years ago
    Maybe this is more complete
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I don't see where it says you need 5 low voltage wires to each can. The housing you show is standard 120 volt, and the driver/transformer is in the can and an integral part of the light. No more of a special dimmer or wiring is required than for any other LED.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks for the diagrams. I review them and get back with any questions. As for the dimmer, are you saying one can use a "normal" say Lutron Skylark dimmer? I understood that these needed a 0-10 low voltage dimmer that required special low voltage wiring to each can. I plan to have either three or six cans on one dimmer.
  • 12 years ago
    The HALO H4 LED luminaire is designed for dimming capability to 15% in normal operation with standard 120V LED-Rated, electronic low voltage, and many incandescent dimmers. The LED module may also dim to 5% using dimmers with low end trim adjustment. (Consult dimmer manufacturer for application/compatibility. Note, some dimmers require a neutral in the wallbox).

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/spec_sheets/halo-h455ricat120d-adv131969.pdf


    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/spec_sheets/halo-h455ricat120d-adv131969.pdf


    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/technical_specifications/Standard%20Dimming_111444.pdf
    .
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you...it's seems more research is needed to see which dimmer would be compatible.
    In reading the second link is it correct that you need one dimmer to one can? That's not going to work for me.
    What is a "low end trim adjustment"?
    Appreciate you sharing!
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    "In reading the second link is it correct that you need one dimmer to one can? That's not going to work for me." No, where did you get that impression? The third link should clear that up. The driver/transformer is on the junction box for each individual light. The wiring to each light is standard wiring. The dimmer can accommodate as many lights as the wattage or VA rating allows. Some dimmers actually work better with more lights since the wattage is so low on LEDs. The lutron skylark is on the list of compatible dimmers.

    What is a "low end trim adjustment"? It is the dial pictured on page 3
    http://www.lutron.com/TechnicalDocumentLibrary/CL%20Dimmer%20Sell%20Sheet.pdf
  • 12 years ago
    I think one of the first two links that are identical 3 posts above is supposed to be this;

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/lighting/products/recessed_general_purpose_downlighting/led/_4_inch_led_housings/_269374.html

    Notice that the picture of the housing and specifically the junction box is different than the one you posted originally.
  • 12 years ago
    H455RICAT120D
  • 12 years ago
    Hopefully, a more organized recap......
    Halo H4 LED Adjustable Gimbals, ELG406 series, combine an adjustable gimbal trim and LED light engine for use with H457 series housings. (LED driver is fixed in housing)
    The H457RICAT1E is an insulated ceiling, AIR-TITE™, remodel housing offering 120 volt dimming capability with electronic low voltage and many incandescent dimmers. (The "low voltage" here refers to the dimming of the "driver" which is essentially a low voltage transformer. 120 volts still goes through the dimmer and all the way up to the housing.)
    The H457 instruction sheet from; http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/lighting/products/recessed_general_purpose_downlighting/led/4-inch-led-housings-h4led-sys-2nd-gen/_853564.ssd.brands.lighting!halo!led.html

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/spec_sheets/halo-705782ins-h457ricat1e-adv131559-ins.pdf

    This says; The HALO H455RICAT120D LED luminaire can be dimmed with many standard 120V incandescent and electronic low voltage dimmers, however updates in dimmer technology and special conditions may apply depending on the dimmer type being used. To be assured of the latest information regarding luminaire and dimmer compatibility, please reference the latest HALO LED H455RICAT120D specification sheet found on the Halo Lighting web page on the Cooper Lighting website: www.HaloLtg.com or www.CooperLighting. com select Halo.

    That leads me to the list of dimmers here;

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/dam/public/lighting/products/documents/halo/technical_specifications/Standard%20Dimming_111444.pdf

    It says; Consult the dimmer manufacturer for compatibility including minimum and maximum circuit load and dimming performance characteristics. The minimum wattage load with ELV reverse phase control type dimmers can typically be lower than incandescent dimmers. Based upon the manufacturer, the ELV may allow the dimmer to control a single LED. Dimming is typically down to15%, and to 5% on dimmers with a low end trim.
    (Typically a dimmer can support 10-15 recessed LEDs. It is often the case that not enough wattage or number of LEDs are on a dimmer to make it work smoothly.) The minimum wattage load with INC/MLV forward phase control type dimmers may typically be higher than ELV type. Based upon the manufacturer, INC/MLV dimmers may require a load of four or more LEDs. Dimming is typically down to 15%, and to 5% on dimmers with a low end trim. (I am not convinced that dimming below 15% is necessary, but those type dimmers may yield better performance with only 3 lights per dimmer)

    That leads us to Lutron dimmers. The link shows a maximum of 150 watts ÷ 13w/light = 11 lights per dimmer. I have not found a minimum yet.

    http://www.lutron.com/TechnicalDocumentLibrary/CL%20Dimmer%20Sell%20Sheet.pdf

    These are what I would call a 'standard 120 volt dimmer' now days. The only difference is that they are now rated for CFL and LED lighting. The specs say a non-led rated dimmer will work in some circumstances. The problems would include not having enough lights on the switch and the lights not turning on properly if the switch is turned on in an extremely dimmed position. Some dimmers and light combinations have been known to cause humming and strobing of the lights. I know of no way to find the best dimmer other than trial and error, but most dimmers marked C-L should work.
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you so much for all this info. If I understand you correctly I can have an adjustable gimbal trim in the H4 led halo series with a remodel can. But the adjustable gimbal for the remodel can is somehow different because of the driver? The spec sheet list the item number as ELSG406 adj. gimbal light engine. I'm looking at the spec sheet for the H4 LED gimbal 2nd Generation and it mentions the remodel housing but lists the light engine as ELG406 with no mention of ELSG406. Halo certainly is difficult to work with.
  • 12 years ago
    Do you have the template for H4571RICAT1E ? The spec sheet shows the dimensions of the can height and width but only the length for the can, cable and box? I'd need to know the height and width of the "box". I checked online but couldn't locate it. Thank you so much!
  • 12 years ago
    I am not sure I understand what you are looking for. Also, do you have the link to the spec sheet you are referring to so I can see what you are looking at?
    ginnynichols thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    The rectangular "box" is connect to the can via the conduit. There are no dimensions listed for the "box".
  • 12 years ago
    "Ceiling opening to match template supplied with housing"
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    "Ceiling opening to match template supplied with housing" The size of the round hole you cut in the sheetrock? It may sound funny the way it is written, but 4.25" is the same as the template size. If you want to put your hands on one, any H45 remodel housing at a local home store will have the same physical body. It is just the internal wiring that will be different. Then you can measure the flimsy cardboard template while your there ;)
    ginnynichols thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    But is there any info on the width and height of the "box"? We are planning to have a SIP ceiling. It's now permitted to have recessed cans that are IC rated. However, the conduit needs to connect the can to the "box". Either can, conduit and "box" get installed in the SIP hole which is 4.25" in diameter OR the "box" gets installed on the OSB and the conduit connects the "box" to the can that is installed in the 4.25" SIP hole.
    Not easy to figure all this out. Thank you so much.
  • 12 years ago
    OK, I will look into the SIP thing a bit. There may be another option.
    The junction box is definitely no bigger than 5"×3.5"×1.75". Of course, you will need a bit more room to stuff all the extra wire into that you will need for slack to wire the fixture from below. You can also look at the H99 and H47 series remodel cans at the home center. The junction boxes should all be the same.
    ginnynichols thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    I am not finding any information that says a recessed can is able to be installed in an SIP. Do you have any links that show this that I can look at?
  • 12 years ago
    Looking for it....what experience do you have with surface mounted 2.5" LED lights? What kind of light, can it be aimed at the wall?
  • 12 years ago
    Is H99 the 2.5" surface mount? Does it tilt to make it a wall wash?
  • 12 years ago
    H99 is just another can with the exact same 'shell'. I haven't found any surface mount that tilt. All of this is new stuff, and there are so many products, that I wouldn't know for sure what you are talking about without a Link.
  • 12 years ago
    I did a lengthy search on LED surface mounts and there isn't alot that might work. I'm not sure there will be enough light emitted to light the wall. It's a promising idea though.
  • 12 years ago
    With SIPs, I assume the ceilings will be vaulted too. What is the slope/ pitch of the ceiling/ roof?
  • 12 years ago
    Low slope 1:12