Software
Houzz Logo Print
hz0523

Kitchen flooring

12 years ago
We just did a major remodel and I'm down to the floors. The layout is open end to end. Have picked out a laminate wood floor that I love for the floors, but can't decide if I should put tile in the kitchen or just run wood all the way through. Any thoughts?

Comments (25)

  • 12 years ago
    Do you want tile? When we renovated our kitchen, I wanted tile and spent hours looking for just the right one. I don't get that from you. If you aren't enthused about using tile, don't. Go with the laminate.
  • 12 years ago
    What a pretty kitchen! We recently remodelled our kitchen and went with a Mannington Laminate that looks like tile. So far I'm loving the fact that it's easy to keep clean and doesn't show dirt and doggy fur. :)
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Thank you, I like it both ways, but have spent months looking for just the right tile and can not find what I like. My contractor (who has given me excellent advice on everything) would like to see it split up, but I just can't seem to find what I like in a tile. I don't like the "busy" look and don't want to go with anything too plain. This remodel has been held up long enough waiting on my floor decision.
  • 12 years ago
    Very nice Anne. I've been looking at those floors. Dirt and doggy hair is a big issue in this household as well. How has it held up for you i.e. scratches, chips etc.
  • 12 years ago
    Since you haven't found anything you like in tile, I would say it isn't for you. When I found the tile I wanted, it was virtually love at first sight--and I still absolutely love it!
    hz0523 thanked hayleydaniels
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I don't recommend laminate for kitchen floors as a little spilt water or liquid can cause it to warp if not cleaned up in time. Tile, especially porcelain tile, is extremely durable. The complaints people have of tile is that it is 1. Cold, 2. Hard on their joints, 3. Anything that falls on it, shatters and 4. difficult to clean the grout lines. A compromise is Armstrong Alterna which is a vinyl tile that looks just like stone or ceramic tile but it is made of vinyl so it is warm, easy on the joints, and the special latex grout is easy to keep clean. Also because it has a small amount of flex to it, things dropped on it may survive the impact.
  • 12 years ago
    While I know that laminate is a risky choice for kitchens, I have had no warping issues with it in this or previous kitchens. hz0523, while this installation has only been down for 3-4 months, I have not experienced any scratching or chips, unlike I had found to be the case with wood laminates. FWIW my dog is 55 lbs.
  • 12 years ago
    Btw, I looked at luxury vinyl tile products too (which have varying reviews) and found that I was able to scratch it quite easily with a key. Yep--I tested, and scratched/gouged the samples.
  • 12 years ago
    This is the tile floor I was talking about.
  • 12 years ago
    I've also had wood flooring in one of my other kitchens. It was a beautiful walnut but I love this tile floor equally. You have dark cabinets so if you choose wood just be careful with the stain you select. I personally would not put a laminate floor in my kitchen.
  • 12 years ago
    Gail, One of my concerns with a light tile was light grout, but this looks beautiful with dark grout. Thank you
  • 12 years ago
    Why don't you just buy tile with a wood print, these also come in different prints/colours.
  • 12 years ago
    Just another photo so you can get a better sense. If you do go with tile, I think this would look great in your kitchen! Flooring is so difficult sometimes. I just recently selected Italian ceramic flooring, very light.. sort of looks like linen, for my beach house & was so nervous about it, but it's beautiful & whenever someone comes in the house they immediately comment how gorgeous it is! Keep us informed about your final selection & post a pic!
  • 12 years ago
    Is the laminate in your 3rd pic? Sort of a grey? If so, it looks great. It also looks easy to take care of. I would go with that. I wouldn't, however, go with the light tile - way too hard to keep looking good.
  • 12 years ago
    Go with a travertine tile, can go wrong there. Looks of pretty colors from natural stone.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Go with tile. Laminate and water do NOT mix and that could be a big issue in a kitchen. Your scratch test on that luxury vinyl isn't a fair test. Unless someone is has ice skates on your floor you won't have that sharp of an edge run across it. We have had a luxury vinyl in our showroom (kids play area) for almost 5 yrs. Not a single scratch. But overall durablilty go with tile. Travertine is nice but has its own issues with care. Daltile has this really pretty porcelain in a vein cut look called San Michelle that would work nicely there.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Travertine or a porcelain tile would be an excellent choice for the kitchen and add a nice contrast with your dark cabinetry . Go for the 12 x 24 format if you want to bring a contemporary flair or stick with 20 x 20s for a more traditional look. If you went with the travertine on the floor ... I would carry the travertine on the backsplash in a 3 x 6 subway format and maybe add a strip of glass or accent dots.

    We agree that laminate in the kitchen would most likely not be a lasting choice. Have you also considered porcelain wood tile? You get the benefits of a tile with the look of wood. There are some great wood tile options out there these days.

    Best of Luck!

    www.northcountytileandstone.com
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Laminates are not a product for kitchens...but many people do it. Some have regrets when the ice maker overfloweth or the dishwasher steam causes bubbling. If you are having a hard time deciding and you feel you are holding up the renovation, then go with the laminate and BUY EXTRA. Like 200sf extra! That way, if you have an issue you can rip out the damaged area and replace with same product. THEN you can take your time to find/finance a new floor in a year or so after the damage occurred.

    You can have the floor you like for now and if something goes wrong you will have enough to "fix it" AND give yourself some more time to search out the perfect solution. Yes, you will pay for the floor 2.5 times...but you can continue with your renovation right now.

    The best option would be to find the appropriate floor (tile, stone, vinyl, lino, cork, etc) for the kitchen and purchase the kitchen floor ONCE. That is ideal. If you feel like you can't do that right now, then go for option #2 = buy enough laminate to cover your kitchen twice (200sf extra should do it) so that you are ready should anything occur. Not ideal but it will move your project along. Option #2 is far more expensive...and that's why it is option #2.
    hz0523 thanked Cancork Floor Inc.
  • 12 years ago
    Why not hardwood?
  • 12 years ago
    pickyvicky we have a farm and 3 dogs that are inside dogs
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    inabunker in the 3rd pic that is actually the laminate wood we're considering. Pictures never do color justice. It's a hickory look. In the second on that is a LVT that has a slate tile look.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I would never rule out a laminate. If you purchase a product developed from a major manufacturers such as Shaw, Quickstep, Mohawk, Alloc or Formica brand you will have a bit of a "quality insurance policy." The locking system on most major brands (unilin is the number one) will insure a superior join lock. If you need to beat the heck out of a laminate to get it together you should avoid it completely. The problem most homeowners run into is that they find the cheapest laminate out there which means the joint integrity/quality is compromised as well as the core quality. Keep in mind that if your dishwasher leaks and goes to your subfloor any flooring medium could be compromised. At this point it becomes an insurance issue not a product issue. The manufacturer claims that come through my store for laminate are 99 percent installation (home owner install) or cleaning related. Someone mentioned a LVP (Luxury Vinyl Plank) which would also be a great option. When shopping these materials it is important to find one that does not use recycled materials and has a fiberglass scrim imbedded in the core for stability. Manufacturers to entertain would be: Engage, Karndean or Beaulieu. It seems the mass floor retailer oversell all these products as being "indestructible". That is a false statement. Keep in mind that everything can scratch including concrete. Preventative measures such as placing felt pads underneath every leg of furniture you own, follow manufacturers cleaning directions and follow install directions to the letter. All of the above will help you will enjoy your floor for years to come. Good luck to you and you did good!
    hz0523 thanked Completely Floored
  • 12 years ago
    The laminate we are considering is a quality floor (not from a box store ie. lowes hd) and I was told it has one of the best locking systems out there. Will be professionally installed. I'm not big on the lvt idea. Have heard way to many complaints about that even the top quality brands. My biggest concern is we will have a lot of wood and I'm concerned it will be too much and take away from the landing at the bar top. The steps will be wood and there will be a wood rail w/ cast iron framing out the landing.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the contrast of the tile (real, LVT or laminate) in the kitchen with all your dark stained cabinets.