Software
Houzz Logo Print
nebraskafarmhouse

Keep this layout or change it?

12 years ago
We've just started planning for a potential remodel to the mail level of our house. The main issues we have are with the bedroom and bathroom. We don't have enough closet space, and the bathroom isn't very functional and needs to be updated. In addition, the "study" was formerly a bedroom that a previous owner opened up to the living room and added a fireplace. Now I feel like the hallway is wasted square footage.

I'm wondering if I should try to stick with the current layout or if it's worth the investment to change the floor plan. We plan to live in the house for 5-10 more years so we're thinking of our own needs and future resale. If it makes a difference, we are in a rural setting.

I've played with the floor plan a little and attached what I've come up with. The powder room is not a necessary addition, but it would be nice to not share our bathroom with guests.

Comments (5)

  • 12 years ago
    I definitely would add the powder room so guests are not using your private bath. People will notice that in future resale. I would suggest swapping the positions of the sink and the toilet in it, so that when the door is open you view the sink from the hall, not a direct shot of the toilet.
  • 12 years ago
    I like what you are considering doing. I think the his and hers walk in closets will help sell the place, as will the powder room. Making the master bath a true, private master bath is a good idea. Both changes should add to your enjoyment of the space as well. The closets are a bit small. I'd play with the layout to be certain they will be worth the extra depth (that it will be usable) as planned. Typically to use two sides of a space it needs to be six feet wide. Also, is this the only tub in your house? If there is another you might consider a double vanity where the tub is and a shower where the sink is at so two can use it at the same time if you don't use the tub.
  • 12 years ago
    Looking at it again, getting rid of the closet in the study might actually throw off the symmetry of the fire place. I realize you were squaring off the room, but you might want to consider adding the space of both original closets to the master closet. Or make certain the room will look ok with the fireplace slightly off center.
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you both for your suggestions.

    @rocketjcat
    I do not think there would be room to for the toilet if we swapped it with the vanity. I agree that I don't like the toilet being the first thing you see, but I don't know of another way to arrange it.

    @jh77
    The closet depth is being determined by the existing wall on the top side (as drawn) and the load bearing wall on the bottom side. For the left closet, I was planning to have hanging storage one one side and shelves on the other side. We have this in our shallow closet now, so I'm hoping it would be adequate space in the new plan? And yes, this is the only tub in the house. I'd prefer a shower only, but I don't want to get rid of the only tub.
  • 12 years ago
    @jh77
    You're observant! I've worried about the same thing with the fireplace. We haven't consulted with a professional yet, but our concern is that wall between the closets is at least partially load bearing. We're not sure how this is set up since neither wall lines up with the load bearing wall that runs down the center of the house. That's why my design shows adding a continuation of the load bearing wall all the way down the center of the house. If we did this, I considered adding some built in shelving or desk to make up for the fireplace not being centered anymore.