I agree that it is too large

I agree about the size as well. I would go with 2-3 mini pendants with colored glass shades. Another option that would work: a diy fixture with repurposed kitchen objects to add a color and whimsy.

Agree, your instincts were right. You may be able to get a smaller one that looks similar but go with a different finish. Check out this link for other ideas: http://www.potterybarn.com/shop/lighting/pendants/?cm_type=lnav

I agree, wrong finish and way too big. I still think you could use a long linear light fixture without the girth. Here's a couple from Joss and Main.

It's not the size as much as the overall visual impact. Even though it is clear glass this is a very visually heavy fixture. An open metal work chandelier may work better for your space. If you want to stick with the lantern style, two smaller pendants may be nice.
[houzz=]
[houzz=]
[houzz=]
[houzz=]
[houzz=]

I was wondering since all are in agreement the light is way too large, would changing the table and chairs to more industrial help because the light is non returnable?

Yes. I was going to suggest that. I like your table but don't feel it fits well with your new kitchen or gray walls.

Sell it on Craig's list or eBay.it doesn't do justice to your lovely kitchen.

I agree with all that has been said. This chandelier does not work. But I do love it that you are trying to combine styles.

Yup. Too big, regardless of your intended style. I like your counter stools and, if you are considering more changes, a new light fixture, table and chairs leaning a little toward that direction would give a great new look to your kitchen.

A large rectangular weathered gray or taupe table would work with that fixture. I think something like the table posted by retroearth (House at Windy Hill) in a much lighter finish would work. You could even do high back wing chairs at the ends of the new table to balance out the size of your light.

As much as I agree with getting a new table, I am not sure there is enough room to get a large enough table and still have the light centered?

Would this table and similar chairs go in this space better?

Yes, but jojo- it there enough room to center a large table like this plus add the large chair at each end? I think you will be up against the cabinet?

You may have to go to a large square table?

I wouldn't get much bigger than the table you have now. I like the table you posted but think it may be heavy on the industrial look. I think the table needs to be simple with the light fixture.

Well, the table and chairs could definitely be more modern, but it's the bulk of the glass on that fixture that make it too big -- I honestly think it's designed for a much much larger space (ceiling height as well as area), so just changing the table style won't help. I'd try to sell the light and replace it, whatever you do about the table. Get something that's long but not so tall. Sorry. :(

As all have said above, the scale and color are off. The table and chairs are a good size and go well, but may I suggest refinishing them (leaving the top of the table dark)? I feel the current color is taking away from the beauty of the rest of the kitchen.

As a rule of thumb I always try to match the lighting over the table with the shape of the table. Your current fixture would work if it was a more rectangular and wider table. For your circular table I would either do a square or round fixture. A simple stainless steel finish chandelier would bring out your fixtures and hardware, and also add repetition to the space. Another option would be to go a bit industrial, like your bar stools. This reclaimed wood light would pull those two element together.

Get out the tape measure and painter's tape. You need 36-42" between the table and walls or any furniture on the walls or that masquerades as a wall/barrier. Move your current stuff out of the way and do some calculating and taping on the floor to get a visual on what size table the space can handle. Consider turning the light the other direction if necessary to get a large enough table in the space. You may have to ditch the stools at the island.

I am still desperately trying to find a solution to keep the light. It was a custom order and weighs 73 pounds so it was a bear to hang!!!! My current table is 60"wide by 85" long so a more industrial table would suit the area better. Any one think I could find a way to keep the light?

This is the view from the family room into the kitchen so area is an open concept and lots of room around the table.

Can you remove the large frame and glass, while leaving the inside arms with bulbs, then refinish it? Or someone local can make smaller frame, and get new glass? The large frame and glass panels seem like most of the issue.

I do think you can keep the light. Maybe one of the houzz photo shop experts could put a different table in for you. I was thinking of a look similar to this. Different side chairs and a table where you could tuck the chairs under. I would use the industrial look for accents. I think the table you posted may be too much with your traditional kitchen.

I would take decoenthusiates advice about taping out the area to see how large of a table you can fit.

I would not spend any more money trying to make this light work in your room. Sell it and buy a different one that compliments your kitchen decor. If you don't, this light will continue to be a thorn in your side.

If you keep the fixture I would think about rotating it and the (new) table 90 degrees. It appears in your 2nd picture that the end chair and rug 'hang off' the dining space delineated by the lower ceiling? Is that correct or just the angle of the picture? Maybe I'm just weird, but that would be very disconcerting or off balance to me, especially if I was seated in that end chair.

linlac, I love the photo of the table you sent and will take your advice to ask a photo shop table to see if that will make a difference. I have plenty of space around the table, 56", 58" and 9 feet. The other end opens to an added family room and there is 22 feet there. I am sending a picture of the old light in there and it was fairly large, 34 wide by 41" tall light before. I just wanted something new and more update. I still don't know what went terribly wrong as I think I have the space.

I think this fixture will go well with a rectangular table and - above all- other chairs. The mismatch between your diningset and fixture draws the attention because of the two completely different styles( shape and colour). Something that leans more towards your counterstools will make your room look better. You might even keep your current table.

Jojotennis, did you make a decision yet?

I am headed out today to look for a new table and chairs. I will take pictures with me and see if they agree the light work and if not I will try selling the light on Craig's list. I already have a buyer for the table and chairs!

That's totally the wrong approach. The light is way too big and not very attractive. Getting a new table to match bad choice light makes no sense.

I would try to go for a bronze fixture. Since you mentioned you can't return then try to see if you can paint it or have someone do it because I personally wouldn't want to get rid of table and get something industrialized looking. Hope it works out

Keep the dining table and chairs... They look lovely in your space. It's the new light fixture that must go!

What about having a giant island installed instead of a table? I like the fixture and would want to keep it too!

Everything if off about it. Your kitchen is beautiful.

Agree that the light should go. Even if you get a new table and chairs, the scale of the existing table is just right for your space- I would not get something much bigger. So you would still have an oversized fixture that doesn't work in your kitchen.

You have a beautiful kitchen. I would heed some of the above recommendations for swapping out the fixture to better suit your decor and space.

Larger chairs and larger rug may balance the dimensions!

Sorry but the light fixture itself has unattractive proportions (too tall for its width) and I don't think it will look good even if a larger table is under it. You don't have an industrial look in your home and that's another reason it draws the eye, not in a good way. Sell it and move on. If you replace the table you're throwing good money after bad.

Jojo, If you like the lamp, can you take the glass shade off? You can then see if it fits the area of the table better. You might be able to find a smaller glass shade for it or have one made.

Ur barstools are industrial, if u LOVE the light then keep it and make changes around that. Get ur barstools to same color as light, get industrial style chairs for table. Maybe give the table a face lift! The light is big but its surroundings can be bigger to balance. Larger rug and more industrial surroundings

You have a stainless steel fridge; change rug to a gray as well!

The light fixture is nice, just not over that table. I would also suggest raising it a notch.

The glass is overpowering and draws the eye. It detracts from your gorgeous space.