Software
Houzz Logo Print
krphoto

My Bonsai trees are almost dead

21 years ago

I have two Bonsai trees. I got them from the flea market. They may be dead. How can I tell if they are dead already? It looks like they need to be soaked in water. What is the right amount of fish emulsion to mix with water for soaking? Please click the images to enlarge for more detail.

color=maroon>


{{gwi:14634}}Â

color=maroon>


{{gwi:14636}}Â

color=maroon>


{{gwi:14638}}Â

Comments (2)

  • 21 years ago

    Hi, what a sad sight.. they are gone, but it might not be anything you did (except maybe to buy them from a flea mkt). They look to be pine trees, and they don't usually look that bad until they've already been goners a long time, which means unless you've had them a long time, they were probably already gone when you got them, and just didn't show it yet. This is the problem with bonsai... you kind of have to know something about them before you buy, because they require at least some basic knowledge right away just to keep them alive, and also require that the sellers be knowledgable - and I think they probably weren't - not a crime, but I hope you didn't pay a lot. Please don't get discouraged from bonsai, but hang on to your money for now, and start off by first reading as much as you can about them, about growing things in general, and trees, and learn what to look for when buying (a much better bet would be inexpensive nursery trees, 3-5 yrs old, in 1 gal. pots - not 'bonsai', but good learning material that you can afford to lose a couple of). This time of year is bad for doing anything to trees though, unless you just get 1-2 and leave them on your balcony (unless they're tropicals) til early next spring - no pruning, repotting or anything - by which time you'll have gotten a lot of reading done, and hopefully have found a local bonsai club to learn from by watching and doing. You have to know how to care for the trees you buy, whether they're appropriate for your environment (indoors or out and how much light, etc.), and all about soil 'recipes', and how to water (they're not house plants) and which ones to let dry before doing it, etc. etc. Don't fuss about the old ones now, everyone here has lost any number of trees while learning, and patience is also a good place to start.

  • 21 years ago

    Hi, Just thought I'd also mention that fish emulsion is only one of many things that might occasionally be used on an occasional tree, but it's not really necessary or important in general. And BTW, pine trees (and other types) can look thirsty (brown and dry) when they've actually been watered too often, or when they've got a neglected case of spider mites, or other diseases, and when to water which tree in which season is a huge 'subject' in bonsai that can take a long time to 'get' because there are so many things to take into account at any time, so you really need to know about care for each type of tree in diff. climates, etc.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting