Software
Houzz Logo Print
qwade

Literati/Bunjin Style

12 years ago

Does anyone have any experience in this style bonsai? I have an idea I would like to try. I would be styling as is common with the literati style to have a plant with very little foliage.

My first question is the procedure.Is all the foliage removed at once? Or, is this done in steps?

The material is going to be a hinoki cypress (Chamaecyparis Obtusa), a young nursery plant. 'Chirimin' is the cultivar.

Comments (12)

  • 12 years ago

    I think you'd be safer doing it in steps, but a picture of the tree would be so helpful, along with your highlighted cut marks...

    Just a personal note... I love hinoki and I'm not sure I'd want to hack it all off to make a literati, but then a picture might change my mind.

  • 12 years ago

    Here is the hinoki. Too much foliage to show you the cuts but ill try to draw a sketch on the computer.

  • 12 years ago

    crude sketch. I am going to select three branches wire and bend into this basic shape. probably be more bends than on the sketch. The foliage will point up right and down as pictured in the sketch. The cultivar here 'chimirin' refers to the foilage chirimin in japan is a fine fabric . I plan to prune into shape shown. The branching is very flexible. I plan to highlight the nice brown bark of the hinoki eventually it will age and even look nicer. Im thinking I shouldn't remove all the foliage at once. I may get another tree similar to the one above. The grower had 3.That way I can have one to grow normally. Its an interesting tree as is.

  • 12 years ago

    When you remove all foliage so fast you seriously impair a tree's ability to thrive and use photosynthesis. Why the rush? I mean I can understand, but if you don't have patience, maybe bonsai isn't for you.

  • 12 years ago

    Duplicated

    This post was edited by moochinka on Mon, Oct 20, 14 at 0:21

  • 12 years ago

    I understand Bonsai is not something you can rush.
    No I am in no rush. I was just asking the procedure. I said in my above post that I don't think I should remove all the foliage at once.Photosynthesis was absolutely my main concern. This is , I think the challenge of the literati style.Keeping the tree alive with such little foliage. A tree grasping for life is the look this style invokes. I was just looking for input to confirm this. The advantage i would have is that it would be easier to wire not immediate gratification.
    My other thought is to leave sacrificial branches and strip the branches I am using.. I am not sure if this would work , So this is the input I am looking for.
    No I have a lot of patience and bonsai is for me.

  • 12 years ago

    Great! The idea of sacrifice branches is good, and will help the line of the trunk of course... and I imagine it wouldn't hurt in terms of having the foliage there... don't know if anyone's ever addressed it.

  • 12 years ago

    I agree...removing the desired foliage at one time might not be a wise move. But, I too enjoy literati/bunjin styled trees. There is a book coming in print on literati styling. Have it preordered from Amazon.

  • 12 years ago

    The literati style is more of a way of bringing out the expression of great age and struggle against the elements. It usually breaks many of the 'rules' we learned about building balance and harmony in our trees, yet seems to achieve its own individual sense of balance in its asymmetry. More often than not, there is a minimal amount of taper in bunjin trees.

    Unless you layer your tree just below where the branching starts, it will be a challenge as a triple trunk bunjin because of how high above the soil line the branches start. The job of building a believable tree would be much easier if the 3 trunks you have planned divided right at the soil line. Also, it appears you have no movement in the trunk line for the first several inches immediately above the soil line to where the branching begins. This would not be typical of a tree in nature that someone might emulate as a bunjin style tree.

    I find that in most cases, when a tree's owner isn't sure about what to do with a tree, it usually ends up a "windswept" or a "bunjin". That's not a backhanded remark about you or your tree. I just think your tree might better be guided toward something other than a bunjin.

    Al

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks Al ---now where getting somewhere.My next question was going to be.Can I pull off the triple trunk form as a bunjin? Most I see are single trunk.By your answer I take it that it would be acceptable. I also contemplated the straight trunk long before you read this post and see the problems. My solution was to somehow tilt the trunk out of the pot keeping it close to the soil line and twisting the more flexible branch above as my main branch, the one to the left in my sketch.Now that may be a little optimistic but I kick it around in my head.

    My other problem with this tree is pruning the foliage. Hinoki's especially this cultiver have a mind of there own. Pruning to the shape I want on the top may prove difficult. I'm currently experimenting with pruning this tree.
    My third question would be if anyone had experience pruning this type of foliage.Its tight,extremely small and dwarf growing. As you can see the tops grow straight up.Lower on the branch round balls of foliage occur naturally, more in line with what i want.
    As far as my reason for choosing this style for this tree. The natural twisting of the branching gave me the idea. The branching is very flexible and i really want more twisting of the trunks than my sketch shows. I actually bought it for a garden tree and it may end up that way or in a pot growing naturally anyway.
    Feel free to call me on not knowing what to do with a tree as i am usually in that camp. I usually work backwards in this regard.Obtain tree and then figure out what to do with i .I am impulsive.
    Anyway I will wait for any further feedback and contemplate some more before making a decision. I will keep my eyes open for other trees that fit this form.

  • 12 years ago

    Don't know if you've ever worked with Hinoki, but apart from it's being very slow growing, you don't 'prune' it like you would a deciduous tree, but pinch out growing buds and/or growing twigs off major branches. You don't want to 'cut' anything. And you already have a thick trunk, which as Al said, will be rather straight, so I suppose you could try using a jack to bend it, but that could also be a problem... and the bark is so nice on that tree.

  • 12 years ago

    Bending would be a good option. I thought of using heavy wire but a jack would work better. the trunk caliper is slightly bigger than a pencil. I would need the right equipment/jack or make some sort of home made device. one small enough to work in the 4" I have to work with.Not much experience with jacks. . Will research.
    Al had mentioned layering. I never considered that option.Got me thinking.
    Question--- Can I cut the bark and cambium and just sink the tree deeper in the pot? Or must I do an air layer where the tree sits now?
    Anyway, contemplating my options.
    Thanks for all the input and keep it coming.
    May start a new thread with another tree. I always like input

Sponsored