Software
Houzz Logo Print
lexer_gw

New Garden, seeking hedge/screen advice

17 years ago

Hello,

IÂm writing to ask for advice on hedge/screen choices:

I have 177 linear feet to screen off to create privacy, enclosure, and a back layer of beds. This is most of the periphery of my 60 x 75 back yard. I donÂt want to do one solid hedge. I want height variation between 6' and 12-15'. I am zone 8. Exposure is: sun to dappled shade, one 20 section of dry shade. Style of the yard: roughly English garden  curving paths, perennial beds, some clipped box and other formal shapes in beds and as short hedges. Little or no lawn, vegetable garden on one side.

Picture of the yard as is:

http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=204375&l=46c88&id=734645244

I would like it to be generally a dark to medium background, so it will recede visually. I am thinking both evergreen and deciduous. Needs to be pretty narrow so that I donÂt loose my yard to it. If space were not an issue I might do informal everywhere but I think I will need to do some areas of clipped hedge to save space.

In some areas I would like to use a two-layered approach with one layer of plants close to the fence and then a second layer of plants here an there that starts to blend into the bed and to allow for points of interest, color combinations, height variation etc. I have also thought of incorporating an arch or two into the second layer, to allow for a shady seat and to give a sense of depth.

Budget is a consideration and I expect to be buying the plants small. So, I have been looking mostly at the faster growing things knowing that this means a lot of maintenance forever. I will likely buy a few larger plants this winter/spring so that I can get a jump on a couple of crucial areas.

I have a list of plants that I need to narrow down and also if thereÂs anything better I would be glad to hear it.

Also, I donÂt want to create chaos with too many kinds of hedge/screen. How many different types or sections do you think could work in a yard this size?

For sheared areas of formal hedging:

Arborvitae emerald green pyramidal (or techny or wintergreen)

illex - holly

Hemlock

Hornbeam

Beech

Privet

Myrtle

Western red cedar

For pruned but not formal hedge areas:

Viburnum, American Cranberrybush or Nannyberry or Pragense or onondaga

Osmanthus Delvayi

Elaegnus Ebbingei

Lonicera Nitidia

Escallonia

Euonymous

For second layer, blending into beds:

Sambucus  Sutherland gold

Sambucus  Black Lace

Camellia

smokebush

Evergreen dogwood

Sumac

Japanese maple

Amur maple

Redbud

Star magnolia

Butterfly bush

Lilac

Siberian peashrub

Winterberry

Crabapple

Laburnum  goldenchain tree

Hazelnut

Forsythia

Golden Privet

Advice? I'd appreciate it.

Thanks!

Lex

Comment (1)

  • 17 years ago

    Lex: while photos are extremely helpful to us in visualizing the situation, the one you provided is not doing your garden justice - it's a bit too small and the panorama effect distorts the perspective. Is it possible for you repost with individual photos of the garden areas rather than a panoramic composite? And a quick plan sketch with some measurements would be equally helpful.

    Beyond this, suggestions will be unfortunately vague :-) Depth of available planting areas will determine to a large extent what can be used successfully for screening as well as layering.......and if this is your intent, it is best to err on the side of generosity.

    And some quick thoughts on plant selection. It's impossible to see from the photo provided where formalized, sheared hedging may be appropriate. Arborvitaes are ideal for taller formal hedges and pruning or shearing is optional, as many (like the Emerald Green) are by habit narrow and columnar. For shorter hedges, box or Japanese holly are popular and for good reason, but germander, rosemary, even lavender could work in the right situation. Formalized hedges require ongoing routine maintenance to keep them looking sharp, so keep that in mind when making your plant choices - don't select a shrub or tree that naturally wants to grow to 20+ feet when all you are looking for is an 8' hedge.......too much work involved :-)

    Otherwise, an informal screening as a backdrop for lower plantings is relatively easy to achieve, provided the depth of the planting bed is suitable. A mix of evergreen shrubs/small trees and deciduous plants will accomplish this, with the weight placed on the evergreens. Your second group of listed plants could comprise the bulk of this, but I might consider replacing the viburnum choices with the evergreen V. tinus and adding Choisya ternata, camellia or smaller selections of Hinoki cypress.

    I am personally very fond of fastigiate hornbeams for deciduous screening purposes and use them often in designs. Their very upright and dense branching structure makes them pretty effective for this purpose even out of leaf. Carpinus betulus 'Frans Fontaine' is my cultivar of choice.

    And some of your listed plants are just not well advised for your area or for the purpose you have in mind. Butterfly bush is a listed Oregon invasive plant, redbuds tend to be rather short-lived in the NW, sumac suckers aggressively and over a wide distance and privet has a host of issues that make it a less than wonderful choice.

    Hope this will be a start to get you thinking. And come back to us with more photos if you can.