Software
Houzz Logo Print
kurtg_gw

landscape or house issue?

20 years ago

We are buying this home, notwithstanding what we feel is a certain lack of curb appeal to the front appearance.

My wife and I thought it needed a different color paint, but my sister had suggested it was the landscaping. Perhaps it is need of updating both.

Reactions here on the curb appeal, is it a house issue or a landscaping one, or both?

Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:38960}}

Comments (34)

  • 20 years ago

    I think this house could be improved considerably with some good landscaping. The house is not unattractive, and I don't even mind the color. If you buy and repaint, I'd keep to a color that blends the house into the wooded lot, nothing too bright. The only part of the house that doesn't look right to me is the left side with the blank wall between the windows, which could be camoflaged with some plantings.

  • 20 years ago

    As much as brown is my favorite color, really !!! brown is my favorite color, I can only agree that both paint and landscaping would help in the curb appeal of this house.

    W/O knowing more than the limited note and one picture, deciding what color and what lanscape to add to the house making any suggestions can only lead you into a real headache.

    My first thought would be to trim the shrubs. They're too unkept making the front unattractive.

    Would I make a small wall to the left of the walk allowing the basement windows to appear more open rather than looking like one is trying to hide them.

    It looks like a Smoke Bush / tree to the right front. This plant seems to command more attention than anything else. Might want to trim it back or give it a better shape.

    House color - tough decision here. The current "brown" color is too chocolate looking. A beige w/ a darker trim would open up the appeal.

    Again, the limited information / picture makes it too limited for my thought or design prowess to kick in and make any real positive suggestions.

    Jake

  • 20 years ago

    I don't like the color, myself, but I still have to say that landscaping would do wonders, and that lack of landscaping is what detracts from the curb appeal. And I don't think it would be horribly expensive or elaborate. You've got a really nice setting and the layout of the walk really lends itself to planting. It appears to be nicely laid out and carves up the yard pleasantly.

    As far as paint, I think it might be good to paint the lower level on the left the same color or even darker than the main level--it looks sort of floaty. I might prefer the window trim less bright against the muted house color.

    I think sister is right though! Looks like a fun project, especially since it'll make such a difference.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks for the quick reactions so far. I can appreciate that we need better pictures for more complete advice on the issue. However, I was just looking for gut reactions to see where the issues fit in relation to each other.

    I guess rather than quickly slap on a new coat of paint when we move in to solve our curb appeal reactions, we'll have to take a step back and look at this in a more holistic sense considering the landscape too. I don't want to end up needlessly painting a second time after coming up with a new landscape design.

    We knew this place needs landscape help and plan to do so, but didn't have an adverse reaction as we thought we did with the color.

  • 20 years ago

    It is the light colored shingles and the clunky roof cut-out over the entryway that are causing most of the visual problems.

    IronBelly

  • 20 years ago

    Although there are lots of strong opinions about software and photoshopping stuff, this is one case in which it might help. If you are able to plug your house photo into one of those paint programs (often offered on-line by the commercial paint co's, you could have some fun trying different colors, instantly combining top, bottom, trim--even shingles--and see the effect. Maybe there are colors you think you prefer but the shingles drive you in a specific direction to look best overall. Then kind of imagine how plantings would co-exist. Precise color choices are quite personal, but you could get some idea of whether you will use color to "ground" the house vs. plantings vs. both, and also can be driving around or looking at photos and thinking if you have some favorite shrubs/trees, as in, are you going to have a lot of green, or want a house color against which purple shrubs would be displayed, or fall reds and yellows, or are determined to plant pink Wave petunias in summer-- whatever.

    My library has some books on coordinating exterior paint with landscaping and while I think many people have done quite well just avoiding the worst clashing colors, and don't have to rigidly use only flowers and shrubs that "go" perfectly with a given house paint, these books do give show some good combinations that may help you find your "AHA!" moment.

  • 20 years ago

    frankie, any info on the books you mention?

  • 20 years ago

    We did photoshop some colors and were focussed on paint color so didn't try visualizing any landscape changes. Shades of a blue/gray and light tan/adobe looked best with the roof and architecture, but we weren't thinking about landscaping also.

    I thought we'd need to be there a bit to get some bearings on the yard and how we'd use it before undertaking any landscape plans.

    I do know there is some tree clean-up to be done and there is excessive shade and poor previous yard maintenance that has resulted in a sparse cover with some erosion in the back and we have two dogs and two kids, so must start there before it is a mudpit.

    Our initial plan was to paint the house and start in the back dealing with the trees that need work, but wanted to see if anyone else was drawn to the front landscape over the color, since we weren't.

  • 20 years ago

    If it were mine, Id skip the paint this season, maybe think about the color till next spring. Id take the money and pop out some perennial beds. For instance I'd cluster big pots of different sizes and shapes of Astilby, Ferns and Hostas around part of the tree. Id pop out a bed along the path that sort of connects the area between the path and the house. (like filling between cake layers.) I would make sure that the stuff had a variety of textures and hights, but not to tall, or densly planted, and stay along the lines of traditional, leaning into the lovely woodland thing going on. I think Id look at some Hydrangias in the curves of the path, tapering out to a planting with lower hight with more ferns, acanthas, maybe some Esther reed daisys in any sunnier ends of the bed, and some things like columbine and bleeding heart, (the native, long blooming type,) for color and intrest. Maybe some asterantia. I have all of the above in a garden under a tree canopy with dappled light so know they will work. (except the astilby, but evry one else has it,) I think Id stay away from the ubiquitious "grasses" except maybe zebra or mondo, also no coryopsis Just some thoughts, it looks like a terrific sight to me. good luck

  • 20 years ago

    Nothing new here, but I'll add my suggestions anyway.

    1) Paint the foundation to match the siding. The white foundation draws attention to it, which I think should be avoided. Brown siding is not my favorite color, nor is it so offensive that I think you need to immediately spend money on new paint. In a wooded setting, brown can work very well. I suggest that you live with it for awhile.

    2) Add some evergreen foundation shrubs along the left side to distract the eye from that downslope. Select plants considering their mature size, so they don't cover the windows and don't need frequent pruning.

    3) When you make your front yard plan, you may want to select more attractive shrubs than the green ones located to the right of your front door. Meanwhile, they just need a good pruning. At some point, you may want to consider removing the grass between the curved path and your house. I'm referring to the path bordering the right front of your house and leading to the front door. Why mow that little patch, when you could grow layers of plants there or use a ground cover that doesn't require mowing?

    My compliments to the person who laid that path and had the good sense to curve it and give you more than a stingy 2-3 foot planting bed along the right front of your house. With the depth I see there, you will have lots of options for attractive plantings.

    What is that white pipe in the lawn? A septic vent pipe? If it is a public utility pipe, are you required to keep it white? If not, I suggest painting it a more earthy color that will be less conspicuous. Shades of muddy brown, gray, dull green or black may work.

    I agree with Ironbelly's comment about the roof color. It looks fairly new, so you'll probably need to live with it for awhile.

    Congrats on finding a new home in a wooded setting. Enjoy!

  • 20 years ago

    Can I assume that, as "curb appeal" is the major concern, you intend to shift this house on in the near future? This is a different question than most people would be asking of a house they are just about to move in to.

  • 20 years ago

    I cannot remember any exact titles now! Also Barnes & Noble had something newer. Some color-coordinating author-person(s) with lots of photos of homes and surrounding gardens/landscaping, " earthtone-color house looks good with ....; yellow looks good with everything; cool blues look....; umm, green houses can really pop with....---you get the picture.

  • 20 years ago

    Nice house, actually, except the colors are reversed. The brown is a "grounded" color, so although not a bad choice, it's floating atop the white-painted lower level. Wrong effect for such an architectural style in a nice sylvan setting. Reverse the two, maybe subbing a nice warm beige for the white and putting it as the main level house color, and it would look much better.

    Definitely missing some variety and nice layered "levels" to the landscaping. But overall you have some nice bones there to work with, good luck!

  • 20 years ago

    To me it makes sense to paint first, before doing any landscaping. My neighbor's pretty perennial beds were trampled by painters. I think it makes sense to do "top down" improvements....given that nothing will be rebuilt, I''d do roof and gutters first, then paint and windows (if you need that), then hardscape and grading changes, then planting. You don't need all of that, but it makes no sense to plant something only to stick a ladder in the middle of it or speckle it with drops.

  • 20 years ago

    Again, thanks for the comments. It is obvious we need to give this more thought.

    inkognito-

    If I understand what you are asking, I think we eventually intend to shift this house around use of the rear yard, but something from the front just seems "off" to us. We can't seem to figure out what that is-for lack of a being able to express that, I called it "curb appeal". We thought it was the color and that a quick paint might solve that until my sister suggested it was more the landscaping (or lack thereof). Perhaps it is that we are just not used to this style of house (I grew up in an 1837 Colonial).

    We are buying this house for the location (schools, community beach, commute, etc)and floorplan (as we needed a larger house with a better traffic pattern with my in-laws and their son living with us). We had this house shortlisted soley on floor plan and location/schools, but it didn't "grab" us and we only went back a second time (after looking at another 30 more) when the price dropped significantly. The floorplan, schools, neighborhood beach & park, commute, and price over rode whatever put us off about the looks.

  • 20 years ago

    The siding color is fine -- in fact I like the natural color -- but I agree with IB on the roof shingle color. While a new roof for aesthetics sake is probably out of the picture, however, what you really should take a look at is trim color. That white isn't cutting it and that front door needs help -- or at least a replacement for the tinny looking storm door. That's where I'd be inclined to put my house facelift money. The landscaping needs help, however, too. The walk layout looks pretty good and it appears there are some nice mature trees, but those shrubs by the door alcove are wrong for a start.

  • 20 years ago

    I think "shifting the house" means fix it up quick and sell for a profit. But you're gonna live there, and you want more "curb appeal" so YOU don't think "ew" whenever you come home. (Real estate folks use the term "curb appeal" alot so people sometimes think of it only in terms of being able to show the house for sale.)

    I have to agree that if you're going to paint, it's best to do that first. Painters do tend to squish things. :) Also, waiting until spring will allow you to fully evaluate what you DO have growing (but it doesn't look like you'll have many suprises). You should be able to work at your own pace since nothing is awful and the neighbors are used to looking at it.

  • 20 years ago

    This sounds corny, but after you have moved in and had a couple holidays there, with the family dishes and the old favorite turkey salt shakers, and you have stood out in the yard with your cuppa some, it will have a different sort of appeal. Right now you are looking at a building, with land around it, and thinking of paint and plants. Eventualy you will be looking at the home where your family lives. That will be a kinder filter. I still think this has a tremendous potential to be a great garden site. I think it will be a lot of fun to see it come to life.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks zzepherdogg, we can appreciate that perspective.

    We just have to look at this view of the community beach to forget about the house/paint :) And it really isn't that bad or it wouldn't have risen to hte top of our list.

    Our boys played at the beach for a couple hours this weekend when we were looking around and we can't wait to get moved in.

    Much better than being shouting distance from the interstate where we are now, even if the commute is 20 minutes longer.

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:38961}}

  • 20 years ago

    sweet.

  • 20 years ago

    What's awkward about the house (from this side) is where it sits on the knoll, with that sliver of downstairs where the slope falls off and the upper storey launches off into space. Luckily the deciduous tree is there to soften the larger end of the house and make it look more balanced, although the tree unfortunately is to the left of the house (instead of in front of it, where it would be more effective) and also points off at an angle away from the house, contributing to the out-of-kilter appearance.

    The lawn and paths, on the other hand, are mostly pleasantly shaped. It would be better to have one path leading to the door, instead of two that converge like a wishbone. If keeping the existing paths I would probably also make the area between the shorter path and the house (where there are shrubs now) all bed, with no grass. This would depend on how it looked during a visit to the site.

  • 20 years ago

    That curving walkway really works as it leads the eye to a.... godawful door. Change the door. Your sister is right, save the paint money. Make the entrance more worthwhile accentuate the walkway by planting something on the low side which may also disguise the undergarment effect of that area. being totally crazy look into green roofs.

  • 20 years ago

    OOOOOH, Inkognito - excellent idea and a perfect candidate for a green roof.

    My first impulse when I looked at the pic, wasn't color although I also don't like the whitish foundation exposed by that uncomfortable slope.

    I don't think you should waste time pruning the 2 shrubs, they're badly placed and lend nothing. Removing them and having nothing would be an improvement.

    The low "face" of this house is wonderfully unimposing and I'd not be inclined to do a traditional foundation layer. and sink the house into the elevation any further. Instead I'm liking great big curvalinear beds of groundcover with maybe a small multistem tree out a distance from the house but still in the large bed. Clean lines. and it would be noncompeting with a fabulus mosiac of sedums on the ROOF!

  • 20 years ago

    mmmmm, I'm now feeling like a green roof would dictate a paint color change. lol

    {{gwi:38962}}

  • 20 years ago

    Drawn-in shrubby tree needs to grow up to be more like one off to the left (too far and leaning) in size to be in scale, at which point leaning one can be cut down. If lawn and beds to be laid out as shown then walk to street should be taken out.

  • 20 years ago

    If the white pipe is indeed part of your on-lot sewage system you may be limited in what you can plant in that area of your yard. Definately not a tree like shown in bboy's post. And I think Maryland has some of the strickest on-lot sewage rules in the country.

  • 20 years ago

    Not that it matters, but it's not my post. I don't have any of that fancy visual aids software in use. I just type fancy.

  • 20 years ago

    It's just a photoshop, I use it most often to put peoples heads on other bodies! LOL But it's decent enough for visual aides on the net.

    With the (okay) limbed up shrub, I feel it disguises the lean of the tree. I like the walk to the street - it has nice flow and intersects the bed well.

    I don't like the trained vine or espalier at the door, does anyone have any other ideas?

    Green roof technology is big in Maryland, one nursery there produces only green roof plant materials.

  • 20 years ago

    Yes. LOL! It's both....did they decide they wanted more light from the front door and chop off the roof there?? The color does nothing for the house and the roof appears to be floating....short of reroofing, I think you can improve this house dramatically with a pale taupe paint (grayish beigy with the slightist pink undertone) The roof definitely has some pink in it on my monitor. I'd paint the trim a darker taupe, add shutters in the same tone, window boxes and most important? A pergola to frame out the entry and improve that mistake. I'd create an island connecting to the walk and around that tree and put a variety of shade shrubs, hostas etc there...but not right in front of the windows....let in the light (keep it to about 3'-4' high max with shrubs in the middle....evergreens and mix of deciduous.

    Have some fun with the front door...paint it a dark pink?? Add more substantial trimout above the door...consider replacing that door too. There's a lot of empty space on the wall next to the door...hang perhaps 3 pots. Sweet Autumn Clematis could cover that pergola in two years and is exceptionally hardy and fragrant. White urns on the porch, steps would also help frame out the entry.

    I'd paint first, build a pergola and then see what you've got before I worry about landscaping....and always paint out the gutter downspouts the main body color...they're not focal points, lol.

    I love doing virtuals at 4am in the morning! Oh, I haven't seen this forum before....not on GW much anymore with the darn popups but this appeared to be a challenge I couldn't resist!

    See what you think....

  • 20 years ago

    I guess a link would help! BTW, the pergola left bare looked just fine too in case you're thinking it's over-the-top...I DO get carried away with my plants normally!

    Here is a link that might be useful: GW HOUSE VIRTUAL

  • 20 years ago

    Yes, I certainly got carried away when I looked at it again....lol.

  • 20 years ago

    That was bugging me....I "cleaned it up" for you and put in another virtual without a vine. Obviously you would have more horizontal timbers on the pergola...difficult to draw from a distance shot.

  • 20 years ago

    I appreciate all the comments and the two that put the time to do the mock-ups. They both have great ideas, and they both help ilustrate the answer to our original question- that what may be causing us some pause is likely BOTH a house and landscape issue.

    fwiw, the white pipe is a vent from a tank for a public septic system; i.e. there are no drainfields but each house has a tank which cycles on and off and forces the sewage to the pipes out at the street for bulk treatment.

  • 20 years ago

    Small Diameter Sewer system. I worked on one of those back in the lae 70's early 80's. All the Rage with EPA, you could get more grant money for your project if you did this "innovative/alternative' design. It was a nighmare. Had to get an easement from every single home. A very big hole to put in the tank. You might have had some very nice landscaping at one time that had to be removed. I still remember an 80 some year old man calling me almost in tears because the tank took out his asparagas patch and he knew he wouldn't live long enough to get another one going. Sorry to digress, but check your deed, the city or whoever owns that public septic tank will have an easement on your property and can come in any time.