Software
Houzz Logo Print
znjbrown

Trying to respect the knotty pine kitchen.

14 years ago
I would love to gut the kitchen and start over. However, my husband loves the knotty pine. What can be done to update the kitchen - countertops, back splash, etc.? The kitchen is 21' x 12' including the eat-in area. The eat-in area is about 7' x 6'. We did do the floor with a 12" x 12" porcelain tile. Just a FYI, there are 71 handles and I didn't even count the hinges.

Comments (6)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Wow that is a lot of knotty pine! If you are keeping the cabinets, a little paint or stain along with new hardware would help update the look. A combo of different finishes could be quite lovely.
    Rustic III · More Info

    Knot On Call · More Info
  • 14 years ago
    I love the oven! I actually just went looking for some good examples of retro knotty pine and found this: http://knottyisnice.com/ Some GREAT examples of embracing the knotty pine past of your kitchen. :)
  • 14 years ago
    i just tried an ebony stain on top of wormy chesnut and it turned out beautifully. it is quite dark but you could lighten up your space other ways
  • 14 years ago
    No disrespect to your husband, but I've learned over the years not to allow men to make decorating decisions. They have no idea how much a woman can HATE something they think is "just fine and why would you want to change it?" Mostly, they just don't want to get suckered into doing the work. And most men hate change.

    LOVE the oven, hate the corner shelves and fridge magnets, HATE the pine. Sorry: it has to be change or one day you're going to take a knotty pine rolling pin to your husband and we'll be hearing about you on America's Most Wanted!
  • 14 years ago
    HI -- Just what is it with men and their bleepin wood ? If you really want a new kichen and your not into the retro look , maybe your husband can love the knotty pine in the garage . Sometimes it's just time to let go , if it's not in good shape or it's not what you want. Or you can strip it down and give it a white wash for a more up to date look. The retro appliances (oven) might be worth a few bucks ! If you do the white wash , then the hinges and handles can be spray painted to save $$ and then just change the counter tops with something that goes with the floor coloring ,or black or white. If you go with a new kitchen then you can change the layout if there are things that are not working for you.Get a certified kitchen designer in you give you some ideas and prices etc.
  • 14 years ago
    We have a matching blue frig and cooktop in the basement that needs a home as well.
  • 14 years ago
    Would it count as "keeping the pine" if you did a color wash over it? If so, that is what I would do. I did that in my own kitchen and it turned out really nice. I also replaced all the cabinet hinges, pulls and handles. It is a lot of work, but it makes a huge difference.
    One alternative is to paint half of the cabinets a color you like, and keep the restas is. All the cabinets in a kitchen don't have to be the same color (and often are not). And on some of the cabinest that you paint, you might be able to replace somedoors with glass ones, which would lighten up the room even further.
    (I love that stove too, btw!!)
    Other ideas to consider:
    Replacing the current d/w and fridge with a white one
    Painting the paneling in the breakfast/eating area
    Painting the dark chairs or purchasing new ones that are lighter in color and in form.
    Replace what is currently on the wall above the table with either a colorful piece of art or even the same type of items (memo board, baskets) with more colorful ones.

    I hope that helps.
    Good luck!
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Hi znjbrown, it might be a good comprise if you just keep the base cabinets as knotty pine and have new upper cabinets. Or just mix them up.

    Pelligrini Kitchen · More Info


    Roanoke 4 Square · More Info
  • 14 years ago
    Oh my goodness, I grew up with that oven! And the matching turquoise fridge in your basement! Waves of nostalgia are washing over me as I look at it. But I'm not so nostalgic for the knotty pine look. I agree with other posters that, were it my kitchen, I'd either whitewash or paint it.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Whitewash the pine, I've done this a couple times with different colors. I don't advise painting it, painted wood always looks cheesy. I say bring up the matching fridge. Clear off some of the clutter from the countertops, add a tile backsplash instead of more pine, and update lighting. Leave your hardware as is, it will look fine with whitewashed cabinets. Find the best painter you can to do the whitewashing, you need someone who has technical and artistic skills. Hope that helps. Charmean Neithart
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Charmean I agree totally, I love the stove and adding the matching fridge would be fun. You will have a very unique kitchen znjbrown.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Any man who insists on keeping his knotty pine is not going to sit still for whitewashed knotty pine. Znj, I went to your ideabook and found 1 picture. It's a shot of an office. Was that meant for the kitchen with white cabinets and wood floors or was that, indeed, some thoughts for a future office? Just curious. Also, who selected the floor and is it what you had originally thought you'd have?
  • 14 years ago
    I kind of like the knotty pine - just not in that quantity! If you can add some color to the backsplash, and keep a light and/or cool color on the countertops that would help. At a bare minimum, get rid of the wavy/curved wood valances and replace them with more angular trim pieces (or pieces with one large, gentle arc). I would also add some light-colored curtains with a pattern that could be interpreted as either classic arts-and-crafts or more contemporary (e.g., simple woodblock patterns).
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Since you want to keep the knotty pine, how about lighting it up the wood a bit and removing some of the upper cabinets to add interest and update the space http://www.houzz.com/projects/10884/Windsor-Terrace-Kitchen Look at the floating shelves, have these made in knotty pine.
    If the old appliances are not efficient then get new stainless along with new countertops and a brighter/lighter backsplash will lighten things up.
  • 14 years ago
    I'm a 30 something woman and I like the knotty pine. I also really like the hardware too. Agree you need to change the backsplash and countertop. I don't think it's accurate to say that any man wouldn't agree to whitewashing the pine. I have two men (dad and DH) that would be quite happy with that treatment and my dad loves pine. Also, when wood is painted correctly it doesn't look cheesy at all. If you decide to paint pine, you have to be prepared to paint correctly or the knots will bleed through the paint job later on. Anyway, I think as long as your cabinets are in good condition you can have lots of fun updating your kitchen without breaking the bank.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Just for a visual, here is a room of white washed knotty pine. Looks fresh and fun...
    Dining and Kitchen · More Info

    I would love to see that with your vintage appliances and a new backsplash.
  • 14 years ago
    My husband would like the knotty pine too. Go figure:) If cabinet replacement is not in the budget, eliminate the wood that you can. Paint or replace your dark wood dining set with a white table and chairs, take down the wood shutters and hang a white and aqua ticking stripe valance, remove the scallop above the sink, and at least give your wood backsplash and wainscoting a fresh paint treatment. You are fortunate to have oodles of storage, so declutter and stow away everything but essentials on your counters
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    How fun Mosby, nice tip!
  • 14 years ago
    Thanks for the ideas. I like to compromise of taking out the bottom cabinets and coming back with a whole new texture from the knotty pine. Will definitely re-do the countertops and backsplash and add more lighting.
  • 14 years ago
    I LOVE the oven, cooktop and fridge! Wow, what an amazing find! You could probably get a good amount for the set! I know plenty of people searching for a set. (I hate the pine too)
  • 14 years ago
    This reminds me of the kitchen in Mad Men. Perhaps watching some of the early episodes would help you warm to the look and work with it. Kind of fun and retro! Check out the "dandelion house" kitchen on Houzz for a very contemporary, retro take on the turquoise kitchen.
  • 14 years ago
    is your husband Ozzie Nelson?
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I love the natural pine & have some pics of my kitchen posted under "storage dilemma." I am not a guy & all my (male & female) friends who have visited my cottage, complement that I have kept the natural walls & always say, Oh no, don't paint! I say bring in some color & only paint if YOU absolutely hate the walls as is.

    I do love the oven! Real quick change, take the baskets/board off the back wall, take off the shutters & add some color. Maybe a print on the back wall? How about painting the chairs to match the stove &/or other favorite bold colors you may have in your kitchen. (Look at your kitchen ware, etc.) I would replace the stove as I think the black is too much. A color back splash would be nice, but it would have to go w/ the other colors you use & not add too much texture as the wood is already a focal point in itself. Kinda like a print. (My sisters & I always tried to see how many things we could 'find' in the knots! Owls, eyes, etc!)

    I know it is somewhat difficult, but putting the papers on the counter/refrig in an organized file, or file drawer & possibly tossing some will also help keep the space calmer.

    Good luck & have fun!
  • 13 years ago
    What is the tile name? I am looking for same
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I would embrace this and look for a vintage refrigerator to match the oven. Get a new stove hood in stainless and new range top in stainless and dishwasher. Pick out new counters in maybe a cream ceramic tile and trim it out in a colour. When you do the counters, have an extra twelve inches added to the depth of the Pennisula. And add some retro counter stools. I would remove the scallop trim piece above the window. Add some curtain panels on rings to all the windows. A ticking stripe might be cute or toile. On the shelves near the window, I would use those for a collection of fiesta ware bowls, mugs, etc. get a cute colour Le Creuset teapot for the stove. I would have new lighting done. Can lights for the ceiling and a cute fixture over the sink on a separate switch. Hope this helps. Darling space.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I like the knotty pine, too.
    The paneling appears to be something different. If it is a lesser finish, it is a good place to add colour. If not, the trim is another. Since the oven is likely to be the first of your appliances to age out of the room, I suggest bringing its colour into the space through paint and accessories, as both are inexpensive to change when it comes time. Repainting the baskets on the organization wall and adding a coloured frame to the calendar, are other easy areas to brighten with paint.
    Printed fabric to replace the shutters would soften the room. If you want to keep some of the retro feel of the space, I would leave the scallop and add cafes. If you wish to modernize the look, you might remove it and look at roman shades.
    As you seem to be heading towards black appliances, a laminate counter with grey will help tie the older elements with the new; there are lots to choose from, and you can bring samples home for comparison. Lightening in some of these other areas will allow you to go with a darker countertop. If all the wood must remain as-is, look for something lighter to balance. This is an ex. from Wilsonart.
Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County