Software
Houzz Logo Print
maryl_gw

Creative minds welcome

I once saw a "creative" person take an old egg carton and transform it into a place to hold earrings. I would never have thought of that. So if you have any idea about what to do with a 90% dead 17 foot crabapple, please let me know. The problem is the birds. There is nowhere else to put another tree, and since this one is a goner, where are we supposed to hang the bird feeders once we take this one down? After a dozen non-violent cats in my past, I finally have one who is a "birder" so those iron hanging bird feeders you see all around are unacceptible for my high jumping cat. I'd leave the tree up, but it's unsightly in a suburban landscape (let alone the safety factor). Help??

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    So it is suburban creativity you are looking for? Leave the tree, cut off limbs to suit and grow something up it. Safety factor on a 17 foot crabapple is zero.

  • 18 years ago

    I see several issues ...

    1. Dead, mostly dead, crabapple. Looks bad in the neighborhood.
    2. Tempting a cat who would love to catch and kill birds who frequent the feeders hanging from the mostly dead crabapple.
    3. Feeding birds during a season when they should be foraging for their own abundant and natural foods. :-)

    Least creative solution, and the most costly if you and a helper can't take it down with a bow or chainsaw; have it professionally cut down and the stump ground out. Work in some new soil and amendments and eventually plant a new tree. Rehang bird feeders and drive the cat crazy.

    Most creative would be to limb it up with a bow or chainsaw, string fairy lights on it, put a table and some chairs under it and dine al fresco as if at a trendy patio cafe.

  • 18 years ago

    Once in a magazine I saw where someone had shortened most of the limbs and painted it a cobalt blue using spraypaint. It was stunning, even if it won't last forever, it will last for several years. You could train vines up it if you wanted to "camouflage" it.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with gottagarden. In the early 1990s I saw a garden in Santa Barbara where they treated a dead tree as a hanger for bird feeders. It was a dead orange tree, and it had been stripped of the thin bark and twigs and there were perhaps forty birdhouses and feeders of every description hanging off of it. It was striking, and I kept my eye peeled for a dead orange tree to drag home for years, until I killed my own.
    Renee

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not sure about painting it, but I would shorten it somewhat for safety's sake and grow a rose up through the limbs. An old rambler is what you need. Although they are once-blooming in the Spring, they put on a long show. I'd recommend City of York, a yellowy-white that has spectacular hips in the fall. I've read that birds love hips but I usually see squirrels eating these. Veilchenblau, a very unusual violet-gray color is another great grower, with very few thorns.

  • 18 years ago

    Need more information!

    What do you want to SEE or have happen in your yard, in terms of priority? Do you want a bird feeder only, and have actually enjoyed the tree as much dead as alive, or would you like to see another living and blooming tree? And how ugly is the dead tree, etc--some dead trees are better than others or lend themselves to that funky look, whereas others, it would be just a more garish eyesore!

    I'm all for repurposing, and some of the suggestions above can look really cool in the right surroundings, so it all depends on the "look" that works in your yard (front yard? or hidden) and what you want. If cat-proof bird station is the most important, you might even nix the tree and have someone build you a structure--I've seen bird "totem poles" or other type structures for multiple feeders.

    If you would really like to see another tree there, and you've got a few years left there, then it would be well worth (to me!) the investment to do as duluthinbloom described and have the tree taken out, and I would shop for a fairly good-sized replacement of some kind. Yeah,it might cost $500+--getting someone with a good reputation for thorough stump-grinding is key to being able to start a largish tree in the same spot, or maybe, you can re-site slightly as long as the existing dead tree is no longer there, and depends on your market, and what kind of tree you choose to replace.

    Be creative, but don't keep yourself from doing a bit of longer-term thinking just because it might crimp the birds for a year. They'll still be there. Most of the time we put things off and then wonder why we didn't do something sooner so's we could have enjoyed it longer.

  • 18 years ago

    All of you have given me wonderful and insightful ideas. Below is a picture of the "almost dead" tree. Putting up another tree is not really an option. While I'm not a creative "landscaper" I am a plantswoman who enjoys full sun plants. This is not the first tree we've planted that we've lost, and each time they are taken out I'm just so much happier with the resulting sunlight then I was with the tree. Go figure. HOWEVER, this particular tree was more then just shade. It was a bird landing place, an outdoor movie theater for my 3 indoor cats watching through the windows (as well as we humans), an excellent place to hang bird feeders out of the reach of our one "rescue" indoor/outdoor cat...well, you can see how terribly inconvenient it is to loose it. So if you all would look at the tree and tell me how "decorative" it is, or how decorative we could make it, I'm really leaning towards keeping it if you all don't think it's a safety issue.
    {{gwi:45383}}

  • 18 years ago

    Birds appreciate places to shelter near their feeding and drinking/bathing places. Soooo, how about another tree, but one with a more upright habit that will cast a slimmer shadow on your garden. Or something with an open canopy that will provide dappled shade ... something that many plants appreciate during the hottest summer months.

    BTW, I finally picked out an amelanchier (serviceberry, shadblow, etc.)' 'Princess Diana' is supposed to have wonderful fall foliage colors in addition to the species' typical spring flowers (attractive to early pollinators = food for your birds, lol) followed by sweet purple berries attractive to birds. Tops out at 20' high at 15' wide. The 'Rainbow Pillar' cultivar is supposed to reach the same height, but only 8-10' in width.

    Just a suggestion :-)

  • 18 years ago

    Oooh, I like the dead tree. It's much nicer than mine was. It looks like it is in your fenced yard. Is that so? What safety issues concern you? Kids climbing it? Eventually, of course, it will fall over from rot, but it's not that tall. As long as it wouldn't take out a roof I'd certainly keep it for the next few years, just to use it as a canvas. Removal of the lowest right and left skinny limbs and anything else too skinny might be a bit of a chore, but it would allow creativity! I like the rambling rose idea, but I think it screams for morning glories.
    Renee

  • 18 years ago

    Cut the tree down.
    Plant a new tree.
    Get a shephard's hook for the bird feeder.
    don't let your cat outside!

  • 18 years ago

    Hosen, you have pointed out something that a friend of mine asked: "What's the rush"? I think I may just "whittle" on it for a year or so taking out the dead limbs as much as possible. What I envision in it's place is a round, stone edged, 2 tiered raised bed with the sedum and Lycoris Radiata (now planted under the Crabapple) relocated to the lower level and on the 2nd upper tier - daylilies. In the middle, a tall stout "T" type structure with bird feeders hanging off both ends (far enough out that falling seeds won't end up in my bed). How does this sound? BTW, if you had told me 3 years ago that I'd ever have a free roaming cat I would have slapped you silly. I do NOT approve of it. However, the cat situation is what it is for now.......When I started this post I think I was still grieving over the loss of this particular tree. Aside from all the other pleasures it has given us for 22 years this tree was a stunner in the spring. Silly perhaps to get so attached to a tree. You all are helping me now to focus on the future (thanks Frank) and I appreciate your thoughts and input very much.

  • 18 years ago

    There was a recent post on the pet forum with pictures of outdoor cat shelters, constructed by the poster.

    They looked quite nice, well as nice as they can look. AS a gardener, I would envision growing some vines on them for shade.

    I encourage you to look at those pics.

    Here is a link that might be useful: outdoor cat post

  • 18 years ago

    Daylilies! Yes! I can't stay away from the daylily forum.
    I think taking your time is a good idea. You can map out your daylily strategy while you trim some branches. By the way, those little branches make great supports for wildflowers, you know?

    I am always torn: should I take out the beautiful flowering nectarine so I get more sun in my flower bed? I have settled on pruning the poor thing into a little martini glass.

    Good luck Maryl, Renee