Software
Houzz Logo Print
slave2thefur

French drain design questions

19 years ago

Hi everyone - I've been reading the posts on drains and capturing rain water with great interest. I've torn out my front grass and redesigned / replanted with drought tolerant landshaping (complete) and a hardscape patio (TBD). The house is now guttered, with 2 downspouts for approx. 700 sq. ft. Here in San Diego, our avg rainfall is 10" during the winter season. I'd like to have the rainfall percolate into the soil with drains that follow the sidewalk (concrete base) and the curve of the stepping stones (dirt base), maybe using a rock streambed look. Previously, the rainwater dispursed over the yard (no basement, sadly), which is poorly absorbent hard clay/silt. The raised bed has very good drainage due to lots of compost and mulch added during its construction.

My questions: will this work? How deep do I have to dig? Should the corners have preforations in the pipe? How wide an area do I need to accomodate the drain - one foot?

Thanks for any advice or warnings ... diana =^,,^=

Here is a link that might be useful: front layout

Comments (9)

  • 19 years ago

    Diana,

    There are a number of ways to address your question. Personally, I do not find much wrong with just letting the rain percolate into the soil surface. I realize that is not always possible and/or desirable. Although it is from a thread I created several years ago, I am going to include a photo of a low tech approach that I used to capture and transfer rain from my gutterless house into a rain garden. Particularly since you do not have a basement, this same setup should work quite well to transfer and disperse water as you describe. I think this should work quite well if placed beneath a dry stream bed.

    {{gwi:54277}}

    In this photo, I used 4-inch perforated plastic drain tile. At the time, I used it because that is what I had left over from another project. It is working quite well after three years of use. However, on similar, subsequent projects, I have begun to use the rigid, perforated drain pipe after some discussions on this forum about the technical issues of each type. The cost difference between the two is small.

    The argument was that, over time, the corrugations in the bottom of the flexible drain pipe will fill with sediment. Quite frankly, IÂm not real sure that I always buy that argument. Most of the applications of flexible drain tile are to extract excessive ground water from an area. In that scenario, water (along with potential sediment) is flowing into the pipe. However, in your case, clean roof water is flowing out of the pipe perforations. In the end, this may just be a case of splitting hairs. If your installation involves a lot of curves, you would wind up choosing the flexible pipe anyway.

    As to depth of trench: Of course, have your utilities marked out (a free service) before you begin any digging. For the DIYer, I would suggest just digging a full spade depth  this isnÂt rocket science. In my area, I know that if I bury the hollow drainage pipe this deep, I can still maintain solid growth of bluegrass lawn over it. Anything shallower and browned-out grass belies what lies below in the dry summer. Of course, this rough measurement may have to be adjusted to insure maintaining a slope, where needed. However, drainage slope really isnÂt that much of a critical issue when you are dispersing (not transferring) water. In fact, much like a septic system, you may actually want terminal dispersal areas level.

    IronBelly

  • 19 years ago

    I second everything IB just wrote.

  • 19 years ago

    You guys are so practical, what I want to know is, is this part of the journey like getting a shampoo or is it more like a perm? No but seriously Dan 'member the copyright thingy? You should claim this material that you have worked so hard on as your own.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for your response, Ironbelly. Your contributions to this forum have been very useful to my layout.
    Even though 10" doesn't sounds like months, it comes in the space of 3 months and the soil is slow to absorb it. I need to prevent erosion patterns around the stone patio I'm designing. A gallon-sized hole takes a day to empty - I get visions of a hard downpour recreating the Bellagio fountains due to the water bouncing off the dry soil. As cool as that would look... I'll take your advice and start digging.
    Thanks for the 'keep terminal dispersal areas level' - hadn't thought that one through. =^,,^=

  • 19 years ago

    Another question: the drainpipes end about 6" above ground along the outside wall of the house. Do I need to physically connect them to the drain pipe, or can I fashion a funnel directly underneath? What has others done that worked or didn't work? =^,,^=

  • 19 years ago

    You can directly connect them into your underground pipe. There are a mirad of available connectors that are specifically made for this task; which are stocked by most any good, "Big Box" home improvement store. The caveat is to make darn sure that you are not dumping a bunch of leaves (or tennis balls) into your gutters and underground pipes.

    Personally, I hate gutters. I find them mostly unnecessary and an ongoing maintenance woe. Yes, they are an answer to controlling water around buildings but there are often better solutions. (A personal rant, here.) In the above photo, the trench is located directly below the roof drip line of my house. There is never going to be a problem with clogged gutters and downspouts here!

    As a secondary benefit: I used a product called "turfstone" to both contain the gravel from eventually wandering into lawn areas and to provide an access path into planting beds located next to the house. Water splashing against the building is also controlled.

    One thing to remember about buildings... The single largest enenmy of any structure is water. It is impossible to eliminate it but you can (and must) control it. However, there are a number ways to do it. Up until this point, society's answer has been to "get rid of it" as quickly as possible. All that is really required is to get and keep the water away from prolonged, direct contact with your structure. The drier it remains, the better. However, there is usually no need to quickly dump it into the nearest storm drain -- what we usually so. Since your house has no basement, your requirements are much easier to be met. I compliment you on your efforts!

    IronBelly

  • 19 years ago

    I probably should have included this photo in my response above. This is a photo that I am really quite proud of... not because of the trench but because this provides proof that I was actually able to get my son to help me do some work around the house!

    {{gwi:54278}}

    IronBelly

  • 19 years ago

    Whether you use PVC or the black crinkle pipe (ADS is the most common brand), there are adapters that fit the straight end of the downspout. They are pretty much an end cap with a flange. So, you can have the pipe coming up out of the ground to meet your downspout wherever that ends after you take off the elbow. (whether you want to or not depends on how much you want to look at it or how well you can screen it). The white PVC is easily painted which may nor be bad to look at. Downspouts are very inexpensive, so replacing them with longer ones that meet the flange closer to grade is not a bad idea.

    Another thing that you can do to protect the underground part of your system is to make a place where debris can accumulate and be removed before continuing far into your system. I designed one for a historic building that was also going to reclaim the water for irrigation. These were quite large so that they could be easily accessed by maintenance people and because the roof was of wooden shingles with 5" downspouts, so the liklihood of large objects entering the system was pretty high. I used 6" PVC elbowing from the downspout into an 8"x8"x6" "T" with the 8" pipe facing the sky and the center of the earth. A short piece of 8" pipe to a threaded 8" cap was brought up to grade (the surface). Below the "T" was another 8"x8"x6" "T" with a section of pipe below that which was capped. The 6" pipe then continued on into the system leaving an 8" deep hole for debris to fall out into. A screen with 1/2" holes blocks smaller floating debris from continuing while larger or heavier pieces accumulate in the sump below. It is 8" in order to be able to reach well down into it for maintenance. A 4" pipe with a 6"x6"x4" "T" set up would be more practical for a home aplication.

    Most people don't bother with this added step, but it is insurance. You could also do this where several pipes come together rather than at each downspout. We had a very expensive and deep system to protect (and it was a multimillion dollar renovation to the building).

  • 19 years ago

    The first rain of the season came, about 1", so I watched the outflow from both downspouts. The one next to the sidewalk gets about twice the outflow, and a 4' test trench extending from its terminus took 2 days to absorb after filling 10". This would potentially leave a pipe section in standing water and drown nearby plants. The rest of the trench (about 50' U-shape) drained fine.

    Should I make a concerted effort to drain that section better than the rest? Should the grade be higher in that section? Deeper trench? More gravel?

    and a newbie question - will 3" pipe work?

    Thanks for the clean-out suggestions, laag. It's certainly easier to add it now. =^,,^=