Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19703663

Potting soil like a brick!

19 years ago

I started with a sack of potting soil from walmart, added equal parts of sand, vermiculite, and peat moss and potted up some houseplants. When the soil dries out it's like a brick! What should I add to lighten it? TIA

Comments (24)

  • 19 years ago

    Potting soil IS mostly peat. All you can do now is soak the heck out of it until you can break it up without harming the roots, then repot using a LOT of grit in the mix for fast drainage, and good compost without vermiculite or sand in it. The sand is making it 'hard' and the vermiculite compacts too. You need something like small aquarium gravel, perlite, chicken grit (from Feed store), or small 'decorative' gravel from a garden or construction site. You may end up watering more often, but shouldn't worry much about rotting roots unless you keep your pots sitting in drain water.

  • 19 years ago

    I started with a sack of potting soil from walmart

    The blue bag for $1.00?

    Unfortunately I know what you are talking about and it isn't potting soil even though the bag says it is.

    It is yard dirt and entirely unsuitable for container plants indoors or out.

    I am not being a potting soil snob or anti Walmart, I really do mean the stuff in that bag is quite literally yard dirt, not a potting mix.

    Go buy a bag of Miracle Grow potting soil, Perfect Mix or any name brand Walmart sells and it will be a million times better than what you have.

    There is *nothing* you can do to improve the Walmart brand stuff. It belongs in the yard, not in a pot.

  • 19 years ago

    My experience agrees with what Lucy said. Any potting mix high in peat moss will cake and become sort of brick-like as it dries.

    I mix my own indoor-plant growing medium. I use shredded coconut fiber (called coir, and pronounced "kwar" - French-wise) instead of peat moss. It's not so acid as peat moss, plus peat is reportedly being "mined" in many places at a rate faster than nature is replenishing it.

    I also use finely-ground bark, which in my area is sold at a plant nursery, and comes from a company that mixes it with cattle manure and composts is in large windrows for a while, then packages it in 25lb bags.

    Making the growing medium is easy and kind of fun. My basic mix is roughly 45% coir, 45% finely-ground bark, 10% perlite. This mix is airy and drains well and does not seem to cake much when dryish.

    I've used sand in my mixes in the past, but have stopped. The occasional person has recommended to me that I try mixing in some sort of coarse grit (notably, granite or ceramic grits). I may try that, but haven't yet.

    Well, good luck...

    Joel

  • 19 years ago

    Get Pro-Mix or Miracle grow. I usually add some perlite in to improve drainage and airflow. The old adage "you get what you pay for" applies to potting soil I find.

    Tom

  • 19 years ago

    kim, if you ask 100 people what they use for a potting mix, you'll likely get 100 different answers. I'll refrain (I can hear the applause) from telling you what I do, but I will tell you that the sand you added did not help matters, and that vermiculite does very little to improve soil porosity.

    Of course, we don't know which of the Wal-Mart products you are talking about....some of much worse than others, that's for sure.

  • 19 years ago

    The potting soil from walmart was in the blue bag "Garden Basics, General Purpose Potting Soil." I will certainly stay away from that in the future!
    I now have a bag of Hyponex Potting Soil and I'll add only perlite to it. And I also got a bag of Miracle Gro African Violet mix.
    Thanks everyone for your input!

  • 19 years ago

    Uhoh. Hyponex is made out of sedge peat moss. This is not a good thing. My suggestion, if you haven't already potted up, is that you add as much as 50% perlite to that stuff, or you'll end up with muck. You could even use more than that of the perlite for most plants.

    Didn't know it was going to be so complicated, did you? LOL

  • 19 years ago

    I did already pot some of them up...I had put about 25% perlite, so the rest of them I'll put 50%. Someone said "name brand" so I thought Hyponex would be good...what brand does anyone recommend?

  • 19 years ago

    Someone said "name brand" so I thought Hyponex would be good...

    I think that was me being guilting of overgeneralizing again. Sorry. I am not familiar with Hyponex so I won't comment on it, but Rhizo knows what she talks about.

    What I *should* have said was that the Walmart stuff in the blue bag that is really inexpensive is yard dirt/topsoil rather than a container plant mix. It is horrible stuff to work with. COMPARED to that stuff *any* name brand potting mix is an improvement.

    Walmart also sells Miracle Grow potting mix as well as Perfect Mix. I have used both and consider them comparable. They are both decent enough that I would recomend them, BUT it is true that opinions vary greatly on what makes a good potting mix. Some hate peat moss, some hate perlite, some hate vermiculite etc.

    Miracle Grow and Perfect Mix, as far as 'general purpose' potting mixes are widely available and generally perform well for a year or so before a repot is in order.

  • 19 years ago

    Another vote here for Pro-Mix. Just the plain old Promix not enhanced or moisture retention.

    Its a hard lesson when we can't depend on name brands but its so true. I picked up Scotts Potting Soil once and wound up tossing it outside in the garden.

    Its always baffled me how some of these name brands can be such junk and stay on the market year after year. Sandy

  • 19 years ago

    I think they stay on the market the way a lot of plants that are totally inappropriate for whatever they're being sold for, like cyclamens for here where it's too hot and humid, and I'm sure you can fill in many others, keep being sold. The 'marketing theory', I suspect, is that people will buy them and they won't work so they'll come back and buy more. I've run into too many people who say things like 'I guess I just have black thumbs' and give up on gardening at all to think that's what really happens. It alternately breaks my heart and makes me VERY angry when these things happen. Gardening, both indoors and out, is such a joy (and addiction!) that when people try it and give up I want to take some of these jerks and bang their heads together. Probably just have rocks at the ends of their necks. Bet you can tell I feel strongly about this! I actually knew of a 'nurseryman' who advised a newcomer to the business that that was the way to make money!

  • 19 years ago

    I often see plants for sale that are not for my zone. But then I thought about the fact that some people might have controlled environments or greenhouses where they can grow them. It's sad to think about how many people probably give up on gardening because they've bought the wrong plants, but I say buyer beware and do the research first. Nursery people who knowingly sell inappropriate plants are definitely something to get angry about...but when anybody says it's all about the almighty dollar, I try to realize everybody's just trying to make a living. I think if they can't do it honestly, they shouldn't do it at all.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Kim1947: Can an inexperianced guy jump in here ?
    I have had trouble with the same kind of potting soil from
    other well know Home Improvment outlets (I won't say who !)
    Then I tried top soil and it wound up on the lawn to fill in low spots. When it dried a little it looked like a desert after a drought.Then I ordered 3 yards of screened top soil, for the lawn and tried mixing a bucket of it with 1/3 perlite for repotting. It worked great.
    I probably hit on the right mix by luck. One of my plants was like you said ( soil like a brick),so instead of trying to shake and dig the soil off the root ball, I soaked it in a bucket for a while and then washed all the soil from the roots. That way I didn't damage the root system.Then I clipped the longest roots back and stuck it in a new pot , pouring in the soil and adding water, little at a time. I packed it slightly ,then let it go for a week,out of direct sun . I have done this with Bonsai evergreens.
    It's growing good but I don't have it now. I gave it to my daughter. Another good natural material for mixing in soil ( for acid plants ); which I get in my wooded area, is rotted hemlock trunks,which has turned to fine( humus ? )
    Don't take my word for all of this! Wait to see of anyone has any comments. I got in deep in the Jade Plant Forum, so
    I thought I'd try another !!!!!
    Good Luck - Lou

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Lucy, Joel and Rhizo1 : Where did everyone go.!!!!!
    I read your posts about sand in the mix. There are different kinds of sand. There is Pointing Sand.It is very fine(sometimes called Marble Dust)Then another fine sand,
    called Bar Sand (used to make mortar for brickwork ), May be the kind your talking about compacting. Try Concrete Sand from a building supply that caters to Masonary Contractors. It is much coarserand cheaper too. I have used it before with Perlite.- - - JOEL!!!!, I don't think I would want to use Granite or Ceramic grits, because of the sharp edges damaging the roots. Maybe I'm wrong But no one is posting answers. I guess they all went to the Islands. I've used concrete sand before, after washing in a piece of screen.I mixed it with some top soil,Perlite and Hemlock Humus.
    I don't have a recipe, just judgement. This mix was good for conifer bonsai. One is out front, with the other plants. I would like to hear some Corrective Critique on the Granite and Ceramic Grits for Joel. Even if you are
    on Vaction.
    Thanks, LOU said that

  • 19 years ago

    Sharp edges of granite/ceramic grit do not damage roots - in fact many studies have shown them to be superior for encouraging root growth. It has been shown that the edges do NOT affect ramification of roots (make them split and grow two vs one) as was thought, but it won't hurt them.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Lucy : Thanks for your comeback. That answers my question !!!!!
    Lou
    PS: Are you on Vacation ?

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Lucy: Could you let me know where you saw the studies
    on the Granite and Ceramic grits. I'd like to look farther into this, in comparison to my using coarse concrete sand.
    As in my last Post.
    Thanks LOU

  • 19 years ago

    I used to use coarse sand and it worked pretty well. Always heard the finer sand was good for making concrete and I didn't want to try growing plants in concrete. Then I discovered perlite and I never looked back. But I think it's very important to remember that what works for me may not work for you, and vice versa.

  • 19 years ago

    Lou - Its been on various bonsai websites, or actual sci. papers online, but I would just Google a few good keywords/phrases to see what was said and by whom.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Green elbows : I think you have it backwards.
    I said the finer sand is used for brick mortar and would be no good because it compacts.
    The concrete sand is very course and doesn't compact.
    I was on the internet looking up Ceramic and Marble grits
    and saw where other people have used course sand. I use it along with Perlite. If the Granite and Ceramic grit works better, I'll try that.I'm always experimenting anyway
    LOU said that

    PS: Hi Lucy, I see you're back from the Islands.
    I have to find something that I can help you with.
    Are you doing any Brick or Stonework ????/

  • 19 years ago

    I found this new product called ZeoPro which was invented by NASA. It is designed to be mixed with potting soil and all kinds of soil. This stuff works great. Never had any problems with it. If you use it you should not have potting soil like a brick. This is really high tech stuff but easy to use and all natural...just mix into soil and root zone. It costs $16.95 for a 10 lb. bag. See it at www.advancedsoils.com

    Here is a link that might be useful: Advanced Soil Science

  • 19 years ago

    Great, we pay for NASA and they turn around and patent stuff so we have to pay high prices for stuff they come up with.

    Seems the universe is a bit off kilter today.

  • 19 years ago

    Tine, have you actually tried it? What were your observations? Does it live up to all of its claims?

  • 19 years ago

    Hi javamilk,

    Ive been using ZeoPro for a year. I use it in my potting mix for my orchids in my greenhouse. Orchids seem to love it and I noticed there has been no fungus gnats. I planted herbs in sandy soil this past summer,10 herbs with ZeoPro and the same variety of 10 more plants without ZeoPro. I just watered all of them in and noticed that the plants with ZeoPro showed no transplant shock. Also, as the summer continued, the herbs with ZeoPro were about 3 times taller and 3 time wider than the plants without ZeoPro. I used no fertilizer. I am not a scientist, but just wanted to see if this stuff really worked. I have been buying several bags since then. Using it on my roses, hostas and my indoor plants. Also, the company says you can reduce fertilizing by 50%-75%. Just my opinion, but I really like this stuff called ZeoPro. I went on the NASA web site and they have developed a lot of consumer products that came out of their space science programs. All I know and care about is that it is all natural and it really works.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting