Software
Houzz Logo Print
amyjean_gw

Thornberry Apple for zone 5A?

17 years ago

I am considering planting a Thornberry Apple from Greenmantle Nursery. They've recommended it, but it apparently blooms in late October. I am afraid of losing the apples to frost. Any thoughts from anyone here experienced in such things? Thank you, Amy

Comments (2)

  • 17 years ago

    Amyjean:

    I am sure you mean this apple ripens in late October. It would bloom with the others. If you can get a hard freeze before the end of October, it might not work for you.

    Greenmantle specializes in the preservation and propagation for sale of old varieties, many that are generally classified as crabs. Among these are quite a few red or pink fleshed varieties, of which Thornberry is one.

    If you have never tried one of these red-fleshed apples, I think you ought to do so before buying and planting one. There are a few that have reasonably decent flavor when eaten fresh, but those are few indeed. Most can be described as "spitters" -- you bite in and spit them out. Unless you prefer very sour, tannic apples, you might not like the flavor of this category.

    I have one here called Geneva Crab that is quite beautiful, both in skin and flesh. But it has no practical use for us other than blending in applesauce with other varieties to give the sauce a nice pink color. No one in my family, or any of the visitors we have had here would eat one of these apples fresh off the tree. I am not talking about sweet/tart here, but bitterly acidic and tannic. If you want to plant a good apple for fresh eating, or even for sauce and pies, you ought to look at some other nurseries and varieties. Cummins Nursery in Geneva, NY has a fine selection of very high quality apple trees, and is an absolutely reliable source. Ask them what they think about the red/pink fleshed apple varieties; they might have one that is not quite so bad. But I kind of doubt it.

    Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

  • 17 years ago

    I've grown and fruited Thornberry - and while it's not a 'spitter', it's not one that I'd recommend very highly.
    Minimal 'red' in its flesh - and I'll agree with Don - the red-fleshed selections are not typically all that great for fresh eating - better for jelly, adding some color and tartness to applesauce, etc. Of the half-dozen red-fleshed varieties I've fruited here, Almata was the best.
    Pink Pearl and Hidden Rose are supposed to be fair to good - but they were both exquisitely sensitive to fireblight in my orchard and never lived to bear fruit.

    If you're looking for a nice edible crab, Centennial, Chestnut, Wickson, Kerr, or even the old standard Dolgo(parent of both Centennial and Kerr) are hard to beat for tasty little apples.