Software
Houzz Logo Print
claysoil

troughs too porous?

19 years ago

My troughs do not hold water. If I fill them with water and let them sit, within minutes they are empty.

Is this a bad thing? If so, does anyone know what I am doing wrong?

Thanks in advance!

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago

    you could seal it...unless the holes are too large, in that case I would put a veneer coat on the inside ( 1/4 - 1/2 inch)

    I had one leaky too, it was because I didn't pack the Tufa tight enough. I put on a skim layer of 1:1 port:sand and it's fine now.
    Marcia

  • 19 years ago

    I've sealed a couple of my things (globe, leaf casting) with Thompson's water sealer, but it sounds like your troughs are too porous for that to work. Marcia's idea of a skim layer sounds like the best advice.

  • 19 years ago

    Why would you want a planting trough to hold water? Is this for a bog garden? Billie

  • 19 years ago

    billie,
    As I understood the problem to be water "runs" out. Mine did, and my trough wasn't given the chance to even absorb any water...That is why I put a 'skim' layer inside. I more or less filled in the gaping holes, and now it is just wonderful for my plants.
    Marcia

  • 19 years ago

    Part of the directions for making troughs is to drill holes in the bottom. When I saw how quickly the water drained from my first batch, I did not put holes into the second batch. Last week I spoke with a woman who sells hand made troughs, and she said that they should hold water. Then I started worrying that mine would be too dry for even rock garden plants.

    So, mix up some portland and sand and coat them with that. On the inside, I assume? And is "construction" sand the kind that I should use? I have a ton of sand that was delivered for use in a sidewalk.

  • 19 years ago

    CLay
    describe how you constructed - Hypertufa should not hold water.

  • 19 years ago

    Claysoil, As Plantman56 said, hypertufa should not hold water unless you don't add any drain holes and seal the inside. You can make the drain holes when you are making the container. You can drill them after the fact but it's just as easy to do it while you're making them. How big is the trough, how many drain holes and how big are the drain holes? What recipe and directions did you use?

    Marica, The trough will absorb some water but it's the soil that retains the water for the plant not the container. If the water is running out as fast as you are pouring it in then it's the soil that dried out too much. Either soak the whole container or add water a little bit at a time to re-wet the soil.

  • 19 years ago

    Okay, the recipe I used was
    peat moss (3 parts)
    perilite (3 parts)
    Portland (2 parts)
    synthetic concrete reinforcing fibers (handful)

    I inverted containers and built the tufa over the containers. I let them cure over several weeks in my 60 degree basement. The first set I made I did make drain holes in them as I initially formed them. When I moved them outside and filled them with water to start the leeching process, I saw how quickly they drained.

    For the second batch I did not put holes in because the first batch drained so quickly that I did not see a need. But the more reading I do it seems that everyone makes drain holes, which leads me to believe that my containers are too porous and I've done something wrong.

    I have not put dirt into the containers yet. I'm trying to sort out if they are too porous and need another treatment before I fill them.

    I don't see any point in sealing them to turn around and drill holes in them....unless they will crack otherwise. I do like the info on how to seal them in case I want to plant something in them that likes a moist soil; and I've been toying with using a trough as part of a pond.

  • 19 years ago

    Construction and ingredients look like you doing it right.
    Hypertufa does drain well. Look at the ingedients, more than half will allow water to drain through.
    I guess it depend on what you plan to plant. I plant conifers, and semps' and they require "great" drainage, so each one of my containers have a large 2-3" hole in the bottom. I also use a potting mix that includes grit and small pieces of bark to increase the drainage.
    If you want to plant things that like moist soil, a tufa conatiner may not be the best choice. I guess that you could elinate the drainage holes, but that may present a problem if you have plants that are growing year round.
    You could also seal with paint or a thin coat of portland.
    As for ponds, I know that lots of people say that it is not a problem however best if the tufa has soaked in a big bucket of water, cleaning it from the lime that is in the portland. Would not want to harm fish if you used tufa that was fresh.

    LOL MIke

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks so much to everyone who has posted their thoughts to help me out. I'm going to leave them as they are because I intend to plant things that like well drained soil.

Sponsored