Software
Houzz Logo Print
brandon7_gw

Apple Rootstock Rotting

18 years ago

I planted four apple trees early this spring. All were on EMLA 111 rootstock. I thought they were doing well until I noticed a problem yesterday. While looking closely at them, I noticed a relatively small crack opening up on one of the rootstocks midway between the graft and the soil. With further examination, I found that an area about 3/4" x 1-1/2" under the bark was rotten. The rotten area was a layer similar to sawdust about 1/4" thick. I removed the loose bark and cleaned out the powdery wood.

What caused this? What should I do about it (if anything)? How is it likely to affect the tree in the long run?

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    Sounds like you have borers, and you got them from whomever sold you the tree. You're going to want to dig down enough to find the critter that did the damage. Either way, most likely, the best course of action is replacement.

  • 18 years ago

    It very well could be some type of borer, but I haven't seen borer damage that looked like this before. Would some type of borer hollow out a large single area like this? The layer below the sawdust is completely smooth with no signs of tunneling. I could have missed it, but I also didn't see any signs of entry. The sawdust part definitely seemed like borer damage to me, but everything else just didn't match up with what I think of when I think of borer damage. I just googled apple tree borer damage and didn't see anything that looked similar to my tree.

    Is there something else that this could be or does it still sound like borer damage? I would post a picture, but I haven't had a camera with me when I go out to the farm.

  • 18 years ago

    Anyone else have any input? Now that the area has been cleaned, I'm not sure how much good a picture would be, but if anyone thinks it's necessary, I might be able to make arrangements. Even an educated guess might help lead me to an answer. I'm going to look closer for any signs of insect damage tomorrow, but I'm still not comfortable that that is what I'm working with. Could there be other explanations for the "sawdust"?

  • 18 years ago

    Brandon:

    Crown rot (aka collar rot) may be a possibility. This condition appears to have several possible causes. It just happens, and I have lost a tree to it, although it was older than yours.

    The injury, as you describe it, seems impossible for the tree to overcome, and I would take it out. Since this occurred in the first season after planting, I would think you have a pretty good case for a replacement tree, since it is highly likely the rot was already underway when you planted this tree.

    Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

  • 18 years ago

    You know I don't know about rootstocks.
    Going by the "sawdust" description my initial thought was also borers.
    In the bag of hickory I got from a friend there is a bunch of what could only be described as sawdust. My brother's termite eaten house also fit that description, even though the termites kept it wet.

    But you could be describing it differently than I would. I could imagine someone describing my niece's old hollowing trees as having sawdust and it's definitely a rot issue.
    I searched that rootstock and did see mention of rot.

    I agree with jellyman that no matter what it is I would see about a guarantee. With a good nursery there shouldn't be any reason to fret over a first year tree.

  • 18 years ago

    I appreciate all three responses! After looking into the symptoms of crown rot, I am kind of leaning toward that. I have my trees planted in very well drained soil, but like Don said, the damage was probably started before I planted the trees, and has just come to the surface. Sounds like you guys are right, I need to contact the supplier.