Software
Houzz Logo Print
roninparkridgeil

Reel Mower for Chicago?

19 years ago

Hi, First post here. I'm not a lawn expert and haven't cut grass much since my teens. A few years ago we moved from the city and have been using a lawn service. I'm ready to start taking care of this myself and have been looking around trying to figure out the best mower for me. I saw a show on HGTV a while ago showing a guy in the UK who's lawn looked like a carpet. I figured that since this is a relatively small yard (takes me under 1/2 hour the times I have done it myself), that I could take the time to really manicure it and start working towards something like what I saw on that program. I figured out that what he was using was a reel mower with a roller for striping and based on its looks, that it was either this or something very similar: http://www.atco.co.uk/products/balmoral.html. Having found this site, I now see that there are several makes available here (Atco's are not sold in the US): McLanes http://www.mclanemower.com/reelmowers.asp, Tru-Cuts http://www.trupower.com/tru_cut/reel-mowers.htm & Trimmers http://www.californiatrimmer.com/oldsite/trimmers.htm. Based on what I have read here (which includes just about every post containing the word "reel"), I contacted the people at Trimmer and got this response: "was designed to cut at a limited height 3/16"  1 ¼" for grasses that are drought resistant or cut short" which sounds like it won't work for me here in the suburbs of Chicago. Can anyone here recommend a Reel mower that would be suitable to this area (5)? I see that some of the manual reel mowers can cut almost to 3" tall, but I have my doubts that they could do the same job that these power models would do. Any feedback in this area would also be helpful too, though. As my yard is not very big, and I'm young enough and would not mind the exercise, if a manual reel could do the fine manicured look, I would consider that. My main goal is not that it be motorized, manual, expensive or cheap. I basically want to invest in something solid and reliable that can make my lawn stand out from the crowd. Thanks, Ron

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago

    One thing you do not mention in your post is service. Do you know where you would go to have the reel/bedknife serviced? Fewer and fewer places service power reel mowers.

    I would look at the Sunlawn MM2 with a DIY upgrade to replace the rear striping rollwer with something heavier.

    It will not cut quite as neatly as a finely tuned power reel, but it will cut to 3" and is built very solidly. It is a non-contact design and is easy to adjust the cutting height.

  • 19 years ago

    Hello to a fellow suburbaner. I grew up in Elmwood Park but spent a lot of time in Park Ridge looking for scenes from The Blues Brothers.

    I had a lot of luck with a Scott pushmower. I dont remember the model or name, something like "PrecisionCut" or similar.

    As for sharpening, call your local mom and pop hardware stores. Most of them have a guy who comes by once a week and picks up and drops off. I worked at a place at Harlem and Chicago about 15 years ago and they had that service. I want to say the name of the sharpening place was called Blain's, but I may be very wrong. They should be in the Oak Park phone book under Dressels.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback. I know where one scene from the Blues Brothers was shot in Park Ridge. Before they rebuilt Lower Wacker downtown, I also used to take out of town guests through there as the Blues Brothers portion of Chicago tours.

    I called a lawn mower repair shop in Niles and they said that they send reels out to be sharpened and that it cost $50 for the service.

    Can anyone compare the Sunlawn to the Scotts manual reel? Is there much difference if any? I've seen Brill got some unfavorable reviews in the forums so I guess I'll avoid them. Here's a place that sells a variety of manual reels including others besides Sunlawn or Scotts: http://reelmowersetc.com/products.htm.

    I'm gathering that the blades don't get very close to walls, trees, etc., so there's no getting around using an edger, is there?

  • 19 years ago

    No, there's no getting around using an edger. :-(

    I like my Brill; I had a Scotts reel and it was -- well, it was like the difference between a -- uh, Lexus -- and a Ford.

    To be specific, the Scotts is much heavier and yet "floppier" -- the handle torqued in use and it didn't feel as stiff. The Scotts' blades contact the bed knife, so it makes more noise while operating and sharpening is necessary far more often. Even the handle cushion is better on the Brill -- in two years, the (thicker) cushion on the Scotts was twisted and shredding. The Brill's looks like it did on Day One. Considering that the Brill doesn't cost much more than the Scotts in lots of places, it was an easy choice. I did not see any Sunlawn models or I might have chosen to buy one of those. They look pretty good.