Software
Houzz Logo Print
ekgrows

Homemade Fertilizer

17 years ago

I am tired of searching for fertilizers that meet my needs, so this year I am going to play around with making one. I will most likely mix bonemeal, bloodmeal, and kelp meal. I have a very basic question.

If I combine 1 amendment that is 12% N, another that is 12% P, and one that is 12% K, do I end up with a 12-12-12 fertilizer, or because each of those amendments is 1/3 of the total volume, would it be a 4-4-4 ratio? I am thinking it would be 4-4-4, but I saw somewhere that someone just added the numbers up.

Comments (39)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Let me ask you a question . . . Why apply equal amounts of NPK when your soil may not need equal amounts of these ammendments, or any at all for that matter.

    If you add nitrogen when your soil has enough nitrogen already, you will get fast growing, lush plants that might not bear fruit. Over abundance of other nutrients also causes problems. The only thing it's hard to add too much of is organic matter.

    It might make more sense to get a soil test, and add required ammendments as needed. It also cheaper!

    Ron
    "The Garden Guy"
    http://www.TheGardenGuy.org
    "New Article & Journal Entry"

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You're correct in your thinking :-) Assuming the various products contain just the single nutrient source, each in equal concentrations (by no means a guarantee, depending on source and formulation), by combining them in equal amounts your are tripling the volume and thereby reducing the concentration of each by a third. Just adding the three numbers together is a no go!

    I've attached a link to a recipe for a basic, all-purpose homemade organic fertilizer. It's always a good idea to have a soil test done, at least initially, to get a baseline for the nutrient content your soil provides but once you have that in hand, addresssed any major deficiencies and have been working with it awhile, a basic all-purpose fertilizer used as a supplement is often a good idea. This is even more important if you are growing annual, harvested crops like vegetables, which have a strong nutrient demand to produce well.

    Here is a link that might be useful: basic homemade all-purpose organic fertilizer

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks to you both! Organic guy - I just used those numbers as an example. (I was going to use 10 as the example number, but 12 is evenly divisible by 3.) I already layered composted horse manure over the beds, but it will need more amending. We have a very large garden, and I demand a lot from it, as I am quite an intensive planter. Using pre-formulated fertilizers, I have to use the NPK ratios that are offered. By making my own, I can customize my soils / plants needs. :)

    Gardengal - Thanks for that. I was pretty sure that was how it would work, but I couldn't find anything to confirm it! I saw one web page where someone said if you mix this and this you add the numbers, and it just seemed wrong!

    Thanks again!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ratio
    is 1:1:1 so that 4-4-4 or 3 times amount 12-12-12 and so on.

    many gardens can benefit by
    a 3:1:2 so 6-2-4; 9-3-6; or 12-4-8; 15-5-10;18-6-12

    A Soil test will help determine what amount of N P K is in the soil currently.

    Additional trace elements and minerals are also needed which is why Dolimite Lime is used since it includes Calcium and Magnesium.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Contact your state universities USDA Cooperative Extension Service office about having a good, reliable soil test done to determine what you might need. The "fertilizer" you are designing there could not be an organic fertilizer, would be very soluble (the easier the numbers are to extract the more soluble the nutrients are), and would cause about as much pollution as any commercially available fetilizer.
    Organic gardening involves knowing what your soil does need, which means a periodic soil test, and getting that into the soil in a way that gets the Soil Food Web to provide the nutrietns needed to the plants when the plants need them.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    kimmsr, I don't understand your statement. What's not organic about a fertilizer based on blood, bone and kelp meal? And why would it cause pollution if used in moderation? And how can it be 'very soluble'? With very few exceptions, nutrients derived from organic sources (animal and feed meals) are not soluble until they go through the necessary interaction with soil organisms to convert them to soluble forms. That's one of the primary reasons they do not contribute significantly to pollution - there are no excess readily soluble nutrients to leach into groundwater.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We are certified organic - so there are products that I can and can't use. Many of the formulated fertilizers (that ARE approved by OMRI) are not approved by our certifier. Bone meal, Blood meal, Kelp meal, Feather meal and Fish meal are all allowed as are other materials - with restrictions - like there are no inerts, synthetic ingredients, etc. Trust that I will do all the research I have to in order to best prepare our garden beds. I will not be dousing all beds with any or all of these materials just because they are allowed.

    We get soil and water tests - we have to for our certification. I have been researching labels, sources, - basically anything I can, for fertilizers, fungicides, pesticides, etc. Some companies will work with us (full disclosure), others will not. I guess they don't want to give out their "secret" formulations. In a way, I understand that, but on the other hand, it means we can't use their products, and it makes me wonder if they are hiding something. Anyway, it is very frustrating, which is why I will just try my hand at my own formulations, with both readily available nutrients, as well as slower releasing ones.

    Thanks to all for their input.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Blood meal is interesting. You don't see much about it in the forums, so the experience level must be pretty low. What we seem to know is that it decomposes overnight into something that can burn plant roots if there is too much. How much is too much is what we really don't know. Grain type fertilizers (based on corn, wheat, soy, milo, cottonseed, alfalfa, etc.) are commonly used in lawns at a rate of 10-20 pounds per 1,000 square feet. You can easily go to 40 pounds per 1,000 without harming anything, but you will probably get some sour smell out of it in a few days. However with blood I would be inclined to go to 5 pounds per 1,000 or less to start. And then you have to mix it with something else to avoid getting it too dense in spots.

    The grain type fertilizers "go to work" in 3 weeks and last for a few months. It is thought that blood goes to work in a day or two and then wears out. Feathers are fairly well known to last forever without benefit unless they are hydrolyzed first.

    Are you interested in doing your own experiments with fertilizers to see what works best for you? That would take the pressure off of getting exactly the formula you think you want. Try several different mixes in different areas and see what happens.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you get numbers of nutrients, for example a 7 percent nitrogen level common in blood meal, that means that that nutrient is soluble, readily available. Anytime you have a series of numbers in the 10 plus range that indicates something present other than organic material since nutrients in organic material are very stable and will not show up in standard testing methods. Therefore a "fertilizer" that is in the 10-10-10 range is not an organic "fertilizer". The whole concept of "fertilizing" is a holdover from the "conventional" gardening mindset.
    So again, the objective of an organic grower should not be to put down a "fertilizer" that will feed the plant but should be about feeding the soil so the Soil Food Web will feed the plants what is needed when it is needed.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Kimmsr - I have explained this a number of times.....let's see if I can be more clear this time, cuz you are obviously not getting it.

    The numbers on the fertilizer label - NPK - have nothing to do with solubility. They are simply an indication of the concentration of that specific nutrient in that specific fertilizer formulation, period. A 10# bag of fertilizer with an NPK of 15-15-15 can be expected to have 15% of the total volume each in nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, or 1.5# each. The rest of the volume will be fillers. Sometimes - not always - elsewhere on the package of of synthetic fertilizers you can find a further breakdown of ingredients that may be immediately soluble. Even with synthetic (non-organic) ferts, solubility is not always immediate for all the nutrient content. Treated slow release fertilizers are one example but even non-treated products may have differing rates of solubility.

    As I stated earlier in this thread, with very few exceptions, organic fertilizers are NOT soluble. Not until they are consumed and digested by soil organisms and converted to soluble chemical elements that can be accessed by the plants - which can only access nutrients in a solution. That's why organic fertilizers are by definition slow release.......there is a period of time required after application for the natural process to be carried out and the plants able to access the nutrients.

    Yet organic fertilizers still reflect proper NPK labelling (which is a federal requirement). The numbers are smaller because the concentrations are smaller. Again, it has nothing to do with solubility. The lack of immediate solubility and the release of nutrients only over a period of time is why organic fertilizers are not inclined to leach excess nutrients (there aren't any) into groundwater and thereby contribute to pollution. They are not considered 'stable' (whatever that means) and they can be tested for and measured - that's how they determine the nutrient concentrations of the various organic products in the first place.

    There are differences in how fast various organically sourced nutrients become available. Blood meal tends to be one of the fastest acting as it is easily digestible by the soil organisms and applying too much can cause burning of plants through the rapid conversion of nitrogen. It can become available in as short a period as 3-7 days but its effectiveness as a nutrient source is typically considered to be 1-4 months, depending on conditions. But it is still not considered 'soluble' when applied as a dry meal. It does dissolve readily in water and its solubility increases dramatically at that point.

    As a rule of thumb, organic fertilizers will generally never have NPK numbers that add up to more than 20. Again, it has nothing to do with solubility but is entirely a reflection of their low nutrient concentrations (compared to non-organic ferts). Hopefully that concept was explained clearly in my answer to the OP's original question regarding combining the three different products and what the NPK would be of the finished result - not 12-12-12 but 4-4-4 based on the concentrations of each in the total volume of mixed product.

    And while organic fertilizer does 'feed the plant', it does so indirectly by first feeding the soil organisms. I think it is you, kimmsr, that is operating under an incorrect mindset to make the assumption that fertilizers have no place in organic gardening. While the application of organic matter is a great natural nutrient source, it is not always very efficient in supplying the high nutrient demand that some growing/cropping activities - like annual vegetable crops - require. This is where supplemental applications of approved organic fertilizers are of great benefit and totally justified.

    Kimmsr, I know you have much to offer these forums, however your lack of understanding of some basic concepts and your dogmatic approach to the way YOU think things should be done gets in your way and is neither accurate nor helpful to posters on these forums.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jeeze gardengal! Don't hold back. Tell us how you really feel?

    I disagree with a lot of what you said but I'll try to be a little less vindictive.

    Solubility has to do with the ease with which a material can dissolve in water. Salty chemical fertilizers generally dissolve right away. Most organic materials are not soluble with blood being an exception.

    Availability, in the context of gardening, has to do with how quickly the nutrient can be transmitted into the plant via the roots. Chemical fertilizers that are not coated in plastic usually melt right into water and become available immediately. Blood is nearly the same. However, the nutrients in grain type fertilizers are not available right away. It takes 3 weeks for them to "act." The nutrients in feathers (an extremely high "nitrogen" source) are not available for months.

    gardengal mentioned fillers in fertilizer. I think the filler she's referring to is the other part of the salts in the material. If you have ammonium sulfate at 40-0-0, the ammonium amounts to 40% of the weight and sulfate is the rest. I think in gardengal's terminology, the sulfate is "filler."

    gardengal, I know you have much to offer these forums; however, your lack of patience and compassion and your dogmatic approach to the way you think things should be gets in the way. Your vendetta against kimmsr is similarly not helpful to posters on these forums. I also realize that my reply to your reply to kimmsr is not all that helpful to the OP but as long as we were putting people in their place, I thought I get in on the action. ;-)

    ...and feel free to comment on my dogmatic approach to the way things ought to be, heh, heh. I've been known to have an unpopular opinion here.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ammonium sulfate (21-0-0) is 21% ammonium ions and 24% sulfate...(NH4)2SO4. The sulfates are not typically listed in the analysis, but if they were, the label would read: 21-0-0-24.

    The remaining percentage is filler....insert carriers of various kinds. Fillers facilitate the application of the active ingredients.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay in the interest of homing in on what fillers are, let's pursue...according to Wikipedia, which I obviously did not consult prior to my previous post...

    Ammonium sulfate, (NH4)2SO4, is an inorganic chemical compound commonly used as a fertilizer. It contains 21% nitrogen as ammonium ions and 24% sulfur as sulfate ions.

    I presume the fillers, then would be hydrogen and oxygen. Any real chemists care to contribute? In any case I think gardengal's fillers are accounted for in the chemistry of the listed compounds in the bag. Yes they are not NPK but they often provide useful minerals to the soil, that is if you are not trying to be certified as organic.

    I've never seen any adulteration or filler in a bag of ammonium sulfate. It looks like extremely pure rock salt to me. I suppose there could be impurities in the crystal...

    Not that ammonium sulfate really has anything to do with the OP's question, but this is interesting from my personal experience. The last time I used ammonium sulfate was during The Great Snail Invasion of '95. I had heard that it was the main ingredient in snail bait in the UK. I tried it and BAY-AM! The snails disappeared overnight! More recently I've heard that AS is not the main ingredient in UK snail bait, but it sure did work for me. I'm an organic guy but if I was faced with using poisonous snail bait or ammonium sulfate (which is sort of edible), I'd use the AS.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Interesting goings on here. Would everyone be more comfortable if I used the words "soil amendments" instead of "fertilizer"?

    I agree that organic matter is important. We use some worm castings, horse manure, and compost from our compost pile. However, due to the fact that our garden is almost 6000 square feet, there is simply not enough to replenish all that we take from the soil every year. We use straw and leaves as mulch, and cover that up with manure at the end of the season. So - we are adding as much as possible. Soil amendments are more concentrated, much cheaper to buy, and faster and easier to spread. And, I do feel that they feed the soil as well. If I fished more, I could just bury the heads, tails and bones left after I filet the fish! Since I don't fish all that much, I'll have to settle with the fish meal that someone was kind enough to make for me! Same goes for the other amendments I'll use.

    I will most likely make 2 combinations. One higher in N - for the leafy crops, and one lower for the fruiting crops. Of course, the soil test results will help determine how much I'll want. I plant in blocks rather than rows, and rotate crop locations every year, so It will be pretty easy to add just what I want right where I want it. Mixing the 3 or 4 materials I choose BEFORE I spread it will make for 2-3 less trips around the garden with the spreader.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    dchall, do a quick Google search on fertilizer fillers and see what you turn up. The bulk of the product....what's not accounted for by percentage weight of NPK....are mostly inert fillers - sawdust, soil, sand, industrial waste, etc. Even some ingredients that could be quite toxic, like heavy metals. These make up the bulk of the volume in synthetic fertilizers and are added so that a) the product is easier to distribute, and b) you are not applying the concentrated nutrient(s) directly to the plant. This is pretty common knowledge to any basic understanding of commercially manufactured synthetic fertilizers. Your 100# bag of ammonium sulfate (21-0-0) is most likely also going to contain 79 pounds of sand or something very similar.

    In organically derived fertilizers, the fillers are (typically) the rest of the materials that make up that product.....in feather meal, for example (NPK = 11-0-0), the rest of the volume that is NOT nitrogen are the ground remains of the feathers, the shafts, etc. which provide bulk and likely a few trace elements as well. And maybe a few other inert ingredients that make it into the mix.

    If you disagree with what I say, by all means point out where I am in error. However, I think you'll find that my explanation is pretty darn accurate - what I've expressed is not a matter of opinion, it's fact according to federal and state regulations that control fertilizer manufacturing and labelling.

    I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and attribute the last paragraphs of your response as an attempt - awkward at best - at humor. If you'll review the contents of my posts over that last 8 or so years I've been a participant here, dogma as it applies to any form of gardening or horticulture is an anathema to me. There are very few absolutes in this industry but what there are are incontrovertible and not open to dispute or opinion - like fertilizer labelling and basic plant biology - because there are laws or scientific principles that govern them. What does cause me concern is the amount of misinformation or opinions that are presented as fact.....usually couched in the terms as "I've always done it this way/this is what my parents/grandparents taught me and it works so it must be true". Or worse....just a lack of education - formal OR self-taught - about basic gardening principles or terminology.

    What I expressed above regarding fertilizers, how they are labeled and how they work is NOT my opinion - it just IS. You can disagree with it all you want, but let me make it very clear that you are not disagreeing with me........I didn't make up these rules, I'm just reiterating what the FDA, the EPA, AAPFCO, ATTRA and individual state agencies require with regards to the manufacture and marketing of fertilizers. I've been in this industry a long time and have spent a considerable amount of time and effort in obtaining a formal education in it and seldom offer any kind of serious advice or recommendations without doing considerable research to make sure I have my facts straight. I also teach and write about these subjects professionally, so accuracy in what I state is a matter of principle.

    I have no personal vendetta against kimmsr or anyone else on these forums. As I stated, kimmsr has a great experiential knowledge base and has a lot to offer these forums. But when he or anyone else makes statements that are blatantly inaccurate or broad declarative statements that are personal opinions passed off as fact, then I am compelled to respond. Sorry if you don't like that but too bad :-)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oooh! This is worse than I thought. You really don't know what feathers are, do you? Somehow I knew it. They're protein from one end to the other.

    I don't think you're up on your chemistry either. Sand in ammonium sulfate? It sure looks like pure white rock salt to me. I'm not a professional but I know that sand and sawdust do not crystallize and would either sink to the bottom of the bag or "float" to the top. I've never seen that. Plus when you add up the elemental mass of the components of ammonium sulfate you get the N and S percentages as listed in the posts above. The H, and O make up the rest of the percentage mass of the molecule. There is no mass left for filler.

    What I have expressed about how chemistry works is not my opinion, it just is. You can disagree all you want but you are not disagreeing with me. I did not make up the laws of nature. You can teach the federal and state laws and you can teach the chemistry. Hopefully they will interlock but marketing will always get in the way.

    Have you been teaching your students that there was sand in ammonium sulfate? Is that the standard of accuracy you hold yourself to? Or is common knowledge and your personal opinion good enough? It seems like blatant inaccuracy can happen anywhere at any time. All I suggested is that you have a little patience when you see something that disagrees with what you believe. Rather than berating the writer, ask where he got his information or something a little less incendiary. I'm dosing you your own medicine and I can see it has touched a nerve. I could have worded this reply much differently. For example...

    My Google search tells me that the fertilizer coatings used to keep them from being immediately available are allowable on the label as "inert ingredients." Google also tells me that sand quarries make their products available as fertilizer fillers. However, I could not find a manufacturing label that showed fillers (or inert ingredients). I was certain that Scott's had their labels posted on their website, but I can't find them. Maybe it was a retailer where I saw them. Anyway I wrote to Scott's to see if they could help. I expect them to deny using fillers. I've seen coatings listed as inert ingredients on bags of grass seed. When I get something from Scott's I'll come back.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink.....if you wish to persist in your way of thinking, there's not much I can do for you. And ignorance is bliss, I guess. Hopefully, those who are not quite so closed minded will derive some benefit to what I posted.

    Feathers may be mostly protein, but protein is not a plant nutrient. It is the conversion of the protein into nitrogen that is of significance in terms of fertilizing and that's why it is reflected on the outside of that bag. You need that bulk of feathers, shafts, whatever - your protein - to finally arrive at a relatively small percentage of nitrogen that actually becomes available to the plant. That's why there are no 'fillers' per se in an organically sourced fertilizer. The bulk/weight is made up of the plant or animal parts the nutrients are eventually derived from.

    And yes the presence of fillers in synthetic fertilizers is commonly known - to the point where the EPA is attempting to enact regulations so that the inert ingredients ("fillers") must be disclosed. These have previously been under no order of disclosure and many fertilizer manufacturers consider them 'trade secrets', in much the same way inert ingredients are treated with chemical pesticides. The sand was an example - different manufacturers use different bulking agents: clay, sand or sawdust are commonly used but there can also be salts, chlorides, formaldehydes or various industrial waste products. And since they are not required to disclose what they use, you really have no idea what you may be applying to your soil or lawn under the guise of a synthetic fertilizer.

    So tell me this: if you have a 10 pound bag of a 10-10-10 commercially prepared synthetic fert, what do YOU think makes up the remaining 7 pounds. And what kind of cites can you find to support that? Or is this just your opinion?

    I'm sorry if you felt my initial reponse to kimmsr's statements "incendiary", but I have taken the time to explain on several previous postings through the years the exact same thing - what the NPK numbers on a bag of fertilizer mean, that they are only a reflection of the percentage weight by volume of the 3 major nutrients contained in that package (the 'guaranteed analysis'), and that solubility, or the lack of it, does not come into play in this labelling. Readily soluble or immediately available components and/or micronutrient content may be disclosed elsewhere on the label, but the micronutrients can only be identified and disclosed if they meet the guaranteed analysis requirements. And the vast majority of organically sourced fertilizers are by definition insoluble in their applied form. This is basic Fertilizers 101 and is taught in all the Ag schools, Master Gardener programs and horticultural colleges. I'm not sure why this is so difficult to grasp, but apparently for some folks, it is.

    And good luck with the Scotts email. Since they are not required to disclose to you or anyone else what their fillers are and may even consider it to be a trade secret, you may or may not get any kind of meaningful response. Be sure to get back to us with what they say.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sometimes a kindergarten teacher has to talk sternly and forcefully to some "problem students" who have difficulty in class.

    IMO, GG48 is one of only a handful of contributors that have any kind of knowledge or experience I pay much attention to.

    Sometimes I have no clue exactly what is being said, as at times it is waaayyy beyond my knowledge level. Given this, I still learn from what she says and I am actually somewhat glad of the repetition of some of her posts, ergo, the "problem students" can actually serve a purpose. Who knew?

    Lloyd

    P.S. Big thanks to GG48, a VoR IMO.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink.....if you wish to persist in your way of thinking, there's not much I can do for you. And ignorance is bliss, I guess. Hopefully, those who are not quite so closed minded will derive some benefit to what I posted.

    I've led you to the scientific answer to your question twice. Who's not drinking the water? Are you trying to make a case that science and mathematics are not true? I wish to persist in the belief that science works and mathematics is the truth. Yes I cling to those. I have faith that the GW readers can add up the numbers you are ignoring and reach a total.

    Feathers may be mostly protein, but protein is not a plant nutrient. It is the conversion of the protein into nitrogen that is of significance in terms of fertilizing and that's why it is reflected on the outside of that bag. You need that bulk of feathers, shafts, whatever - your protein - to finally arrive at a relatively small percentage of nitrogen that actually becomes available to the plant. That's why there are no 'fillers' per se in an organically sourced fertilizer. The bulk/weight is made up of the plant or animal parts the nutrients are eventually derived from.

    I'm not sure what feathers have to do with the price of tea in China, but I agree with your statement. Your only mistake earlier was in thinking that the shafts were filler. They are not. They are a protein source for the microbes. They're not a very available one, but they count.

    And yes the presence of fillers in synthetic fertilizers is commonly known - to the point where the EPA is attempting to enact regulations so that the inert ingredients ("fillers") must be disclosed. These have previously been under no order of disclosure and many fertilizer manufacturers consider them 'trade secrets', in much the same way inert ingredients are treated with chemical pesticides. The sand was an example - different manufacturers use different bulking agents: clay, sand or sawdust are commonly used but there can also be salts, chlorides, formaldehydes or various industrial waste products. And since they are not required to disclose what they use, you really have no idea what you may be applying to your soil or lawn under the guise of a synthetic fertilizer.

    This is why you want to stick with name brand fertilizers if you are going to use synthetic fertilizers. I don't think I have been saying that you were wrong about manufacturers being allowed to use fillers. What I'm saying is that the rest of the material in a bag of 10-10-10 fertilizer is not likely to be sand. It is much more likely to be chemicals. After you add up all the chemicals in the bag if you still have not reached 100% of the weight, then the rest must be inert fillers. Please read on.

    So tell me this: if you have a 10 pound bag of a 10-10-10 commercially prepared synthetic fert, what do YOU think makes up the remaining 7 pounds. And what kind of cites can you find to support that? Or is this just your opinion?

    Science is not my opinion. I guess you could say that it is my opinion that the total mass of material inside the bag is the sum of the mass of the individual contents in the bag. And it is my opinion that all the scientists that have come before us were not leading us astray on the atomic weights of atoms. I'll do an example of the mathematics of the chemistry to show you that there is no filler in the bag.

    I thought I had explained this twice before but I can do it in more detail. To summarize, the entire mass of material in the bag is chemicals. There is no room for fillers.

    I don't have any data for a 10-10-10 fertilizer so I'll do it for one I can get data for. Here is the location of the MSDS for Scott's LawnPro Step 4 Lawn Fertilizer 31-3-10
    http://www.hardwarestore.com/media/msds/134288.pdf

    According to the MSDS Scott's LawnPro Step 4 fertilizer contains the following ingredients
    Urea
    Ammonium phosphate
    Potassium chloride
    Ferrous sulfate
    Manganese Oxide
    Manganese Sulfate

    From chemistry we know the following molecular formulae
    Urea (NH2)2CO
    Ammonium phosphate (NH4)3PO4
    Potassium chloride KCl
    Ferrous sulfate FeSO4
    Manganese Oxide MnO
    Manganese Sulfate MnSO4

    What we don't know is the amount of each. We do know the final NPK is 31-3-10 (from the MSDS). Using my handy dandy Excel spreadsheet, which I ginned up just for you, I have identified one solution that makes the NPK come in at the specification and the weight of the bag equal to 100 pounds. From that we should be able to determine that 100 pounds in fact does equal 100 pounds. I know that sounds crazy but anyone who has studied engineering will get the message locked in that statement. From the Periodic Table of Elements, we know the following

    Hydrogen weighs 1 gram per mole
    Carbon weighs 6 grams per mole
    Nitrogen weighs 7 grams per mole
    Oxygen weighs 8 grams per mole
    Potassium weighs 15 grams per mole
    Sulfur weighs 16 grams per mole
    Chlorine weighs 17 grams per mole
    Phosphorous weighs 19 grams per mole
    Manganese weighs 25 grams per mole
    Iron weighs 26 grams per mole

    and there are 454 grams in a pound. All I have to do is determine the molecular mass of each material on the Scott's list and how many moles of each material there are in the bag. That's not so bad.

    Just using the molecule as a guide, and simple arithmetic, the molecular mass of the ingredients can be determined to be:
    Urea = 60 grams per mole
    Ammonium phosphate is 149 grams per mole
    Potassium chloride is 74.55 grams per mole
    Ferrous sulfate is 151.9 grams per mole
    Manganese oxide is 70.93 grams per mole
    Manganese sulfate is 151 grams per mole.

    Then by trial and error, I adjusted the spreadsheet values to determine how many moles of each material could be in the bag to equal 100 pounds. It turns out if you mix the following recipe,
    58.15 pounds of urea
    15.10 pounds of ammonium phosphate
    21.35 pounds of Potassium chloride
    2.34 pounds of Ferrous Sulfate
    1.09 pounds of Manganese oxide
    2.33 pounds of Manganese sulfate

    you will end up with a final mix of

    5.13 pounds of hydrogen
    11.63 pounds of carbon
    31.38 pounds of nitrogen
    24.19 pounds of oxygen
    3.14 pounds of potassium
    0.99 pounds of sulfur
    11.19 pounds of chlorine
    10.15 pounds of phosphorous
    1.69 pounds of manganese
    0.86 pounds of ferrous iron

    Surprise! The total weight of the molecules and the total weight of the materials are both 100.36 pounds. There are no pounds left for sand. The NPK for the blend is 31.27-3.13-10.12 which is pretty close to 31-3-10.

    Thus it is my opinion that science and mathematics can be used for the benefit of mankind and even this forum to demonstrate that at least one fertilizer manufacturer does not use fillers in at least one of their mixes. I suppose you could say that the ferrous sulfate, manganese oxide, manganese sulfate as well as that pesky carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and chlorine are fillers because they provide no NPK. By almost any defenition they probably are; however, they also delivering the NPK to the user. Plus some of the materials provide bulk amounts of manganese, sulfur and iron which can be useful in a chemical fertilizing program. In any case there is no sand filler in this mix.

    Maybe by law the manufacturers are allowed to use fillers, and maybe you have interpreted that to mean they all do, but you need to know what you are talking about. You have to understand the chemistry or you can't understand this topic. To make a blanket statement that fertilizer manufacturers use hazardous materials as filler in their products is highly misleading. You have to take that on a case by case basis. Two materials that are pretty well known to contain heavy metals are Ironite and Milorganite. But I think for you to say that they all do is something you absolutely cannot prove.

    You are making me jump through fairly serious mathematical hoops to illustrate this. Fortunately it's not that hard and am willing to do it for you. You could have proved it to yourself by opening a bag of fertilizer and looking for the fillers. Note that I am not asking you to do that. Even though you believe all or most fertilizers contain fillers (to include sand) I believe you could not demonstrate that if you were asked. Besides, by law a bag of 31-3-10 has to contain 31% N by weight no matter how much sand is in the bag. Taking this to the extreme, if it had 99 pounds of sand you could not get any appreciable amount of N in it. What would be the point of using fillers?

    I hope you can take this to your students in the future. If you ask me one more time what is the rest of the material in a bag of fertilizer, I'm going to have to report you to your chemistry teachers. I don't think I can spell it out in any more detail than this. Do you want me to provide sites to prove to you that science is a fact? You should have gotten that in school.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's late & I was bored - wandering around the forums. I just stumbled on this thread and noticed with interest that most of the controversy tends to stem from two ideas. One is the idea that the % of an element in a fertilizer blend somehow has something to do with it's solubility, that the higher the % of an element in a fertilizer, the more soluble the element is. I can't imagine why 5-5-5 would be any more soluble than 20-20-20. We can't be taking into account saturation levels, because we fertilize at no where near those rates. Also, there are organic forms of fertilizers that release elements very slowly, yet are higher in some nutrient %s than soluble synthetics.

    Mr Dchall did some impressive work, and there is probably no disputing it, so I wouldn't try. Basically, he proved that the whole is equal to the sum of the parts; but, that 'filler' thing keeps eating at me and has raised a question. There is probably not a whole lot of science in what I'll say, and the math is really simple.

    Let us say we have 100 lbs. of the very best 'name brand' 5-5-5 fertilizer money can buy and consider it's content for a moment ...... we know it contains a total of 15 lbs. of NPK (macro-nutrients). That means that we have 85 lbs. of the product that is yet unidentified. It would be useful to us and our plants if a significant part of that 85 lbs. was secondary macros and micros, but we should be able to absolutely agree that it is not. We would be generous to allot another 5 lbs., especially in view of the low % of macros in the blend. So, after being generous, we can see there is probably 80 lbs of completely useless material in 100 lbs of top quality 5-5-5. The question is What do we call all that superfluous material that is of no value to the plant? I guess, and this is just for me, if someone wants to call it 'filler' - and I know what they mean, it's probably not far enough off the mark for me to make too much of a fuss over it.

    Take care, all.

    Al

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Ammonium sulfate (21-0-0) is 21% ammonium ions and 24% sulfate...(NH4)2SO4."

    Er, sorry - this is simply not correct. Ammonium sulfate is 21% nitrogen, not ammonium. The nitrogen is held in the form of ammonium ions, (NH4). Ammonium contains nitrogen, but the total percentage of ammonium would be greater than the total percentage of just the nitrogen. The rest of the 'filler' is the sulfate and the hydrogen in the ammonium. If you do without the 'filler', then the nitrogen would just disappear into the air.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you sell a fertilizer with a label that says this is a 10-10-10 fertilizer then someone should be able to test that and find that indeed that product does contain what the label says it does. To extract the nutrients from that product means they must be soluable, disolvable because you cannot make a calculation and arrive at those numbers. That Blood meal, an organic fertilizer, has 7 percent Nitrogen is known because that N is readily available, easily extractable, soluble, ie. it can be disolved.
    In soil fertilizers are made available to plants via moisture, so those nutrients must be disolvable in water, moisture, for the plants roots to uptake them. Perhaps this kink will also aid in understanding.

    Here is a link that might be useful: About fertilizers

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Eventually, all nutrients, whether coming from organic or synthetic sources must be soluble in the nutrient stream to be used by plants. Let's use an amendment other than blood meal (usually 10-15% N, btw), because that is somewhat unique. Let's use alfalfa pellets. Obviously they are NOT soluble, yet we find the NPK and other nutrient content widely published. Soluble - insoluble makes no difference, we are simply ascertaining the amount of nutrients that will immediately or EVENTUALLY become available from a particular source.

    Al

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    tapla, true you cannot make the nitrogen in alfalfa multiply in the bag, but the alfalfa might feed microbes that can produce usable nitrogen out of thin air. This is a complicating factor in organic gardening. Legumes inoculated with the right microbes will extract nitrogen from the air and store it in usable form. So far we can't predict how effective that is. The point is the sum of the nitrogen locked in a bag might only be the tip of the iceberg as far as getting nitrogen to the plants.

    To kimmsr's point, the chemical fertilizers are usually soluble in water and the nutrients can be measured relatively easily. The nutrients in organic fertilizers are in the form of protein, carbohydrates, enzymes, vitamins, and hormones. Those are not usually soluble and can only be estimated. Since they are organic and food, their value to the soil microbes is really anybody's guess.

    For example corn meal (and perhaps coffee grounds) seems to attract the Trichoderma fungus while other meals have not demonstrated that ability. In the lawn Trichoderma appears to be a disease fighting advantage; however, in the mushroom grower's compost, Trichoderma is a terrible disease by itself. Thus a pound of corn meal has different qualities from a pound of soy bean meal. We don't know enough about all the actions and interactions to know which fertilizers work best with which crops.

    Many people have good luck with corn meal but others do not. Many have good luck with molasses and others do not. Sometime you have to stop reading about it and see how it works for you.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just a point of interest . . .
    Rainwater, especially after a thunder storm is supposed to contain a good amount of soluable nitrogen. The ions in the air get electricly charged and extract the nitrogen, from what I understand. Collecting rainwater after a thunderstorm and using it to irrigate your garden at a later date provides a quick, free growth spurt. I have noticed that effect after thunder storms for many years.

    Ron
    The Garden Guy
    http://www.TheGardenGuy.org
    Read Articles & Journal Entries!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm going to stay focused on the subject. I think it unnecessarily clouds the issue when we introduce the new topics of molasses, corn meal, diseases and the ability of corn meal to suppress diseases, nitrogen fixation, or what fertilizers work best to the discussion. My (and GG's) simple point was that the % of stated nutrients in fertilizers has nothing to do with solubility. That was one of the two points I commented on, and the best argument I saw was that you introduced the word 'usually' - but that doesn't mesh well with an absolute statement like he made or your observation that blanket statements are misleading. ;o)

    We also kind of glossed over the 'filler' thing, so I'm guessing it is quite acceptable to say that the 80 lbs of superfluous ingredients in 100 lbs. of the best 5-5-5 synthetic can indeed be appropriately labeled 'filler'.

    Those were the only two points I wanted to offer thoughts on. I don't see convincing focused argument against either. I really don't feel like broadening the discussion into other areas unrelated, as it's likely to produce more heat than light; so having had you suffer my say, I'll offer the last word(s) to whomever would like it.

    Take good care.

    Al

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    dchall, I have to compliment you on your effort :-) And while I do appreciate all the work and math you went through to arrive at this conclusion....I have some doubts on it's complete accuracy. I don't claim to have a degree in chemistry or even more than a passing understanding - my college chemistry classes were a long time ago - but there seems to be a few flaws in your logic. First, you are assuming that the breakdown in the chemical components will be pure and that one will be left with with the various chemical elements in the weights you have arrived at. The most glaring example is the hydrogen and oxygen.....based on your calculations, one would have about 30 pounds of gaseous materials in that bag of fertilizer - in essence, air! That's gonna be one whopping big bag of fert!!

    Regarding the actual contents of a bag of commercially prepared synthetic fertilizer you wrote.....
    I thought I had explained this twice before but I can do it in more detail. To summarize, the entire mass of material in the bag is chemicals. There is no room for fillers.

    Of course the entire mass is chemicals! Everything IS, in one form or another. The dang fillers you dispute are chemicals!! But the entire mass is not typically comprised 100% of the breakdown of the chemical compounds that eventually provide the the plant nutrients. A lot of these chemicals are in fact part of the inert ingredients - absolutely necessary as a chemical source (generally in compound) of the desired plant nutrients but providing little, if any, benefits to the plants themselves. I guess a better term for these are 'carriers' - the more complex chemical compounds from which the desired plant macro and micro nutrients are eventually distilled. That does not negate the fact, however, that a great deal of other material is often added as a means of arriving at a uniform mix of product (and a prescribed weight) so that the desired chemicals - the NPK - can be distributed evenly. These are the fillers I referred to and whose existence you deny.

    You don't believe me, that's obvious. Would you believe The Fertilizer Institute? Or is this association of fertilizer manufacturers making up a bunch of stuff as well or misunderstanding exactly what they are including in the product they're selling? One could reasonably assume that somewhere in their manufacturing facility, there's a scientist or two with at least a passing familiarity of chemistry.

    How much N, P and K are in your bag of fertilizer? The analysis found on each bag or bulk shipment of fertilizer tells the farmer or consumer the amount of nutrients being supplied. States have a system of laws and regulations that ensure the fertilizer is properly labeled and delivers the amount of nutrients stated to the farmer or consumer.

    The three numbers on your bag of fertilizer are referred to as the "analysis." It is the percentage of nitrogen, phosphate and potash that is available to plants from that bag of fertilizer. In this diagram, this product contains 5 percent nitrogen, 10 percent phosphate and 5 percent potash.

    So what's the other 80 percent of what's in this bag? While brands vary, typically the rest will contain some micronutrients and filler material, which allows for even application of the nutrients across the fertilized area. (emphasis is mine)

    Of course the issue is what exactly are these fillers. As explained previously, they can be a variety of materials. And you are right in assuming that there is a chemical component - everything can be broken down into some assortment of chemical elements, even sand. Excluding what micronutrients may be included (and they tend to be present in relatively small quantities) they could indeed be salts, chlorides, polymers and/or a variety of minerals. Even some organic matter, like the sawdust. Or industrial waste. Hence the issue with disclosure of these materials and the EPA. But to assume that the entire contents of a bag of commercial synthetic fertilizer is totally comprised of the various chemicals that provide the guaranteed analysis of the 3 major plant nutrients is simply a false assumption. There is a lot of other stuff in there - the inert and/or filler ingredients. And they are there for a purpose, primarily to aid in the ease of distribution of the desired chemical components, the NPK.

    And their presence is pretty well documented. From the University of Tennessee Extension Service:

    For example, if we have a 50-pound bag of 10-10-10, there are 5 pounds of N, 5 pounds of P2O5 and 5 pounds of K2O. To convert the P2O5 to actual elemental P, multiply it by 0.44; to convert the K2O to actual K, multiply it by 0.83. The other 35 pounds of the fertilizer material is filler or the carrier material of the fertilizer ore. The filler or carrier helps to evenly spread the fertilizer and avoid burning plants with too much fertilizer. A 50-pound bag of fertilizer labeled 0-20-20 would have 0 pounds of N, 10 pounds of P2O5, 10 pounds of K2O and 30 pounds of filler or carrier material. Various materials are used as fillers. Some common ones are: pelleted biosolids, attapulgite clay, vermiculite, montmorillonite, fuller's earth and diatomaceous earth. (again, emphasis is mine)

    And a couple of other links that clearly outline similar statements.

    http://www.in.gov/idem/files/appe-fertilizer_labels.pdf

    The remainder of the contents in a fertilizer container is comprised of a mixture of one or more "secondary nutrients" (i.e., calcium, magnesium, and sulfur), "micro-nutrients" or as they are sometimes referred to as "trace" elements, (i.e., boron, chlorine, copper, iron, manganese, molybdenum, and zinc), and a filler material (generally sand or granular limestone).

    http://www.agr.state.nc.us/cyber/kidswrld/plant/label.htm

    To calculate the pounds of nitrogen in a 50-lb bag of 10-10-10 fertilizer, multiply 50 by 0.10. Do the same for calculating the amounts of phosphate and potash. A 50-lb bag of 10-10-10 contains a total of 15 lbs of nutrients: 5 lbs nitrogen, 5 lbs phosphate and 5 lbs potash. The remaining weight is filler, usually sand or granular limestone.
    Another example:

    50-lb. bag of 8-0-24 fertilizer

    To calculate the pounds of nitrogen: Multiply 50 by .08, which equals 4.
    To calculate the pounds of phosphate: There is no phosphate in this bag of fertilizer.
    To calculate the pounds of potash: Multiply 50 by .24, which equals 12.
    A 50 pound bag of 8-0-24 fertilizer contains a total of 16 lbs of nutrients: 4 lbs nitrogen, 0 lbs phosphate, and 12 lbs potash. This would leave us with 34 lbs of filler.

    I could show you a few dozen others, but I trust you get the point.

    And btw, the primary nutrient content of an organic fertilizer is not estimated. It is measured and disclosed - as required by law - on the fertilizer label. This is the guaranteed analysis and means that the nutrient is present in at least the minimum percentage as stated on the label.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Fertilizer Institute - facts and stats

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I really don't know crap from crapolla when it comes to the nitty gritty of fertilizer but I was curious this morning and googled fillers in fertilizers. I stopped looking after about the sixth different site that said there were, in fact, various fillers in some fertilizers. Kinda put an end to that particular debate good enough for me.

    Not that I doubted you GG48. :-)

    Lloyd

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "The most glaring example is the hydrogen and oxygen.....based on your calculations, one would have about 30 pounds of gaseous materials in that bag of fertilizer - in essence, air! That's gonna be one whopping big bag of fert!!"

    And you're claiming you took chemistry at college level? Nitrogen is a gas too you know, *unless* it's part of something like ammonium sulfate.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Duh!! And that is entirely the point which totally negates dchall's contention that the 100# bag of fertilizer contains 100% of chemicals he has attributed to it and nothing more. The 100 pound dry weight, as it comes from the factory, can't possibly have 30 pounds of material (ignoring the nitrogen at the moment for the sake of argument) that are gases in their elemental state. The mole is primarily a unit of mass or substance rather than weight and a direct correlation per mole to weight is totally invalid with gaseous substances which are measured by volume, not weight. This is a basic principle of Avogadro's Law. A mole of any gas (at a standard temperature and pressure) will have a volume of 22.4 liters. Given this basic scientific principle, dchall's example of 5.13 lbs of hydrogen in the Scotts fertilizer product would occupy some 52,000 liters or the equivalent of 1840 cubic feet. And as I said, that's one whopping big bag of fertilizer.

    If the gases (H, N, O) are bound to some other chemical in compound and not in their gaseous state, that's a totally different issue and goes right back to the orginial contention. A 100lb bag of fertilizer does not necessarily contain 100lbs of the chemicals that will eventually provide the plant nutrients. The point is you CANNOT make a direct correlation between breaking down the chemical components of a bag a fertilizer into their basic elements and their molecular/molar weight and then convert that to pounds or grams or any other standard weight unit of measurement.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    DCHall - there was actually one more ingredient listed on the MSDS sheet for that Scott's product that you did not mention - Nuisance Dust - which is also called an inert ingredient. Check it out.

    Here is a link that might be useful: MSDS

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I back calculated dchall's ammonium phosphate and urea from the label 31% N and am wondering, was it DAP, MAP, a liquid or some formulation I haven't heard of yet :) Any help GG48?

    BTW, i just love my copy of the Western Fertilizer Handbook and recommend it to all. Alot of very useful stuff not related to fertilizer also.

    And I thought the thread about composting dog poop in the soils forum was lengthy.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Y'all are hilarious! I guess gaseous elements have negative mass. Bwahahahahahaha!

    The point is you CANNOT make a direct correlation between breaking down the chemical components of a bag a fertilizer into their basic elements and their molecular/molar weight and then convert that to pounds or grams or any other standard weight unit of measurement.

    LOL!!! Yes! You can.

    I can see there will always be a future for people interested in science and math. Gardengal, please don't bring your level of teaching to Texas. We have enough trouble as it is.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gardengal, please don't bring your level of teaching to Texas. We have enough trouble as it is.

    That's unfair. Gardengal you can come to Texas any time. You really do have a lot of good stuff to say. And you can call it 'filler' if you want. I'm probably the only person you'll ever come across who's sensitive about that word.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    DC hall - I am still confused. The MSDS sheet lists nuisance (inert) dusts, and mentions Crystalline silica (quartz, sand). It does not say how much might or might not be an inert dust, it only lists the threshold limits for dusts containing less than 1% crystalline silica. So - in fact - there is "filler" (inerts) in this product that contains less than 1% crystalline silica , no?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gaseous elements with a negative mass?? Where'd you come up with that? What negative mass? You're the one that listed gaseous elements in terms of weight. By making a simple mathematical conversion from your assigned weight to volume, which is the only valid and meaningful measurement for a gas, by your calculations the hydrogen element in that bag of fertilizer would occupy an enormous space. Where exactly is the 'negative mass' involved in that?

    "We have three variables by which we measure gases: pressure, volume, and temperature. Volume is related between all gases by Avogadro's hypothesis, which states: Equal volumes of gases at the same temperature and pressure contain equal numbers of molecules. From this, we derive the molar volume of a gas (volume/moles of gas). This value, at 1 atm, and 0 C is shown below.

    Vm=V/n=22.4L

    Where:
    Vm = molar volume
    V = Volume in liters
    n = moles

    Solving for V with 2327 moles (the equivalent of your 5.13lbs), you have the hydrogen in that bag of fertilizer occupying 52,000+ liters (and this is negative mass.....how??). So how can you possibly validate your claim that you can make a direct breakdown of the ingredients in a bag of fertilizer to their elemental components and still come up with with your 100lbs? I don't know what kind of math YOU learned, but I'd be a little bit afraid of it.

    dchall, you have taken a great of delight in mocking me and my statements despite how well documented or supported they may be and have gone through some bizarre mathematical gyrations that don't seem to hold water in a rather futile attempt to prove yours. So far, you have failed and YOU are the one that appears to have egg on your face. The bottom line is that the chemical elements in a bage of fertilizer CANNOT be broken down into their pure forms until after chemical reactions take place to breakdown the compounds they are comprised of. This happens AFTER application - not while in the bag - through nitrification, mineralization, and the actions of moisture and temperature. Ergo, your 100lb bag of 100lbs of pure chemical elements is just not happening.

    And as to the 'fillers'.....ekgrows has pointed out they exist in this bag (yup, there's that sand I was referring to!) and since the MSDS declines to provide quantities, one can reasonably assume they make up a good percentage, especially since your chemical elements don't.

    How about we just bow out of this particular discussion now since it seems to have strayed very far off-topic from the OP's orginal question, for which I believe he received a satisfactory answer sometime ago.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    DC hall - I am still confused. The MSDS sheet lists nuisance (inert) dusts, and mentions Crystalline silica (quartz, sand). It does not say how much

    When you add filler you dilute the other ingredients. Say you added 5 pounds of sand to the bag I analyzed above. The only way to keep the NPK ratios would be to completely eliminate the ferrous sulfate, manganese oxide, and manganese sulfate. If you added more than 5 pounds of filler, then you cut into the NPK ingredients. When you reduce those you cannot possibly achieve the listed percentages for NPK. The total NPK percentages are what is listed on the bag by WEIGHT of the bag. I suppose you could put 4 pounds of sand and a few ounces each of the iron and manganese materials and keep the label honest, but beyond that you are diluting the NPK.

    Here's how you use fillers. You buy 5 pounds of 10-10-10 fertilizer. You put 5 pounds of crushed corn cobs along with the fertilizer into a 10-pound bag and sell it as 5-5-5. I just don't see that going on. Gardengal has more access to brands, so maybe she sees it all the time.

    Bowing out, but I'll leave you with this. After your gas discussion, your invitation to Texas is withdrawn until you bring a note from your chemistry teacher.

    I learned my math in 4 years of aerospace engineering, 2 years of operations research, 18 months of the calculus of probability and statistics, and a year of the calculus of human physiology. Then I spent 28 years using the math as a rocket scientist, medical research facility designer, and jet engine engineer. If I've made an error in my numbers, please bring your chemistry teacher to show me. Your gas theory doesn't work because we're talking about the mass of ionic salt crystals in a bag, not the volume of individual atoms allowed to reach a pressure equilibrium with the atmosphere. I did not mean to set you up for this but you grabbed the ball and ran with it all by yourself. While you are still running, run your volume calcs on NaCl, sodium chloride, table salt. Remember that one pound of the stuff comes in a package that's about a quart in size - and there are no gas bags attached. Na (a highly reactive metal) is 40% by weight and Cl (a gas) is 60% by weight.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You're right dchall, when you add filler the NPR ratio become diluted. In that Scott's LawnPro Step 4 fertilizer, most all the constituents are supplying plant nutrients. No filler is needed in that mix.

    If the lawn needed only a little potassium, we'd want a fertilizer that delivers a small percentage of potassium so it's easier to distribute and we don't risk overapplication. Scott's only needs one or two chemicals to carry the K, so they add cheap filler instead of expensive synthesized chemicals to dilute to the mass K percentage we want.

    I don't think anyone is saying that all your fertilizers are full of sand and sawdust. We're just saying that you'd have a hard time if some weren't.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    DC: It was a joke about the MAP and DAP, sorry you missed it. No, I'm not going to explain it tonight. BTW, I could care less who "wins" the debate but I hope to fully understand both sides in the end, where they were correct and where they were incorrect. A good bit of news is that we don't have to fully understand how fertilizer works to use it effectively and efficiently.