Software
Houzz Logo Print
tjg911

bone meal / phosphorus

20 years ago

i bought a 5 pound bag last spring. i remember someone saying there is a much cheaper product than store bought bone meal. i use it for root crops for the phosphorus. anyone have any suggestions? i am organic so naturally at this forum i'd expect an organic product.

thanks,

tom

Comments (6)

  • 20 years ago

    tom,
    i don't know about price, but for a few years now i've been reading about rock phosphate as a better source of phosphorus. there are probably several reasons why it's regarded as better, but the one that sticks in my mind is thati it's simply powdered rock that's high in phosphorus. since the basis of soil is broken down rock anyway, it seems like a good way to enhance fertility. i used bone meal for years but now feel better about rock phosphate because it takes animals out of the equation. i don't think the prions that cause mad cow are killed at the temperatures they use to steam bone meal. and the unhealthy and unnatural way animals are raised,it might be better to stay away from using their body parts anyway. rock phosphate is a slow release form of P, and i think it only needs to be applied every couple of years. i don't know if this is what you're looking for, but maybe it'll help.

    debbie

  • 20 years ago

    I don't think you can get much cheaper than bonemeal. The only way is to buy it in bulk. I order it in 50-lb bags through my local nursery. I think the last one I ordered was spring 2005, and it was $19.99. I go through about one bag a year, and I grow a *LOT* of plants. I live on 11 acres, with probably a half-acre of that in vegetable and perennial gardens. Bone meal is typically 3-2-0.5, and 24% calcium.

    I use a bit of greensand as well for some slow-release potassium and trace minerals, but most of my potassium needs are supplied by wood ash. Rock phosphate sounds like it might be a good minor supplement as well for slow-release phosphorous. A web search revealed a 50 lb bag for $14.95 with 3-8% available phosphorous and 48% calcium. I probably wouldn't use it as my only source of phosphorous though. Also, a natural gardening book I have says that it raises the soil pH a bit.

    In any case, find a cooperative local nursery to order things for you in 50 lb bags and have it brought on their regular deliveries. Otherwise, shipping costs are murder.

  • 20 years ago

    Most all soils have way more phophorus than we could use in a lifetime. The only problem is that these same soils are usually so lacking in organic matter that that phosphorus is unavailable. Rather than spend money on something that is not needed add organic matter to your soil. Get a soil test before adding any soil amendment except compost.

  • 20 years ago

    Kimmsr is correct that many soils already have adequate phosphorus, but may not be available to plants due to electrical bonding between P and soil.
    Scroll down to the article in the link below titled "The Rhizosphere, The Space of Magic and Mystery" By Jon Cloud for more information.
    What is needed to break the bonds and make P available to plants is biological activity that would accompany soils rich in organic matter, as Kimmsr also mentioned.
    If the proper microbes are not already in your soil, you can, in addition to adding more organic matter, purchase or make your own mycorrhizal innoculant, which would introduce symbiotic fungi that would mine P and other nutrients from the soil to feed the plants without having to add additional P amendments.
    For more info about arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus:
    http://www2.ctahr.hawaii.edu/oc/freepubs/pdf/SCM-5.pdf

    Overfertilization with N and P have caused major problems in aquatic ecosystems, including eutrophication, toxic algal blooms, fish kills, loss of biodiversity, etc. See EPA article:
    http://www.epa.gov/watertrain/pdf/issue3.pdf

    In addition, the rock phosphate mentioned above by debbie is a finite non-renewable resource. See article:
    http://www.fao.org/documents/show_cdr.asp?url_file=/docrep/007/y5053e/y5053e05.htm

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rhizosphere

  • 20 years ago

    good lord! mad cow/bones? never considered that! the use of the bones did not bother me as i use fish emulsion. i'm a vegetarian but not so strict these issues would be taboo. the cost of bone meal is more reasonable as you buy a larger amount, 5 pounds is the smallest and no doubts the most expensive way to buy it. last year i used just 2.5 pounds but i forget if i used it for anything other than potatoes. excellent crop, best ever for yields. however, i also used a soaker hose for the 1st time so i am not sure if the water was more responsible than the bone meal. i suspect the water was really far more helpful.

    my soil has a ph of 6.6 - 6.8 so i really don't want to be raising the ph, i do not add wood ash (tho i have a lot of it) to the soil. rock phosphate i have heard of but as i want the P where this year's root crops are i don't want something that works over time as much as something that is readily available now. my soil is high in organic matter so poor soil is definately not my problem. not that i have a problem! i just thought a boost for the roots was good for root crops like potatoes, carrots, onions, rutabagas, radishes, turnips.

    i was interested in the link provided but the site is blocked here at work. getting that is a no no!

    anyone else have options on bone meal safety re prions?

    tom

  • 20 years ago

    The safety issue of bone meal has a political angle. As a consequence of BSE, the Canada / US border has been closed to meat products, including bone meal. So US prices may be going done (glut to local markets) and Canadian prices are higher. A major meat processor here in Ontario has begun to produce bone and blood meal fertilizers as a result of the new demand.

    To contribute to your question of the safety of bone meal. There is really very little research on the subject. During the mad cow crisis in the UK, at least one professional gardener contracted BSE as a result of breathing in powdered raw, powdered bone meal from local slaughterhouses. BSE was a widespread problem in England at that time-- far more animals were affected there than have ever been affected here-- although we don't know for sure because the inspection regime here is extremely pro-business and anti-public safety.

    The bone meal that is sold commercially in North America is highly processed (which is partly why is it not permitted by most organic certifying organizations). The bones are boiled, steamed, dried, crushed and pelletized. It is not known whether the steaming temperatures kill any prions that may have entered the system.

    Remember that that an infected prion would have to be ingested to do you harm. You would need to either swallow it, or breathe it in.

    I started to write about the conditions of the animals in factory farms, but I won't open that can of fish. Let's just say that these are sick, sad, drugged creatures. On the other hand, bone meal re-uses organic material that would otherwise go to the landfill.

    If you can find a local source of ground bones from an organic livestock producer-- great. But most of these producers just compost their carcasses. The equipment to process them into useable bone and blood meal is too expensive, and the market is (still) too small.

    In the end, it is a personal decision, based on health, environmental, and political reasons.