Software
Houzz Logo Print
richdelmo

Transplants mixture damages soil?

16 years ago

Something recently came to mind that I am posting on the winter sowing forum and the organic gardening forum. Over the past few years IÂve changed much of my gardens to all organic. With winter sowing all my seedlings are started with Miracle Grow potting mix. So when I transplant, whatever amount of miracle grow mixture that is in the potting mix naturally goes into the gardens. IÂm now thinking this is doing the garden soil damage as far as being organic is concerned so I probably should use a starting mixture that does not have any chemical additive. For those who follow organic growing methods would you agree with my thoughts and if not why not.

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    What would be the reason for the damage, given the ratio of starting mix to extant soil?

    Surely it could be argued that your home garden cannot be certified organic if that is what you wish to achieve, but damage? Nah.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    Even this very expensive potting soil is simply mostly peat moss (a non renewable resource), maybe finely ground tree bark, maybe Coconut hulls (coir), all organic matter. While using products from this company is antithetical to many of us organic gardners there are organic people that do use it with no qualms. I doubt that what your seedlings were started in would have that much overall affeect on your soil, good, or bad.

  • 16 years ago

    kimmsr brings up a good point - there are things in that potting mix that are not chemical additives that still rankle the folks who think about sustainability and ecosystem health and footprints and EROEI and such...

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    kimmsr, you say peat moss is a non renewable resource which I've read before, but for years I used to spread a large bag of it on each of my gardens every spring a practice which I stopped several years ago. Since it is non renewable what good or bad is it doing in my soil now? Nothing I can do right?

  • 16 years ago

    i realy can't see any problem apart from the peat moss issue, i buy seedlings to plant but the bit of medium with each seedling is not going to make any difference to my organic medium.

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: lens garden page

  • 16 years ago

    Dan.....while I am not a purist I do not accept half truths either. Any man made chemical in any amount is poison to the mycro herd. They can not live with the posions. When using the harsh chemicals in the soil, on the soil or on the plants we harm the very living biolgy we must have to maintain when rebuilding the soil. This simply translates to the phrase....healthy soil makes healthy plants and excellent quality food.

    Gardeners and small plot folks can and are effectively rebuilding with out the constant use of more poisons. Some have become so good at it that they have or could certify organic. The movement is well and good.

  • 16 years ago

    Any man made chemical in any amount is poison to the mycro herd. They can not live with the posions.

    I shall tell all the soil scientists & folks who work with soil fauna of this new knowledge of yours, this breakthrough in chemistry. Where have you published this new discovery of yours?

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    First, I'd encourage the OP not to take everything written here at face value. There are some personal agendas being promoted that really have very little to do with reality.

    Second, when dealing with the natural world, it all has to do with dosage. Everything is relative. Small amounts of man-made chemicals will have only minor impact on the vast populations of organisms that exist in the soil and that impact is typically very temporary. Even many so-called organic products and remedies can damage or destroy soil microbiology and larger beneficials if applied unnecessarily, without understanding of their impact or in excess. Just working in and walking on your soil has the ability to destroy vast quantities of microorganisms but they repopulate themselves very rapidly.

    While I wouldn't use the MG potting soil for seed starting for a variety of reasons, the impact it will have on your soil from your transplants is minimal and will be remediated rapidly. As to the peat moss issue, Canadian sourced peat moss IS renewable (and that's nearly all the peat moss sold in north America), you can use it without concern in your gardens and it does work very well as a soil amendment.

  • 16 years ago

    rich, Peat Moss is a non renewable resource because of the length of time needed to replace what is harvested from the bogs, more than your lifetime. Many of us have all around us, and are given every year, tremendous quantities of a renewable resource of organic matter those leaves that fall from trees that is greatly underused and undervalued. Every year I see people expend large amounts of time and energy raking up this renewable resource, putting it into bags, and paying someone to haul them away to a landfill where they become pollutants and then in the spring buy some peat moss to replace what they threw away in the fall.
    Peat moss does not replace those leaves since peat moss is devoid of any nutrients, about the only thing peat moss might do for soil is increase the moisture holding capability some which those leaves will do plus those leaves will add nutrients, feed the Soil Food Web. There is some research that does indicate that the Soil Food Web will not eat peat moss until there is nothing else left to eat, which may be why some of us find evidence of peat moss still in our soil many years after planting something that grew in the potting soil.

  • 16 years ago

    Some folks just seem to have closed minds when it comes to this issue despite all the literature that is published contrary to their very narrow-minded views.

    "Peat is renewable and in terms of its accumulation, peat in Canada is growing more than 70 times as fast as it is being harvested. [According to an issue paper entitled "Canadian Peat Harvesting and the Environment," published by the North American Wetlands Conservation Council (Canada)] Even though Canada does not have peat supply concerns, the industry is looking for ways to accelerate peat bog regeneration. Until recently, peat bogs have been left to regenerate, a process that can take up to 20 years. New research in ways to restore bogs quickly, indicates that time can be shortened to five to eight years." (emphasis mine) btw, the North American Wetlands Conservation Council is an environmental group that has no commercial interest in the Canadian peat industry.

    One of the biggest advantages of using peat as a soil amendment is its ability to further decompose very slowly, much more slowly than other organic matter. This allows it to perform its functions of aeration and moisture retention more efficiently and for a far longer period than just adding compost.

    Regardless, the amount of peat contained in any kind of seed starting or potting soil that gets transferred to the garden with transplants is inconsequential with regards to contributing nutrients or not (it IS a soil amendment afterall, not a fertilizer). That's not its intent so why that issue is raised is immaterial. Same with the leaves - they are not commonly used for seed starting (nor should they be) and the amount of fallen leaves that actually winds up in landfills is about nil. Virtually all areas of the country have both municipal and residential yard waste recycling that result in compost, if not the leaves used as mulch or compost on site.

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, some people do seem to have a closed mind about this issue. Accepting only what the industry, the harvesters and sellers of a product, has to say about that product is an indication. That horticulturists and soil scientist throughout the world have determined peat moss is a non renewable resource and that based on that the Royal Horticultural Society has strongly recommended its members not use peat moss does not seem to be of any value for some.

  • 16 years ago

    The RHS is UK-based and the peat they are referring to comes from their own endangered, over-harvested peat bogs. And under those circumstances, gardeners in the UK (or elsewhere in Europe) who do not have easy access to Canadian peat are well-advised to avoid using - what is in those locations - a non-renewable product.

    It is an entirely different set of circumstances with regards to the Canadian peat industry, which - as very obviously stated above and can be easily researched - is a model world-wide for restoration and renewability of peat. One cannot make valid or meaningful comparisions between the Canadian peat industry and similar acitivites elsewhere in the world.

    And as to closed mindedness.......how many times is it necessary to regurgitate that is only the "industry, the harvesters and sellers of a product" that make this claim when it is patently not true?? Anyone with a brain, a semi-open mind and a computer and basic research skills can confirm this.

    I'd suggest everyone do their own research and draw their own conclusions and don't rely on the same, tired, unresearched dogma that is repeated by the same, unenlightened individuals ad nauseum.