Software
Houzz Logo Print
plantphreak_ca

No Impact Man

19 years ago

Have you heard about this guy? Living in New York, he has decided to see if he can have no impact on the planet. None, zilch, zip. No motorized transportation, no electricity, no new stuff, nothing to eat that isn't locally grown or comes in "packaging". Okay, he can do that. One thing I cannot even begin to understand though. No TOILET PAPER! I could give up a lot, but toilet paper? I don't think so!

Here is a link that might be useful: No Impact Man

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    plantphreak, you could use a peice of bread. LOL
    He is using flour, an oven. What heats the oven?
    He's not all the way to no impact i don't think.
    Remember when so many people went to living completely off the land, years ago?
    vickie

  • 19 years ago

    I don't know if this is the same guy, but I read about a couple trying to do approximately the same thing in NYC about a month ago & apparently there are groups of people all over the country attempting this & blogging about it.

    IMO these people are just as bad as those who drive behemoth SUV's and proclaim that there really isn't a problem with the environment. They all seem to be setting themselves up as people who are, well maybe better than everyone else isn't precisely the right term, but that's how it comes off. Plus they can also be martyrs while they're being so "environmentally correct." (The giving up of toilet paper always seems to invoke the same reaction).

    However as Vickie says, unless they choose to live in a cave & forage for nuts & berries & not wear any kinds of clothing, they are making some kind of impact. They'd be doing more good if they were working with the owner of their apartment building to put in solar panels or trying to eliminate the diesel fuel belching buses from the streets of NYC. Right now, besides bringing a bit of publicity to themselves, they're really making no positive environmental impact whatsoever.

  • 19 years ago

    He's ok I guess, but I'm more impressed by those who go about quietly and do whatever it is they try to do to improve their own lives,the lives of others or the environment. We all know people like this who seem to have no need to tell the world via a blog or anything else about their efforts.

  • 19 years ago

    Using no electricity except for a solar panel to power his computer might be considered a step in the right direction.

    Bidets may or may not be considered a substitute for TP, but they do use water in addition to the toilet's use, thus contributing to water pollution. He would make a more effective impact by using a solar-powered [battery] incinolet.

    I'm always of divided opinion when reading about this sort of effort. I'm glad that another somebody is realizing that if we really want an improvement in the environment, it will require every individual to make a change in lifestyle. I'm one of those who believes that the change doesn't have to be back to nuts-and-berries-foraging; if everyone would stop being so unthinkingly and needlessly wasteful now, we could probably clean up most of the pollutants within the next few years --- few as in five, not as in 2050.

  • 19 years ago

    No TP, I'm not going to shake hands with him.

  • 19 years ago

    LOLOL. Thanks Gandle for putting into words what I was thinking. We could go a very, very long distance into reducing our impact on this planet by simply wasting less. We pour out gargantuan amounts of fossil fuel to power lights bleeding upward into the heavens, for example. Our builders could start engineering homes with proper orientation to light. I suspect any one of us could think of a hundred ways if we gave it any consideration.

    I don't think a move to be less environmentally damaging means science or technology should be trashed, either. It's a double edged sword and the same technology driving the consumer can be channeled into constructive ways to maintain a good lifestyle on less. I am practically a Luddite, but I won't give up my computer or my dishwasher for example. They are efficient appliances I can use to good advantage. IOW their impact is small compared to their value for my lifestyle. IOW, just making good choices of how you wish to use energy and material is a step in the right direction.

    In every movement there are zealots. They have a place in raising public awareness. Hopefully some good will come of it before the impetus dies, because for many I suspect it's a fad and they'll soon tire of it. Changing a lifestyle does not come over weeks or months, but over years of making small adaptations until that's just the way one lives. Those changes were made of necessity during the world wars and the Great Depression and look at the mark it left on one generation. So, let them blog away.......at least it gets people thinking. Let's also not be too quick to lump those who are joining the movement as fruitcakes or with some other label, or second guess their intentions. Most people who think out of the box about an issue come across as strange, but for every turn of events in our history, there have been those people who do and there is usually something to be gained from the experience. In our own GW there is a new Forum called Going Green. One topic was homeowners creating their own greywater systems. It's not a crazy idea, it's inspired and conventional thinking has squelched it so far with antiquated and stifling laws at local levels. I lived in one old farmhouse with a greywater system. It was there when I moved in, and there when I left. I lived in that house for twelve years and the septic system never needed pumped or repaired and the time it took the earth to purify and recharge good pure groundwater was drastically reduced. Every flush of our toilets mix pure potable water with foul waste and by having greywater systems we don't add thousands of gallons of clean but unpotable water to the tanks to be contaminated.


  • 19 years ago

    I think I heard about him...didn't Good Morning America do a story on him? Seems like I heard it as I was running out the door :)

    I don't think he was planning on doing this long term. It sounded to me like it was an experiment for his family to see what they could live without.

    I was very impressed at the amount of entertaining they did. They talked about how they had people over and they played games and just got to know one another. He talked about how much closer his family was since they no longer had some of the distractions of a busy "modern" life.

    It reminds me a little of the families that sign up for the PBS shows where they go back to a certain time in history. Most of those families seemed to have grown from that experience and I imagine his family will too.

    He was turning off the electricity after the interview. I'm not sure I could take it that far :)

    I laughed at Sheryl Crowe's idea of one piece of tp...none? I DON'T THINK SO!! :)

    Lisa

  • 19 years ago

    If he wants to call this his path, so be it.
    He's just tired of the world as he knows it and is doing something besides just griping about it.
    He'll learn (and teach...) as he goes and maybe he will at least find peace and perhaps contentment in a more quiet life.
    Anything that leads to introspection and growth is good in my book.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio