Software
Houzz Logo Print
claritamaria

Spag & Bag Alernative?

19 years ago

I have this:

{{gwi:176489}}

Broke off when I was moving plants outdoors. Bagged it for about 2 weeks but saw that the part of the bulb in the spag was lightening up. But it has remaied firm, while the rest of the bulb is beinning to dessicate. What is the best way to get some roots on this?

I was originally thinking

1) an alternative to spag and bag- some modification or spag & bag alternative techique that someone has stumbled on? My conditions are usually humid.

2) Since I've observed that the portion in spag has remained firm, maybe I have to bury this up to the leaves? But with what? Spag? Rock?

3) Is it even possible to get this going in the direction of a plant? I am not experienced with kei kei;s or seedlings. Done some BB propagation but they had roots.

Spag stays very wet for a long time at time of year for me. Feel the need to learn something. If it doesn't make it I won't be upset.

With all the water growing discussions going on I am not wondering if that would be a way to go? Perhaps with tooth picks? or even a bag and no spag? anyone ever tried it? I have rock, pumice, tree fern and bark

Clara

PS The GW email is fritzing out again. If anyone else is having this problem, please report it

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    The alternative, i'm sad to say is probably the garbage bin. As for the water culture thing. i've no doubt it would work. But as with all the other methods the question that has to be asked is??
    Why do most people grow orchids in pots? The show season has started here and most of the orchids exhibited at numerous shows will be in a pot.

    That is not to say that a bit of fiddling, experimenting is out of order and sometimes compromises work well, such as a bit of water in a cache pot.

    As for the Vanda (it is actually an Ascocendra) with its roots growing in the glasshouse gutter. Though the plant looks fine. If it flowers after the ten year period there will have to be some drastic surgery if i want to take it to an orchid society meeting.

  • 19 years ago

    Geez Clara, do you really need *that*?! Arthur's right... GARBAGE!!!

    Shouldn't be worth your time, unless it is worth A LOT!!!

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    {{gwi:176490}}I have one very similar to yours, a backbulb from an Encyclia profusa that has just finished blooming and had 2 new growths. I removed the backbulb to move the plant toward the edge and leave room for the new growth without up potting.

    This backbulb had leaves but no roots and no active eyes. I started it in rock, which is what has worked well for me. I have put it down under the bench in reduced light and just leave it there. There is a layer of rock under the backbulb. It will get water daily and the rock will keep the humidity next to the backbulb high.

    Chances are pretty good that this will eventually take off. As soon as I see new growth I will start increasing the light to normal levels. If this were not a collectible orchid I would have trashed it, but I have friends who would love to have it.

    If this is an orchid you want to keep, or you need the practice for a time when you get a scruffy backbulb from a really nice orchid, give it more time. In fact, as long as it doesn't dry out completely it might come back. Orchids are very hardy.

  • 19 years ago

    Did it ever occur to anyone that I may not be interested in orchids purely for the bloom? I love the growing process more. I view flowers as a bonus or a result. Clearly the 2 of you don't share that POV and that is fine. We each have our reasons for growing orchids. If I want to make science experiments in my spare time, why not? Something to learn. Like I said, if it croaks it, then it does...

    My opportunity to expertiment on this, than something of value.

    Clara

  • 19 years ago

    Clara, don't get in a 'huf' - try a little damp sphag in a small pot and sit the bulb on top. Clip it to keep it from rocking. Keep in a lit area (no sun) and wait and wait. If it works, you'll see a growth begin. Then move to good light.

    Keep the sphag loose and damp. I've had better luck doing it this way than bagging.

    An old timer at my OS gave me two backbulbs from Enc. Alata Majus (have no idea if anything good, but he seemed to think it was gold.) Tried his method of bagging and one bulb began to rot. Have the other once sitting on sphag and its still firm and green.

    Good luck,
    Jane

  • 19 years ago

    The Encyclia alata var majus is warm to hot growing, large-flowered, fragrant summer bloomer from Mexico and Central America. Definitely a collectible orchid. Not really rare, but one I don't have and I collect Encyclia.

  • 19 years ago

    Clara,

    Sphag & bag haven't worked for me, nor has plain sphag, as it has for you, Jane. Things just rotted. User error for sure.

    Right now I'm trying a rootless Promenea in bark in plastic, w/ the pot in an opaque S/H pot w/ stones & water in the bottom. When I went to repot it after it bloomed, there were no roots but 4-5 pbs, 3 w/ leaves, and one new growth starting. It's in reduced light now.

    Richardol, going on your set-up, it might be better off in stones.

    Clara, let us know how your experiment goes.

    Whitecat8

  • 19 years ago

    Don't know about your plant - if it can be saved or not, but I don't like the bag and sphag method either. I now use the "Tray O Sphag" method. I put some damp sphag in a shallow tray, lay the plant on top and maybe cover key areas of the plant with a few strands of sphag. The sphag dries out almost daily, but that's what I want. I like all the air movement and the fact I can control the dampness. I'm using this method with a dead Dend at the moment that decided to put out a couple of keikies. The old canes of the Dend aren't rotting and the keikis are growing nicely.

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    What Kev does is what I do with problem ctsms. Works like a charm every time!

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Hi
    i use an old aquarium for a cutting shed .For orchids i sit them on top of some tree fern. Use grill work to keep plants out of the water. Keep the humidity at around 80 percent .Uncover during the day. Nice as you can either use natural or artificial light. No direct sun of course.
    gary

  • 19 years ago

    Another method that I've had success with is "sphag in a bottle". I take a 2-liter soda bottle, clean it really well, cut it half so you have a top and a bottom, put a couple inches of moist sphag on the bottom, insert orchid backbulb (I use a bamboo skewer to hold it upright), set the top back on it so it looks like a bottle again and secure it with some tape, unscrew the cap so it can ventilate, and stick it in a north window for indirect light. It's worked every time for me.

    -ken

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations