Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacinh_gw

phals dying after flowering

16 years ago

Hi,

I have been growing phals and have gone from killing them soon after I bought them to getting them to put out flower stems. My most recent problem is that when my phals flower, they would start to have limp leaves from the bottom, and eventually yellow and fall off. The phals are otherwise healthy (at least before flowering).

The last one only had a few flowers (4) and died soon after all flowers open. I looked at the root and they seem to be okay, no rot (i have killed a few due to watering too much).

My current flowering one is starting to do that again and I am really worried. I have uploaded a few pictures.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jacinh/4816071424/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jacinh/4816071472/

Could someone please give me some advice? It kinda looks like crown rot but I have been watering very carefully (in the morning so it has time to dry) and the orchids are in a well ventilated place.

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    it's normal for them to lose the older bottom leaves, but not normal for them to all die. are you fertilizing them with anything? the newer leaves look healthy from the pic. the plants need to be stressed in order to flower, with phals it's cold. perhaps they're being stressed too much. any sign of bugs? what're the growing conditions

  • 16 years ago

    What's your potting media ??
    What's your weather like ?
    Do you have them inside or outside ?
    What about the roots ? Have you checked them ?

    Alma

  • 16 years ago

    I have had probably three or four phals die after flowering and mostly it was because I bought them in moss and they were rotting away while I was enjoying the flowers. I am not sure if the flowering causes the plant roots to rot quicker or not, interesting question. I would just check that the roots arent rotting, that's my plan for future flowering phals.

  • 16 years ago

    For many people, moss is difficult to work with (me for example). Often it looks good around the edges but is rotten at the core. Also, you have not mentioned what kind of light you are giving the plants. As Cody and IceCream have indicated, we need a bit more information please.

  • 16 years ago

    I will tell you what works for me. I am sure other people do things different.
    First off when I buy any orchid I repot. Phals are usually potted up in Spagnum moss. The phal has been in that pot and media for a long time. Growers are not going to spend extra money on new moss. It has more than likely been over fertilized. Growers do that to force flowering. You can bet there are mineral deposits in the bottom of the pot. Also how often have you tried to pull the phal out of the pot and found it so root bound that you have to cut the pot away. No air can get to the roots when they are like that.
    I do grow phals in spagnum I find it works best for me. I have tried it in bark, tree fern, even semi-hydro.
    and numerous other things. I have the best success with the Spagnum. (I repeat that is what works for me.) I take a plastic pot and drill holes in the pot to make it look like swiss cheese. I put my spagnum in very loosely so the roots get plenty of air. I take that plastic pot and set it inside a clay pot. The kind with the slits in the sides. I suspend the plastic pot in the clay pot. I don't let the walls of the plastic pot touch the clay pot. This allows plenty of air to the roots. I mist the Phal ever day or two depending on how the moss looks and how hot it has gotten. When I do mist, the the clay pot also gets wet. This increases the humidity around the Phal. Since I started doing it this way I have not lost any phals. I am getting new leaf growth and excellent roots.

  • 16 years ago

    thanks for all the replies. here's my growing condition:

    Light:
    I grow my phals inside next to a window on top of a humidity tray. There is no direct sun. I do open the window halfway in the summer to give them some air.

    Water:
    I water when the pot feels light. Usually about every 10 days in the winter and every 4-5 days in the summer.

    Media:
    I use fine bark, I think it's pine. The orchids all came in moss and have been repotted.

    I fertilize with 10-10-10 every 2 or 3 watering. There are no sign of bugs.

    With the last dead one, I see some roots are ok but some roots are hollow/stringy. I cannot tell if I over-watered/under-watered. I use plastic pots with slits on the side and bottom and they sit directly on the humidity tray grid. I can't see how I can over water them?

    This current one (shown in photo) has very healthy roots, with new roots growing.

    Have I under-watered my phal? I didn't really change my watering pattern. Do phals need A LOT more water when they are in bloom?

  • 16 years ago

    phals don't need more water when they're in bloom. did you happen to recently repot this phal or was it in bloom when you potted it? i'll think on it a little more

  • 16 years ago

    cody_mi,

    No, the phal has been growing in the same pot/media for about a year. After I repot it about an year ago, it grew some roots and one new leaf, and the current flower stem.

    I was really surprised to see the leaves yellow. The first one (bottom-most) yellowed and fell off, now the second one is 2/3 yellow.

    thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    Phals are the only orchids that likes repotting. They should be done at least once a year. If my spagnum looks bad I will repot before the year is out.
    Everytime I have repotted Phals you can almost see the plant perk up. The leaves look brighter and roots are fuller. Almost like they are saying thanks boss.

  • 16 years ago

    You say you grow your phals "next to a window. There is no direct sun." What kind of light does the window get? In an east or north window the plant should be right smack in the window. In a south or west window it should be a couple of feet back.

    What color are the leaves? Are they dark green? They should be light green.

    Your problem sounds like too much water with not enough light. Any water, without enough light to stimulate the plant into using it, will be too much.

  • 16 years ago

    orchid126,

    thanks for your input. the window is south facing but since it's very close to my neighbor's house, it doesn't get any direct light. The color of the leaves doesn't look too dark. Let me try to move it to a brighter location since I really cannot think of anything else.

    I really don't have any other workable windows since most of my windows are east facing with direct light. Maybe I'll put up some sheer curtain.

  • 16 years ago

    Try moving the plant closer to the light little by little. Keep feeling the leaves. If they're okay, continue to move the plant even closer. As soon as the leaves feel warm to the touch, move it back an inch or two. The plant will be at maximum light.

    East facing with direct light would also be suitable for your phal. That should be morning light, which is gentle. They can take more light than people think. Again, feel the leaves in an east window.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't know if this is any help. But of late, I've heard from a number of Phal breeders who have been having some difficulty with loosing their Phals. One after repotting hers - and pretty high numbers too. They have started to use diluted Physan sprayed on their Phals once a month and have noticed a significant lowering of losses.

    I don't think it would hurt to try it, and if it works, you may have your solution.

  • 16 years ago

    One of the problems that can occur when repotting phals is to pot the plant too deeply. Phals have a central "stem" and the leaves on the stem should be even with the medium, no deeper.

Sponsored