Software
Houzz Logo Print
bluebirdbabe

All my frogs died again!

18 years ago

This is the second winter that all of the frogs in the pond died. I think it may be too small and it isn't deep enough for them and they all freeze. My gold fish all made it even the little babies. I don't want this to keep happening. Is there something I can to to help them survive. This summer I am sure more frogs will come and I don't want them to die as well.

My pond is 11' x 4' x 2 1/2' deep and 600 gallons. Any advise is appreciated.

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    So sorry to hear about the frogs. I hate to say this, but your pond is probably too shallow and doesn't have enough volume (amount of water) so it most likely freezes all the way down to the bottom. Your frost line is about the same as mine, and I have two ponds a small one that is about the same as yours and a bigger one that is double that and just shy of four feet deep. The small one froze to the bottom the last two years, and I had the same frog mortality last year in it. (don't know about this year, but I am assuming it will be the same.)
    If you don't want to deal with netting out dead frogs every spring, then I think you have three choices, either get a pond heater/deicer, and which one is a problem I have been dealing with myself, or make it bigger, and deeper; or drain it each fall, and keep the fish indoors all winter in a tank or aquarium.

    Good luck!
    Jodi

  • 18 years ago

    Jodi thank you for the reply. I had a pond heater in the pond and I know it did not freeze all the way to the bottom. I can not bring the fish in, they are too big for our indoor aquarium. This year was the first year the fish spent the winter in the pond and they did very well. I think you are right, the pond is not deep enough for the frogs. There is one other option and my DH suggested that we have a frog hunt and bring them to a huge pond about a mile away. It is a natural pond that is at least 5' deep. I think they will do fine there.

  • 18 years ago

    That sounds like a good idea, just make sure to cover the pond with something like a net to keep the frogs from coming back till it freezes, and they have gone into dormancy.

  • 18 years ago

    Our pond is 3 feet deep in one area and 4 feet in another,we use a deicer and have found dead frogs every year??

    Still don't know why?

    Wayne

  • 18 years ago

    Are you all sure they're dead and just not still hibernating? Hibernating frogs can look dead.
    I have a 50 gallon pond that I keep a bird bath heater in every year (zone 5) and the frogs/tadpoles/minnnows have always survived. I do give them places to snuggle into (a pot of soil on its side/quilt batting etc.
    Another possibility is that you had a warm spell in the middle of winter and they came out of hibernation, and then it got cold again quickly, and they didn't have time to go back into hibernation. That can kill them.

  • 18 years ago

    What type of in-pond accommodations do you provide? If there is a pot of bedding material available for them to dig themselves in, they will likely make it if my friends pond experience is any help. She added a couple of plastic pots of aquatic potting material after the frogs pushed the water lilies out of their pot to make room. I am in a zone 5 area and I rarely get more than 6 inches of ice. Good luck, Sandy

  • 18 years ago

    Please tell me more about the "bedding material" I didn't know I was supposed to put any bedding material in the pond. I have had my pond for 4 years and the last 2 years the frogs have died. They survived the first 2 years and I didn't put any thing in the pond. There are 4 water lilies in the pond.

    I think it was the warm spell that did them in. I saw a frog at the top of the water and it was very much alive. Then the water froze again and then thawed and that is when the frogs were dead. I am sure they were dead they were on their backs at the bottom of the pond.

    I am willing to put bedding in the pond but I am not sure what it is.

    If there is a winter thaw, is there anything I can do for them or is that nature? I really don't want this happening again. I feel like I am setting them up to die. My pond was built for my birds, it has a stream for them to bathe and drink from. We added the fish and they are doing really well. The first summer the frogs came and we were happy to have them and they made it through the first 2 winters.

    Any information about the bedding is appreciated.

    Karen

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Karen,
    I didn't do it this year, (I forgot!), but its a small pond with a deicer, and I think that keeps it warm enough. I usually put a piece of quilt batting down into the water, in-between a few potted plants that are in the pond.
    Other than having a deicer/heater and pots and batting, there's not much you can do to prevent them coming out of hibernation too soon. I guess its just nature.
    And I think that frogs choose to spend the winter in places that they think are okay......so you sort of just have to trust their judgement, and whatever happens after that.
    I don't think you're setting them up to die.
    Do you remove some of the gunk in the pond in the Fall? Do you use a bubbler through as much winter as possible? That might help put more oxygen in the water, and that possibly might help.

  • 18 years ago

    I have not actually tried this myself, but it was suggested on this forum to put some layers of quilt batting weighted with rocks on the pond bottom during the winter for frogs to hibernate in.
    Last spring we had a warm spell, then a freeze. I lost a number of frogs that were out and about during the warm spell.

  • 18 years ago

    I place my lily pots in plastic milk crate containers and sink them to the bottom of my pond every fall. The frogs like to hibernate in the lily pots and under the crates. They also like to climb into folds of my liner.

    I've never found a dead frog and there are usually plenty of live ones in the spring. I know the frogs will die if they come out of hibernation too soon and I avoid any major cleaning and leave the plants on the bottom until the weather gets really warm. It usually puts me way behind on spring cleaning, but I'm sure I am saving some frogs.

    If fish are surviving the winter in a pond, I think frogs should also be able to survive.

    Any frogs that come out of hibernation too soon are usually doomed. It happens in lakes, rivers, and backyard ponds. They are wild creatures and sometimes they make deadly mistakes. We can do our best to help them, but we can't control them.

  • 18 years ago

    There are so many sources on a google search it can be overwhelming but the fact is frogs can survive even if they become a frogcicle. Not all hibernate in water. Many hibernate in the ground or in plant debris. In water they are usually found in debris on the bottom or in the soil in plant containers. That is what I referred to as bedding materials. Several forum members have used the quilting material but I have some reservations about that since they often use the polyester type and many of those have such long strands they could entangle the frog and others are so short they won't hold together in the water and just float away. Some of the sources recommend leaving debris on the bottom until temperatures are reliably above freezing. A search on this subject in this forum should bring up some good discussions. In the link , Laura zone5 has, as always, some well thought out suggestions and others on that thread do as well. To do a search go to the top of the forum page and you will see a place to enter the subject "frog hibernation". Sandy

    Here is a link that might be useful: basilbird's worries