Software
Houzz Logo Print
york_rose

Basye's Purple - how high?

15 years ago

I have a question about Basye's Purple.

I've never grown this rose nor seen it anywhere around where I live, so far as I'm aware (thus at present I'm relying solely upon the images & description at HMF).

There's a spot on the condominium property where I live that could nicely accommodate a dark pink/red/purple remontant rose that was about 5' high (and appropriately wide to be a decent flowering shrub for the landscape, rather than a fussy, delicate, weak, "rose"). I'm thinking that if Basye's Purple is tall enough and bushy enough as a flowering shrub it might work very nicely (as a base of color for taller roses such as Therese Bugnet, or the hybrid musk Eva).

Am I thinking rightly about this? In my (largely) cool summer, zone 6 climate would Basye's Purple get tall enough and wide enough to work in such a spot (as a lower growing harmonious rose for the taller, more vase shaped Therese Bugnet or Eva), or should I consider other roses instead?

(I know for sure that in addition to either Therese Bugnet or Eva, on the other side of the bush the neighboring roses will be Tausendschön, grown as a free standing shrub, and the climbing dark pink rose Parade, grown along a 3' cast iron fence.)

Whatever rose I choose needs to be at least 4' high because otherwise in this particular spot no one will even notice it's there. Besides Tausendschön, the other shrubs in that area are all large things, 6' or higher (such as the rhododendron "Roseum elegans").

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    My Basye's Purple is probably somewhere between 4 and 5 feet high, but it's not a particularly nice shrub. It's leggy, thorny, and not particularly bushy--homely enough that we were talking about taking it out just today. My Hansa is slightly bigger, but a MUCH better looking plant. It also gets some fall color and hips.

  • 15 years ago

    My plant arrived looking beautiful, with flowers and buds on it. That was its high point and it died a lingering death after that. It doesn't seem to be the easiest rose to grow, or at least not for me.

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you, lucretial.

    In my climate, when discussing roses you're talking about shrubs that are bare from sometime in November through sometime in April. One wants those bare stems to be as lovely as possible. For myself, aside from their hips I've long regarded the "typical" rugosa as a rose shrub that looked "weedy". I've never really been a big fan of them in a prominent place in one's home landscape, and that was in part why I was asking about Basye's Purple (where at least, like Therese Bugnet, one had the advantage of prominent nice winter color on the canes).

    If however despite that winter color, Basye's Purple is "ugly" during the winter, there's no way I want to plant this.

    Other suggestions?

    Most roses are going to be thorny/prickly. Rosa rugosa canes are typically heavily covered in thorns/prickles, but they're all pretty much thin and weak (provided you're talking about the species rather than its hybrids with other more stoutly prickled roses). In my experience the typical problem with rugosa roses in winter isn't so much that they're thorny, but rather that the stems and bushes look "weedy". They look just fine in the New England & New Jersey coastal sand dunes, but I'd prefer to avoid that look in our condominium/100 year old brick mansion garden landscape, even as I like many of the other features of rugosa roses. It's no accident that Rosa rugosa, while native to the northeastern Orient, is also supremely happy (almost to the point of invasiveness) in New England! I'm looking for whatever (probably rugosa) rose would get the right size for the spot so that my neighbors liked what it did for the area, looked lovely in the growing season, and also looked presentable in the winter (while being hardy enough to survive most of our zone 6, humid, stormy winters without dying to the roots). In my estimation Rosa rugosa hips are truly lovely (even as the shrub overall is "weedy looking"), but I'm open to that if I can find one that will "work" for me in the spot I'm envisioning.

    Suggestions?

  • 15 years ago

    Martin Frobisher. A hybrid rugosa from the "Explorer" series, so I suspect it should be hardy (just checked HelpMeFind, and it says it's good to zone 2b). Nice reddish-purple canes in the winter, without being horribly thorny like "real" rugosas. Mine's a few years old, grafted (from Pickering), growing in a HORRIBLE spot (clay, rocks, shade) and making a pretty, self-supporting, 6' columnar shrub. Flowers are beautiful. Smells good, too.

  • 15 years ago

    Just saw that you said darker colors--Martin is pretty light. A great rose, tho.

  • 15 years ago

    I would suggest Purple Pavement for your rugosa; it may be a trifle small; 4 foot is about the limit here in Zone 5, but it'll have the darker color and a nice round form. Has a few large Rugosa hips to add to its winter interest as well.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Musings blog

  • 15 years ago

    My Basye's Purple rose is still small. It has nice plum-brown very prickly canes.

    Purple Pavement is really prickly too. It has great fall foliage around here, but the hips are soft and do not last through the winter.

    Masha

  • 15 years ago

    My Basye's is 6-7' suckering through rosemary and boxwood. Took about 10 years to get that big. The canes are mahogany, the bristles somewhat lighter in color. My favorite feature of this rose is the fall foliage in shades of apricot and pink. I am thinking of underplanting it with Anda. There's not much on HMF about Anda, but it's got a radiant deep bloom and twiggier branch pattern than Basye's Purple. I'm in Georgia, by the way.

  • 15 years ago

    This is one of my favorite roses, but my climate is very different from yours. The deep mauve to purple single blooms with a neat circle of silvery stamens are unique, and the thorny canes are quite attractive in winter. Here it is not a a rose with dense foliage, but nevertheless one of my favorites. I like its ungainly leggy habit. Let me add that a very nice and vigorous rose, much more so than Basye's purple, is scharlachglut. A once bloomer (scarlet) with thorny red stems in winter and very beautiful hips. It should be very winter hardy. It will get big if you let it.