Software
Houzz Logo Print
alameda_gw

Question About Fertilizing Rose Bands

I have ordered quite a few rose bands. They are putting out leaves, growing well. On a few of them, the leaves are beginning to turn a light green, am thinking this could possibly be the start of chlorosis. I want to take excellent care of these babies and would like some advice on what to do. Dont want to give them anything that could harm their growth....I have a Ferry Morse electronic PH tester. I tested these roses, some bands I just got in [with the soil from the nursery] and some of the ones that have beautiful green leaves. Dont know if this gadget is worthless or not, but they all tested around 7.0. I think roses are to be, optimally, about 6.0 to 7.0. Is there anything I could add to the regular water that would help restore these bands to deep green? They are potted in a mix of bagged rose soil and Miracle Gro w/out fertilizer and mulched. They are in plastic greenhouses right outside my garage, protected from wind, plenty of sun. They are growing well except for this problem. Also, they have been potted since December [first batch] and mid January [2nd batch] and I am just now getting the 3rd batch in pots. Should I be giving them a light dose of any kind of fertilizer - fish emulsion, seaweed, ??? Would appreciate any advice on this. I have raised bands before with good success, but havent had lightening of the leaves before. Thanks for any advice! Oh, and one has buds this morning......Walferdange.

Judith

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for bringing this up, Judith. I've wondered about pros and cons of fertilizing newly-planted roses myself. I've received roses from growers who advise adding fertilizer to the bottom of the holes when planting; other folks say not to fertilize the first year. Since roses are heavy feeders, it makes perfect sense to me to feed them to help them become established.

    So what does everyone recommend?
    -terry

  • 18 years ago

    Judith, I do not think it is recommended to feed small roses. I COULD be wrong but I know anything other than granular fertilizers are not for first year roses, or at least that's what I've been taught.
    Don't know about that leaf color, sorry.

    Carla

  • 18 years ago

    Alameda -- I've had problems very similar to what you describe & have come to blame my watering practices. There's been considerable variation in root development with the bands I've received over the years. I think it's very important to assess the roots of each new band & increase pot size very gradually, erring on the side of too-small pots.

    Altho mature roses require lots of water, I don't believe the same is true for newly rooted cuttings. For me, the best root development occcurs when young ownroot roses are kept barely moist and even allowed to approach dryness for short periods of time. Placing them in containers that are too large retards root development -- especially when the medium is kept constantly too moist. I've attributed the pale green new growth to too much moisture. Fertilizing roses that are in that state seems only to make bad matters worse.

    In the controlled environment/humidity of your greenhouse, evaporation is reduced and more moisture is available to the plant thru its leaves as well as its roots. I think that extra-cautious attention to your watering schedule might improve your situation. Good luck.

  • 18 years ago

    What are they? Roses with multiflora heritage like quite acidic soil, and can definitely show signs of chlorosis at neutral pHs. Then there are other roses, like gallicas, that really seem to like much higher pHs. It's not a one size fits all measurement. If that is the problem, pretend they are azaleas. Does azalea potting soil still exist? I wouldn't bother repotting them, but for future reference....

    If I'm repotting bands, I like to use potting soil, like they sell for house plants. It isn't sterile, and contains nutrients that will keep the plant happy for a while. If they are planted in sterile soilless mix, or if they have been in the pots for a while, they will definitely need to be fertilized. Liquid fertilizer at half-strength isn't a bad start. Any general fertilizer will have 'seedling' recommendations and that's about right.

  • 18 years ago

    Windeaux, I think you are exactly right about the watering. These bands are potted in either 4" or 6" pots, as I thought the size of the band determined. I watered them very well when I first potted, to remove any air pockets, and I have barely watered them heavily since, and if I poke my finger down and if soil is damp, dont water. I have been afraid of overdoing it.

    The roses with lighter leaves are Cl. Baby Darling and Cl. Dancing Doll [a sib to Renae]. It was a tiny plant to begin with but leafing out nicely except for lighter leaves. These leaves are not like the pale-with-veins-showing chlorosis leaves I have seen on certain polyanthas, but just lighter green. El Dorado has a few light green leaves, but others that are dark green. I just want to head off a problem before it starts.

    Dont think I even need to water them now, perhaps the 4" pots pretty soon. Cl. Baby Darling is in a 4" pot, Cl. Dancing Doll and El Dorado are in 6" pots.

    Does the soil need to go more toward 6.5? I forget what to add for acid/alkaline soil, which is which, lime or sulphur. The soil mix I put them in is pretty complete, friable and I have pulled the 4" pots sides out and dont see roots growing so they dont need repotting yet.

    And I need to correct something about my original post......the Miracle Gro does have fertilizer in it, a 3 month supply. It is mixed with the bagged rose soil by BWI that I have used with good luck for years.

    Do any of you all who grow bands plant them in the ground the first year or keep them potted and overwintered until the following spring?

    Also.....I noted that Mme. Creux, who was a very tiny band when I got it, and was in the last batch I potted, is just "there"......wonder if a humidity tent would help this one along? Or just better to leave it alone, give it time and wait for spring to make it grow. This one is definitely going to take some coddling.....Cl. Dancing Doll was like this, but slowly coming on, but with lighter leaves.

    This whole process is a real treat for me......I go inspect them all the time, watching them grow.....such fun! I have a Peach Silk and Kiss of Desire, among others that were tiny bands carefully nurtured along and are now fine strong climbers. I really enjoy hearing how everyone else grows theirs......thanks for all the replies!
    Judith

  • 18 years ago

    A splash of fish emulsion at quarter to half strength (full strength is 1 tablespoon in a gallon of water) works well for baby roses.

  • 18 years ago

    Judith,
    I wouldn't worry about fertilizing them, unless it is with diluted fish emulsion.
    I have put bands in the ground before, and even with drip irrigation on them I lost 7 out of 8. Since I've started potting them up for at least 1 season I haven't lost any at all. I really don't know what the difference is.
    You will find that some of the baby tea roses (like Mme Creux) will kind of sit there until they get in the ground and then they will take off like a rocket. Either way, though, they do best in a pot for a year.
    Almost all of my roses have light colored leaves this time of year (if they have leaves at all). I wouldn't worry about that very much.

  • 18 years ago

    Again, I agree with Hoov. That would not hurt anything to give fish emulsion at a lessened rate.

    Carla