Software
Houzz Logo Print
hoovb

Interesting Rose Autopsy

When a rose fails I like to look at it carefully after I dig it out, to find out WHY it failed--was it my care, the specimen itself, root/crown gall, the soil?

This 13 year plus 'Abraham Darby' was interesting:

{{gwi:228878}}

The above is the living part of the plant. The rest died. Looking closely (note the "C" shape at the top)...
{{gwi:228879}}

I realized that this part is a part of the rose that went own root. The stem emerged from the side of the bud union, and because the bud union was half-buried, roots formed out the bottom of that stem. The "C" shape at the top was where it was connected to the original bud union, which had dried up and crumbled away as I dug it up.

This poor 'Abraham Darby' was moved once to often, and then the spot where it ended up got shadier and shadier, and I was planning to remove it for a long time anyway, because the Rust was just horrific. But now that it is dug up and the dead bits discarded, I find I have a fairly substantial own root Abe, and I'm so tempted to replant it in a sunnier spot and see if I can get more than a one-cane wonder out of it. Just can't let go of Abe.

Do you investigate why your failed roses have failed? What have you learned?

Comments (23)

  • 13 years ago

    That's really interesting, Hoov! If it were me I'd probably pot it up and see what it would do.

    Since I rarely have the courage to dig up anything with a breath of life still in it by the time I dig out the dead ones there's usually not much left to learn from.

  • 13 years ago

    Hoov .........

    Yes ! If a rose is not thriving, I will dig it up to see what is going on with the roots. I think I have learned more about roses that way than just by observing the top growth.

    In a couple of weeks, after it gets a bit warmer, I plan to dig up three roses that I may have sited wrong and need to be planted in a warmer part of the garden. This is the first year that we have had heavy snow that lasted for several weeks at my elevation, since I bought my house in the mountains. The bed where the troubled roses are located was where the snow melted last, which, to me, indicates it is a colder part of the garden and the roses are subject to cold air flows. I am hoping they will surprise me when I move them, but there may be something else going on in the root zone. I'll know more when I finally dig them up.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

  • 13 years ago

    That's interesting to have a look at. It took me a while to understand what was going on.....(migraine makes me thick headed). Hope it grows into a happy healthy boy Abe for you.

    ...round here, if it's dead- the winter did it almost certainly.

    This post was edited by lola-lemon on Thu, Feb 28, 13 at 17:24

  • 13 years ago

    That is interesting. I would plant it. The poor guy's been through a lot. Mary

  • 13 years ago

    In my case it's almost always gophers. I don't have to dig anything up - I can just lift up the whole dried-up bush.

  • 13 years ago

    I am moving roses and always look at roots. Abe's good as an own root so I would pot him up. Cut away the stuff that is not own root and plant a little deeper to encourage further rooting. Put some annuals in with him so he won't look so lonely.

  • 13 years ago

    I ended up planting him next to another Abe Darby so they can Rust together. Rust or not, love that Abe Darby!

  • 13 years ago

    I dig up roses if they are having problems sometimes.

    Last year I transplanted a noisette into more sun in a spot it should have loved. It got even sicker looking awhile after I moved it. Puzzled I dug it up to check on it as the soil, I thought was wonderful. After I took it out and dug down, I ran into a line of old tires that had been buried under the split rail fence where I'd planted the rose. I figured it was being poisoned from the tires and moved it again. It perked up so I guess that was the problem.

    Near there I dug down because there is a spot where grass will not grow and it really bugged me. I found a bunch of old asphalt chunks that had been buried. I think the asphalt is there to help stabilize the dirt at the edge of a sloped area. Sure plays havoc with plants.

    I hope the Abes are happy together, Hoovb.

  • 13 years ago

    I do that. When I moved into my house nearly 20 years ago, the bed in front that goes along my porch had 13 azaleas in it - about 12-15' long. Some were big, some were tiny. I don't see much point in doing a lot of work for such little return - blooms for only a few weeks/year, so I dug them all out. A couple had never had the roots spread when they were planted, and the roots still had the shape of a 6" pot. First root examination, the person who planted them didn't know you needed to separate the roots of azaleas (and other things, too, I do it for everything).

    Anyway, I went to Antique Rose Emporium and came home with 3 Mme Antoine Mari tea roses. They filled the entire bed that had held 13 azaleas, and bloomed most of the year. Then they started declining a couple of years ago. That puzzled me. So last year I decided to dig the bed. I had originally put weedblock down, and it had about a 2" layer of leaf litter on top of it, and didn't block weeds but water. We had just had a substantial rain, and the roses were totally dry. They were dying from being dehydrated. I had to toss one, moved another, and left the one in the center, and cut out the weedblock (horrible task), and have planted a lot of different things in that bed now.

    Here's the bed now, you can see Mme Antoine Mari blooming in the center, in front of the window unit.

  • 13 years ago

    I have dug up roses that were not thriving. Usually I have not seen a reason for it, but often assume it's due to root competition, a dry area, or too much shade. Often a failing rose will perk up if grown on awhile in a pot. I think some roses don't do well in the ground if the roots are too small, and if grown on in pots until they're a pretty substantial size they will then have the energy to thrive in the ground. That might be especially true for hybrid teas. So many think that they do better grafted, but possibly it's just that they need big roots before going in the ground.

    I did find some gall on the roots of a potted plant that was just sitting there so I threw it out. Love Abe Darby.

  • 13 years ago

    erasmus ...........

    " I think some roses don't do well in the ground if the roots are too small, and if grown on in pots until they're a pretty substantial size they will then have the energy to thrive in the ground."

    I agree completely. I've even tested this theory in my current garden and have seen the difference in plant performance between plants that have a larger root mass compared to plants with a smaller root mass at the time of planting.

    I think the plants with the larger root mass have more material/tools to take up moisture and nutrients and are less stressed during the transplanting process.

    This is just my personal observation in a challenging gardening area.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

  • 13 years ago

    Speaking of finding chunks of buried asphalt and old tires, it's so irksome that a lot of so called "professional" landscapers do just that--contaminate the soil. Doesn't seem very professional to me. I had a project last summer and the guys were just covering garbage (plastic containers, fast food packaging, etc) over with a shovelful of dirt--had to have a talk with the boss.

    Also brings to mind the Cercis tree I just dug out. The roots were mostly round and round the rootball, not streched out at all even being surrounded with excellent soil. Once they start circling in the pot they are going to do that forever. I was careful to replace the Cercis with new trees recently upsized in pots--no circles. Though it made it easier to get the Cercis out...

  • 13 years ago

    I hadn't put it together until this year but now I also think that potting a rose back up can save it.

    Last year I had some really bad bare root orders. Roots were shaved down to nothing from three big mail order companies. Two of their three canes conked out within a month of planting. Of the two I dug up, no root hairs were developing. A year after putting them into pots the top growth is telling me they may be ready to go back in the ground. The two I left in the ground hoping for the best just died as soon as summer hit. Oh and the ones that survived in the ground were misnamed. I probably could have struck out less if I'd gone to Big Lots. Mary

  • 13 years ago

    I bought a Fraser holly plant one time that turned out to be extremely pot bound, and it took forever for the roots to spread out. Pot bound roots can be encouraged to branch out by cutting into them or scratching some loose. So when potting up a rose it is important to give it a progressively bigger pot until it is the size you want.

    Lyn, I face some degree of the same problem you have with challenging soil. Seems like roses are remarkably drought tolerant but first they have to get established.
    My soil is light, wonderful to dig, but drains fast.
    HoovB, it's amazing that professional landscapers would mess up the soil like that. Someone once said that it's not what you don't know, but what you know that ain't so that's a problem. In my area professional tree men often go around topping trees, completely ruining their beauty.
    I have some large beautiful trees and a tree man stopped to talk to me the other day, wondering if I want my trees topped. I was thinking he's got his eyes out for a natural shaped tree that could be ruined. Geeze. I thought that was a local tree man affliction but I hear it goes on in CA too.

  • 13 years ago

    Erasmus, that's awful ! Look what I found in my neighborhood - I'm going to take pics after these branch out. They'll never ever look good again, I'm afraid. These are live oaks.

  • 13 years ago

    Oh yikes. What were they thinking? Was there storm damage? :(

  • 13 years ago

    I planted a one gallon Leonie Lamesch straight into the garden. One gallons usually do well here, but Leonie grew backwards and the main cane started to die back. I dug her up and put her in a large pot. She's tripled in size and covered in blooms. I really don't know what her problem was in the ground.

  • 13 years ago

    erasmus ..........

    I truly wonder if anyone really has good soil. Mine drains well and holds the moisture, but you can't dig in it. I was new to gardening when I bought this house and went about creating the rose beds in such a way that I am now going to have to re-work them and do them right.

    Gardening in glacier slurry/subsoil is an adventure. Believe it or not, the water runs from rose hole to rose hole with just a slight variation in the grade in the bed along the fence in front of the slope....not to the french drain I put in when I bought the house. When I deep watered the roses at a slightly higher grade at one end of the bed, the water moved on down the bed and drowned the roses at the other end. I didn't know that was the reason those roses were not thriving until I dug one of them up.

    This year, I need to rework the whole bed so that the soil is consistent. I am dreading this project because, it's huge.

    Smiles,
    Lyn

  • 13 years ago

    I had the same exact problem!!
    Once, I bought several bare root, grafted roses from poundland here in Nottingham and all of them died, one after the other.
    When I investigated the reason behind their deaths, the root stocks have already died and faded away resulting in the dooms of the grafts. :\

  • 13 years ago

    I did not do the autopsy yet, still hoping the patient has some life left...but I know the cause...I saw the hole and have a trap.

    But Bewitched is probably be-gone (not too sad just don't want the varmint getting a taste for roses)

  • 13 years ago

    hoov, do replant it. Abe is worth it. I have mine where it gets some shade and it does quite well.

  • 13 years ago

    Sorry for your loss, Kippy. You need one of these guys:

    {{gwi:228882}}
    Pituophis catenifer catenifer, Pacific Gopher Snake

    I planted that sad Abe and he started to grow, then both Abes came down yet again with such a massive case of rust, blackspot, powdery mildew, anthracnose, and downy mildew (all at the same time!) and so they are outta here. The Abe out front only has Rust, so he can stay, for now. Sigh.

  • 13 years ago

    Hoobv, I think I might pass on your little garden friend. Although I tend to have the "good luck" of finding those helpers by me. I also have a lot of gophers still here. This beast made it through my anti gopher wall by using the neighbors side of the zone. I would love to add to my wall...but that might mean digging under their garage. They are working to clean up that dump zone so hopefully the cats/hawks have better access to the gophers.

    I am debating picking up their favorite super highway pavers and give it a new "road base" of kitty litter balls.