Software
Houzz Logo Print
morrisnoor

A found Tea rose to identify...

18 years ago

Still me... another question for you ;o)

We have a Tea rose, easily found in cemeteries or old gardens here and there, who's made us crazy.

She has colours that vary day after day, from light creamy-blush to dark cerise-pink, like only Teas are able to do. But not just this. She resemble to at least one hundred millions other Teas!!!

I try do describe her. The bush didn't care for neglect and can become big, always very full of foliage and branches. Few large prickles, on smooth, green canes, grey-green when mature. The new growth is reddish, but not purple, and mature foliage shows a grey-green hint.

Buds long, pointed, elegant. Not a very big flower like Mrs Foley Hobbs, but a smaller one like 'Marie van Houtte', very full, with muddled centers. Flowers always nod, and balls frequently both in spring and summer. The colour is very variable as I've said above. Typical colour is creamy pink with cerise-red in the outer petals, darkening with age. But can be almost evething in similar shades (sometimes there's also a yellow-buff hint in the centers).

A few picture from a friend:

{{gwi:235103}}

The whole bush

{{gwi:235105}}

These are taken in spring,

here's a flower of my plant in late october, showing the overall darker colour in full open blooms.

{{gwi:235106}}

I have an idea about her name, but I would like to hear from you, first...

Thanks!

Maurizio

Comments (20)

  • 18 years ago

    It could pass for General Galleni. Same foliage and red final bloom color along with the new growth color and lack of prickles.

    Lance

  • 18 years ago

    It is beautiful! I wonder if GG would change colors like that.
    I want to know what it is too.

    Carla

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Lance, but I don't think it is GG. I've had GG and the shape of the blooms was very different (..ok... you know... I just think that flowers on GG don't have any shape.... :op)

    I hope that Jeri or Anita are reading here.... ;o) and come to help us! :o)

  • 18 years ago

    No expert here, but my Niles Cochet does the same color change too. Ciao da Simona.
    {{gwi:235107}}

  • 18 years ago

    It reminds me a bit of Hugo Roller, but that rose is mostly found in Australia and I don't know that it ever turns completely pink as in your last picture.

    Ingrid

  • 18 years ago

    Mme Lambard is the chameleon to beat all chameleons, no two flushes or two plants producing the same bloom color. The spring flush has lighter, two-toned blooms, but once it heats up, it is a coppered rose color for the rest of the season. It sets lots of hips, the foliage is perfect, and the plants can grow to great size.

  • 18 years ago

    Ciao Simona! YESSSSS....I was wondering, exactely, if it would be 'Niles Cochet'... :o))

    Ingrid, the colour in Hugo Roller is similar, but it seems that flowers are held upright.

    Cass, I agree with you! I have Mme Lambard and I can see clearly now different flowers in the same plant, in different colours depending on the weather the day they've been opened...
    Have you any idea about my rose? I see in your page that you have 'Niles Cochet'... ;o)

    Ciao!
    Maurizio

  • 18 years ago

    Maurizio have you seen the photos of Souvenir de Victor Hugo on helpmefind?

  • 18 years ago

    Maurizio, I have grown Niles Cochet for almost 20 years, and I do not think your rose is that.
    The lighter parts of Niles are more silvery-pink.
    His buds are very FAT, stuffed with petals which may not open in cool damp weather.
    Another significant thing about Niles:
    He is quite likely to produce some blooms which are 'Maman Cochet,' and some which are 'White Maman Cochet.'

    Here's Niles:
    {{gwi:235108}}

    The colors of your rose seem a better match for Rosette Delizy, or photos I've seen of Hugo Roller.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    Mauricio, Niles Cochet is just so unlikely, coming from California, being such a late Tea. Also, the foliage and canes are really rather unique, modern looking for a Tea, lots of green wood, somewhat weird growth habit if budded, the leaves rather shiny. It has never, not once, finished the way your bloom finishes. But the canes as you describe them remind me of Niles Cochet.

    I know of a series of Teas with sweet creamy apricot centers: Mme Jean Dupuy, Souvenir de Victor Hugo (both almost thornless and therefore distinct), Dr. Grill which has a beautiful picture on the Vintage Gardens website, even Marie d'Orlean's spring blooms can look that way, although the quilling of the blooms in summer heat is diagnostic for that rose. Mme Berkeley has sweet apricot centers. But the only one I have that finishes coppery pink every time is Mme Lambard.

    I have to check if General Gallieni does that in the spring. I just can't remember. It finishes true madder red. And think of all the roses no longer in commerce that might be prospects! Oh, such joy, identifying found Tea roses.

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:235101}}

  • 18 years ago

    Cass that is a gorgeous photo!

    Maurizio, the first photo looks like Rosette Delizy to me, but RD never finishes so dark red for me.

    Jerome

  • 18 years ago

    Maurizio

    the characteristics you note, and the accompanying photos I could easily ascribe to 'Hugo Roller', as I know him. He does nod his head a little, although not as much as some other Teas.

    Additionally, my Hugo can show the same red/cerise blooms concurrently with some being completely buff/yellow (sometimes with pink guard petals, other times not).

    He is a member of my small list of 'Troublesome Teas' in that he balls frequently, othertimes the blooms can appear very coarse & his colours rather harsh & garish. Of course when he is occasionally good - he is exquisite!

    Are there records of 'Hugo Roller' listed in early 20th century Italian catalogues?

    Jane

  • 18 years ago

    Hi guys and girls :o)
    Thank you for the advice!

    I was hoping it would be less complicated... :o/ But it seem that I have to wait the new flowering, then take new detailed pictures to show you.

    I have seen on HMF the pictures of 'Hugo Roller', but the flower shape is too globular. Flowers on my rose are ever-nodding, as you can easily see in my second picture. The colour in the last picture isn't the rule, I've posted it just to show how much it could be variable.
    Also, there's no records of 'Hugo Roller' in old italian catalogues, and it seems to be the same now everywhere in Europe.

    I was wondering about Niles Cochet, seeing the two older pictures of it on HMF, who looks almost identical. But I've never see first hand a labeled plant of a Cochet family (so curious, even Walter Branchi have never had these roses in his very large collection of Teas and Chinas...)

    Another quality of my rose is in her petals: they are very thin, like 'Mlle Franziska Frueger' or 'Mme Lambard'. That's why, I think, it balls so frequently.

    I have in my garden since few weeks, start growin', Maman Cochet: in a few more weeks, I'll be able to see if her foliage and flower shape are the same of my rose or not...

    Ciao!:o)
    Maurizio

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Guys!

    Me again :o), after so much time.
    In order to only say that 'Maman Cochet' from Peter Beales has proven to be identical to my found Tea. They are in bloom now, and it's impossible to distinguish. Therefore, I have 3 'Maman Cochet' now... 2 of them will find a new home, I need space for some new entries :)))

    Ciao!
    Maurizio

  • 18 years ago

    Congratulations. I am happy you figured it out. I always wondered about your rose. I just picked up 'White Maman Cochet' and I just love her blooms. Looking forward to your next mystery!

    Joanne

  • 18 years ago

    Hi, Maurizio. Maman Cochet has very thick, very stout canes, rigid in growth. That should help you confirm the identification.

  • 18 years ago

    How exciting, Maurizio. I just planted the bush form of Maman Cochet after falling in love with her climbing version. I'd love to have the white and yellow versions but have no room. With your experience with the two earlier MCs is she a heavy bloomer. I have seen her called a "stingy bloomer". My climber has not bloomed all summer but admittedly she is young (6 months in the ground) with rampant growth, so I'm guessing the lack of blooms at this stage may be appropriate. I have never seen a bloom on the climber with such contrasting colors. More in the peachy/rosey range so far. But I look forward excitedly to flowers like the ones in your photos.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Does it set hips, are the peduncles smooth or bristly are the ribs of the leaf prickly

  • 17 years ago

    Mme Lambard was also my first thought, as it's capable of producing flowers like the second flower picture, and can also produce light colors with a yellowish tint. Form can also be quite variable. And a variety of shades and forms can occur at the same time.

  • 17 years ago

    I thought Rosette Delizy too except for that late deep colored bloom!

    But my Rosette has produced exactly one flower, so I am far from an expert.