Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19722594

Florence Bower's Pink Tea

13 years ago

Another treasure lost from commerce...

First bloom of the season today, own-root plant, beginning its second year in the ground. Two 9' canes so far, with buds on every lateral (somewhere between 50 and 75 buds total). The foliage has been very clean. Even I (whose nose can't detect many tea scents) can smell this one -- very sweet. It looks like this rose is going to do well here.
(I'm still getting used to this new camera, so please forgive photo quality).
~ Debbie

The bud this morning (very low on the plant, so not visible in the whole-plant photo below):
{{gwi:243322}}

Later in the day, same bud; the flower is about 3.5" across:
{{gwi:243324}}

Another view of buds, showing sepals and glands:

{{gwi:243326}}

Whole plant (sorry for the busy background -- my "chaparral")

{{gwi:243328}}

This post was edited by catspa on Fri, Mar 22, 13 at 23:10

Comments (33)

  • 13 years ago

    WOW. SIMPLY WOW.

    Man, I haven't COVETED anything in a long time (other than R. chinensis spontanea) but that is DROP DEAD GORGEOUS.

    What do you know about it?

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Jeri,

    I got the rose from Vintage and only know what Gregg has written there -- that they got it from Ruth Knopf. I would love to know more. Who was Florence Bower, for example?

    A weird thing is that I can never call it up on HMF by typing in the name, even in quotation marks. I always have to type in "Florence" and scroll down. I've include the HMF link below.

    ~ Debbie

    Here is a link that might be useful: Florence Bower's Pink Tea on HMF

  • 13 years ago

    Love it! And the chaparral

  • 13 years ago

    Beautiful tea rose! Can this be purchased anywhere?

  • 13 years ago

    Debbie, I think that we should have this rose in the Sacramento cemetery. Maybe you could propagate one for us when yours gets bigger. It's really gorgeous and seems to be a true Tea climber, which is not a very common thing.
    Anita

  • 13 years ago

    Beautiful! That's all I can say! Wish I had her! Stunning!

  • 13 years ago

    I'm so pleased to see the bloom. When I first saw photos of this rose, I ordered two bands immediately. I would love to see another photo when you bloom is fully open. Such a beauty!!!
    Gracin

  • 13 years ago

    This rose is going bonkers in my garden! Very vigorous, large flowers. Flo is making me very happy!

    It outgrew its pot quickly. Last weekend I transferred it to the largest pot I have, and I'm training it up a sparsely-foliated tree.

    I'll send some pics when it finally gets going.

  • 13 years ago

    Idixierose, thank you so very much for letting us know about Florence Bowers! It makes such a difference to know at least a little about the person who saved the rose, to have that connection with the plant in your garden. I hope she knows how much this rose is appreciated. A wonderful thing to have done.

    Anita, on the propagation, will do and I will contact you when I have successfully propagated a plant. My intention is to propagate and/or make cuttings available (through HMF) for any rose I have that goes out of commerce (per HMF) due to the closing of Vintage.

    Gracin, following are some photos of the fully-open flower from today (I finally found the "macro" function on my new camera...).

    ~Debbie

    The flower is 4" wide, fully open
    {{gwi:243330}}

    {{gwi:243332}}

    This post was edited by catspa on Sun, Mar 24, 13 at 0:08

  • 13 years ago

    What a voluptuous beauty! It seems to be ideal for training as a climber judging by the picture of it going up the arch. I hope we'll see it when it's flowering there. This rose surely deserves to make a comeback.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the posting, catspa! I have a very new specimen of this rose, now in its first full season, and still "band" size; but root growth after I received it and put it into a 1-gal. can was enough that I felt secure planting it in the open ground a couple of months ago; and, with the weather warming up, it's starting to put out its first new leaves as an open ground plant. It's going to be under my eye even more than most roses, as I planted it against the wall just outside my bedroom window. It's in what I'm starting to call my Tea Allée. Its immediate neighbors are 'J.E. Murphy's Tea' and 'Alliance Franco-Russe', with such doughties as 'Safrano', 'Anna Olivier', 'Devoniensis', 'Lady Roberts', 'Mlle. de Sombreuil', and some nameless Tea foundlings a little more distant, all of them doing splendidly.

  • 13 years ago

    I examined my little band-sized plant of 'Florence Bower's' closely today. The little thing has a lot of heart: It was already producing no fewer than four flower buds. I pinched off two. It's obviously a very generous rose. I hope an i.d. can be determined for it some day! Has anyone floated any i.d. possibilities?

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks, Debbie, for your offer to propagate for the cemetery and to be a source for this and other rare roses. It's not going to be easy to keep roses like this available - HMF is a great way to do it - passalong plants will be more important than ever.
    Anita

  • 13 years ago

    Odinthor, the Vintage website says that Phillip Robinson considered this to be a candidate for the real Souvenir d'un Ami until he noticed that it was climbing. Judging by the amount of variation in the photos on the HMF Souvenir d'un Ami sites, 'Souvenir d'un Ami' seems to be a name applied to at least a few different roses, some of which kind of look like this rose but lack the notably glandular pedicels and receptacles on Florence Bower's pink tea.

    Though the flowers of the two differ in some respects (and my Mrs. B.R. Cant does not have the glandular receptacles that are so striking on FB), the range and shades of warm pinks in the Florence Bower's rose are virtually identical to those in Mrs. B.R. Cant, including the pale yellow petal bases and the darker pink shadings on the outer petals. Their scents are also very similar.

    Due to a sad lack of rose ID skills or knowledge of rose lineages on my part, I have no idea if these similarities have any meaning. But, to me, Florence Bower's pink tea and Mrs. B.R. Cant seem to "run along the same lines".

    ~ Debbie

  • 13 years ago

    So now I am wondering (question for the experts): which other teas have a scent like that of Mrs. B.R. Cant? Is her scent very unique? ~ Debbie

  • 13 years ago

    I've never smelled another rose with the wonderful earthy scent of 'Mrs. B.R. Cant'. The scent is what makes it a "must have" for me; all of its other felicities, wonderful though they be, come in second.

    I've always been perplexed by the statement that 'Florence Bower's' was ruled out as 'Souvenir d'un Ami' because it (FB) was climbing: "One of the wonders and delights of my childhood was a fine plant [of Sd'uA] . . . which grew up a pillar in the conservatory [...]" (from Rose G. Kingsley *Eversley Garden* of 1907; hm, I see that in some of the notes in *The Old Rose Advisor*, I mis-spelled it "Kingley"; sigh, oh well...; anyway, RGK was born in 1845, so her "childhood" would have been lived within the decade and a half or so immediately following the introduction of SD'uA--what I'm getting at is that she most likely knew "the real thing"). While just about all Teas will I think be climberish under the right conditions (you go, atavism!), growing up a pillar in a conservatory seems to me to strongly imply a normal climbing tendency, such as FB has. Singer (1885) finds it vigorous and "branches slender and flexuous." I also see that SD'uA is listed in *Choix des Plus Belles Roses* (1845-1854) as having sepals "elongate, ciliated with small glandular hairs," which seems consistent with glandular pedicels and receptacles. 1846's *Revue Horticole* calls it "a beautiful dark delicate pink"; more than fifty years later, D'Ombrain in 1908 similarly finds it "a pale or a deep rose." I'm not making a case for it being 'Souvenir d'un Ami'--at least, not until I've grown it for a while!--but I can't see ruling it out, given the above. How pleasant it would be to find the real 'Souvenir d'un Ami'!

  • 13 years ago

    Well, Odinthor, if you love the scent of Mrs. B.R. Cant, you will love that of Florence Bower's, too. To my nose, they are the same.

    There are glandular hairs on the sepals as well the receptacle, and the sepals are elongate:

    {{gwi:243334}}

    {{gwi:243335}}

  • 13 years ago

    And I see that the epidermis ("bark") is "reddish-green, primarily where the sun strikes" (as Singer has it in 1885); and at least some of the flower-stalks I see in the pix are indeed "brown" (as Jamain & Forney have it in 1873). I can see the arrangement of the larger (outer) petals as being "imbricated" as the term was used in those days (as Parsons has it); and it's clearly "abundant" (as Revue-Horticole has it in 1846). I submit that we have a contender for 'Souvenir d'un Ami'.

  • 13 years ago

    What ever it is it sure is lovely!

  • 13 years ago

    I think there is an argument to be made, Odinthor. Descriptions made closer to the date of introduction should take precedence, and many of the older excerpts in "The Old Rose Advisor" do not agree well with the rose photos displayed on HMF's 'Souvenir d'un Ami' page.

    In particular, I am interested in the glandular hairs on the sepals, receptacles, and pedicels. Of the dozen Teas in my garden, only Florence Bower's has these. All of the others are smooth, except for Etoile de Lyon (ex Vintage), which has some ciliation on the edges of the sepals (but not down the midrib and not at all on the receptacle). Your Kingsley excerpt mentions this, as you note, as does caption on one of the oldest portraits (1855, with respect to pedicels) posted on HMF (http://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=21.119325). Many of the roses in the HMF photos, where this feature can be seen, are as smooth as can be.

    The canes are so far certainly "slender and flexuous" and very easy to mold over the arch. There are hooked thorns more or less as described. An interesting thing about the description on HMF is that the variety is described as having a height of 8' to about 10' and a width of 4'. Doesn't sound like any of the shrubby, non-climbing teas in my garden (whose proportions tend to run more the opposite way!), nor a good description of modern bearers of the name (where did the listed dimensions come from?). More like a "pillar", I would think...

    Well, this certainly gives us something to look forward to studying over the coming years, doesn't it?

    ~ Debbie

    Here is a link that might be useful: 1855 portrait 'Souvenir d'un Ami'

    This post was edited by catspa on Tue, Mar 26, 13 at 7:54

  • 13 years ago

    Yes--now that a blossom has opened on mine--the scent of 'Florence Bower's' is indeed very much like that of 'Mrs. B.R. Cant', even perhaps a little fuller and deeper than that of 'Mrs. B.R. Cant': I think that there's a bit of coffee grounds aroma underlying the rest in 'Florence Bower's'. Wonderful!

  • 13 years ago

    Debbie -
    I sent a note to Billy West (one of the tea rose book authors) and asked her to take a look at this post. She's not on GW, but asked this:
    "do you know whether the glandularity seen on the receptacles in these photos is a consistent feature of this rose, or does it vary with conditions, zones, seasons."

    I realize that your plant is young, but perhaps you've observed it enough to know.

    (If you're on Facebook, come join us, that's where we network with some of the international rosarians)

    Janelle

  • 13 years ago

    Janelle,

    I just posted this answer on my HMF photo of Florence Bower's bud, where the question also appeared:

    "Unfortunately, not enough observation to know. This is the plant's first real flush. The rose was put in the ground December 2011 and there were maybe a dozen blooms scattered over all of last season (2012). I did not pay close attention, but I do know that the buds were glandular at some point last year, because of noticing the scent left on my fingers. I will certainly monitor phenology of the trait on my plant over future seasons."

    This question sure makes me wish there were more specimens around to observe. Can anyone else weigh in on glands on the sepals and receptacle of Florence Bower's?

    (I'm not on Facebook, but an international rosarians network could be tempting)

    ~Debbie

    This post was edited by catspa on Sat, Mar 30, 13 at 15:28

  • 13 years ago

    Re the significance of glands on the receptacle, I just checked out the description for 'Souvenir d'un Ami' in "Tea Roses: Old Roses for Warm Gardens", where it is noted (p. 188) that the description for 'Adam' by Paquet and Rouillard (1846) states that 'Souvenir d'un Ami' can be "distinguished from it ['Adam'] very easily by the peduncle bristling with glandular hairs". This backs up the *Choix des Plus Belles Roses* (1845-1854) excerpt from "The Old Rose Advisor" quoted previously.

    So, the real 'Souvenir d'un Ami' would be expected have highly glandular receptacles, as FB does (on my plant, at this time, at least).

    Debbie

    This post was edited by catspa on Sat, Mar 30, 13 at 13:11

  • 13 years ago

    Just to muddy the waters, I have Souvenir d'un Ami which is identical on HMF with the one Cass shows and also the one in the San Jose Heritage Garden. It also seems verysimilar to the two old lithographs shown there and the description on one of very bending stems and not that great a rebloom. There are no glandules on mine whatsover. The rose looks nothing like Florence Bower's Tea in that it is paler, seems to have many more petals, which are shorter toward the middle, and will often have a "pillow" of unopened short petals in the middle until the rose has opened extremely widely after a few days. That middle area is a darker pink than the outer petals. The SdA roses from New Zealand and Australia are not the same rose that I have. Unfortunately I did not document from which seller I bought this rose.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    For what it's worth, all flower buds on my quite young plant indeed "bristle with glandular hairs." The other Teas I checked at the same time do not show this feature.

    This rose is a bloom machine: You might recall that I pinched off two of its four buds last week. It has already grown three more buds... If the memory of one's friends is of their loving generosity, this rose certainly is an appropriate "souvenir d'un ami"!

  • 13 years ago

    That's good to know, Ingrid; I couldn't find a clear or close enough view of the receptacles on the Cass/SJHRG photos of Souvenir d'un Ami (which Cass mentions was obtained from Ashdown). The "Jack L" of Thousand Oaks photo on HMF of a Souvenir d'un Ami bud (flower of which resembles the Cass/SJHRG versions, too) also shows non-glandular receptacle and sepals.

    Because degree of glandularity can vary to some extent with climate, season, and growing conditions (and here I'm talking from familiarity with identifying wild-growing plants of other species, not roses, of which I know next to nothing), I'm assuming that's why Billy West is asking if this is a constant trait on FB.

    I can see why there has been dissatisfaction with reconciling modern versions of Souvenir d'un Ami with the old descriptions. As noted in "Tea Roses, Old Roses for Warm Gardens", the Australian Souvenir d'un Ami, along with only occasionally having glands, also lacks "...the plump bud, elongated receptacle and drooping globular flower shape shown in early illustrations and photographs of 'Souvenir d'un Ami', (Curtis 1850-53; Drennan 1912)...". Florence Bower's may turn out to lack these, too, and/or have other inconsistancies with 'Souvenir d'un Ami' as originally described. Will certainly need to grow FB for more years further than I have now to see what she's really like.

    Debbie

  • 13 years ago

    Good to hear, Odinthor. At least the receptacles "bristling" with glands on FB are consistent between yours and mine! ~ Debbie

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the additional information Debbie!
    Janelle

  • 13 years ago

    Nabbed a Florence Bower's Pink Tea while at Vintage today picking up some donations for our Open Garden sale. It is such a vigorous, beautiful plant! Gregg had another half dozen of these roses available so it's still possible to order it.

    I got some other roses for the cemetery collection and of course a few for myself. Have wanted La Belle Sultan for a long time - and have coveted Manning's Blush ever since seeing it at Beale's nursery (where in the world am I going to put it???). Roses are so hard to resist....
    Anita

  • 13 years ago

    This is great news, Anita! The more who can grow Florence Bower's and the more it is spread around, the better the chance it will survive and, perhaps, the better the chance of one day identifying it. For those who have or get a plant and are able to do so, it would be great to post photos and observations about it on HMF.

    Billy West just posted a series of questions in the "Comments" section of the Florence Bower's site on HMF:

    "It's probably too early to tell, but does "Florence Bower's Pink Tea seem like a rose that repeats regularly, or does it have an exuberant spring flush and occasional blooms after that?
    Do many other grow this rose? In different climate zones? Photos and observations from other zones would help build up information about the extent of its variability.
    I'm curious to know how much the colour varies.
    Do you know whether the original plant still exists?
    Glandular bristly pedicels aren't uncommon in Teas, but receptacles that are consistently this glandular are rare and if this is a stable trait in "Florence Bower's Pink Tea", it might help track down its original name - it'll certainly be a way to eliminate possibilities!"


    Anyone who has input has something of value. I can't answer any of these questions yet.

    Debbie

    Here is a link that might be useful: Florence Bower's Pink Tea on HMF

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you for posting those photos! I saw Greggs plant when it was still very young and I thought it was unfair to judge the blooms of a Tea rose on such a small plant Thanks to your photos I placed an order two days ago for Florence Bowers Pink Tea'.
    Two years ago when I bought my house I wanted the entryway to have an arch with pink climbing Tea roses, of a medium to deep saturation of pink, and as climbing Mrs. B.R. Cant' is no longer in commerce I thought I was out of luck.

    Thank you, thank you, thank you.

    Luxrosa

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio