Software
Houzz Logo Print
kebc77

need to replace some 'full sun' perennials with 'partial shade'

16 years ago

Hello,

I planted perennials in what I considered our "full sun" section of the yard 2 years ago. But discovered after watching things grow that there is a small section of it that is actually partial shade due to the canopy of a large maple tree that just reaches into the garden bed. At about 1:30PM in summer, the line b/w sun and shade corresponds exactly with the plants that are thriving vs. those that look a little more sickly.

I wanted native plants that attract butterflies and hummingbirds; we have sandy soil (that is on the acidic side judging from the color of my 'Endless Summer' hydrangea). Plants that are affected are Agastache 'Blue Fortune' and Echinacea 'White Swan'; I will be planting butterfly weed this year (full sun sections only!) and have some Baptisia australis that's doing well in both full sun and part shade. The front of the garden bed is out of the tree canopy so is doing OK (has sedum, aster, yarrow, and daylily).

I'm going to move the agastache and coneflower and would like suggestions on what I might put in there. Would like something about 3 ft. Garden style is informal. I thought about bee balm but I'm afraid that that part of the yard might be too dry.

Thanks!

Kristen

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago

    I just planted some thalictrum (meadow rue) in partial shade. I live in TN, but it is a native plant in MI, too.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm surprised you are having problems with Agastache in part shade. Mine is quite happy in part shade, particularly the Golden Jubilee, which seems to bloom better in part shade.

    Do you have it in a fast drying soil? Shady spots tend to stay moister than sunny spots.

  • 16 years ago

    How about turtlehead (Chelone)?

    For textural effect, Chasmanthium thrives in part-shade, and while classified as a grass, it actually is reminiscent of bamboo in appearance. Ferns do well in part-shade (as long as the soil isn't dry).

    For shrubbery, the obvious choice is hydrangeas - Annabelle is completely winter-hardy up here and is a showstopper in full bloom. Not sure if this one is native, though.

  • 16 years ago

    you said: At about 1:30PM in summer, the line b/w sun and shade corresponds exactly with the plants that are thriving vs. those that look a little more sickly.

    ===>>>> but you also mention a maple ... is the low producing area closer to the tree???

    if so.. it might not be a shade issue.. as much as a tree issue ...

    in other words ... make sure your presumption about light is correct.. before you waste too much time and effort under a maple ...

    it is near impossible to grow ANYTHING under some maples ... if not all.. eventually..

    another fact you mention is how dry it is in that spot ... and that is not a sun issue ...

    let me put it this way .... i consider grass the single most evil invasive plant on the face of the earth .... it grow everywhere.. and anywhere .. and especially where i dont want it .... and yet.. under most mature maples.. it can not thrive ... not only from lack of sun.. but more likely.. lack of water ....

    if what i suspect is correct ... and maybe not.. who knows ... it might not matter what you want there.. you MAY not be successful ... because of the tree ... and i dont mean to stop you from trying.. i am just pointing out you may have misidentified the problem ...

    below is a pic of maple roots

    good luck

    ken
    {{gwi:208954}}

  • 16 years ago

    Agree with Ken to some point BUT it *is* possible to have plantings under a maple. I've done it. Under multiple maples.

    The trick is to find plants that handle the root competition and don't mind some dryness, and to plant a bit out from under the tree - I'd say at least 6 foot away from the base of the tree. There are also a few tricks you can pull out of your bag such as lining holes with garbage bags or sink large plastic pots to plant in, use moisture-absorbing crystals, etc. I have even gotten hydrangeas (!!) established under a maple tree, and they are thriving (the moisture crystals were invaluable here).

    Here's an example photo. You can see the shadow of the maple in the lower left corner. We have turtlehead, hosta, fern, brunnera, and you can see the edge of a hydrangea. The bed extends closer to the tree, you can't see it in the first photo. Anyway, the edge of the bed begins about 6' or so from the base of the tree. Hey, I think the plants are doing pretty darn well. I used the garbage bag trick to get the turtlehead going, but they've been there about 10 years already and are firmly established.

    {{gwi:195257}}

    Same bed, different angle. There's plants behind/next to the hydrangea you can't see in this photo:

    {{gwi:208957}}

    Point is - it takes effort to garden under maples, but it is possible if you're willing to do some trial and error and be creative in how you manage the problem.

  • 16 years ago

    Agree with Ken to some point BUT it *is* possible to have plantings under a maple.

    ===========>>>>>>>>

    of course its possible..

    but my point was to properly ID the problem ....

    ken

Sponsored
Schlabach Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars22 Reviews
Franklin County's Reclaimed Wood Professionals