Software
Houzz Logo Print
sakura2006

big disappointment!

17 years ago

I hired arborist to remove tree roots below ground to expand my garden.

Guess what?

I didn't realize but part of my back yard where I want expand my garden is nothing but pure clay and I cannot plant anything unless I add many bags of top soil, sand, peatmoss, etc to fix clay soil.

I tried to break up clay soil but it is impossible for me because dried clay is so hard and just like concreate.

What is easiest way to fix clay soil for people who want to plant flowers and vegetables?

Is there anything else I need to add to break hard clay soil?

One thing is sure.

I cannot plant roses on clay soil because of very poor drainage.

Comments (24)

  • 17 years ago

    It is easier to work after a rain. Take your time, work-up a small bed at a time, make raised beds, use compost, lots of 'em (I buy from a nursery). I also add coffe grinds, banana peels, epson salt, fireplace ashes (collected through the winter) and peat moss.

  • 17 years ago

    Don't add sand. It actually makes drainage worse. See the thread on cat litter, which eventually gets around to that point.

    When the clay is moister it may not seem so bad. The best time to work clay is when it is semi-dry so the clods break up when hit with the shovel. Don't work with it or step on it when it is wet, as doing so will compact it into a tighter mass.

    Peat, compost, or bagged manure will help-- a layer 2-3" thick tilled in 8-9" deep. Clay with organic matter is fine for roses if you never compact it when it is wet. Be sure to use paths or stepping stones, maybe boards, to step on.

    There is a type of amendment that does break up clay somewhat and ensures there will always be air in the soil. It is a porous gravel created by baking clay, shale, or slate at high temperature. Brand names include Turface, Profile, PermaTill, Schultz Clay Conditioner, Espoma Soil Perfector. A 3" layer is recommended, tilled in.

  • 17 years ago

    Huh? Let's start all over again.

    Roses love clay. Roses love water. Peatmoss is a drainage nightmare, topsoil is usually pure garbage, and why anybody would want sand is totally beyond me.

    You don't work clay when it's dry. You work it when it's damp. Not too wet, not too dry.

    Easiest way is to call a landscaper and ask if they have a small tractor. Not a tiller, but a tractor the next size up from a large homeowner kind. It should have a backhoe attachment, and can dig down a couple of feet without trouble.

  • 17 years ago

    Get yourself a decent smaller pitchfork.
    I got mine from Depot I believe. Much easier using the pitchfork then a shovel

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, the type of fork with flat blades, called a spading fork, is easier to use than a spade.

  • 17 years ago

    Clay is actually a good start. At least you know it retains moisture, as opposed to sand. I also do not recommend adding sand to your soil composition. I would contact the agriculture extension in your area and see what their advice is. Try digging a hole and see how long the water takes to drain. Maybe you'll find that you won't have to do so much amending after all.

  • 17 years ago

    I used a granular product (it's gypsum) called Soil Buster on the clay. Also, plenty of amendment as mentioned above. That is the beginning of good soil. And if you can, raise the bed; I used 2x4 boards which helps alot. Clay is great for holding nutrients, so once it's worked, you should have good results. Starbucks will provide coffee grounds, and if you can find a stable with manure to compost, all the better. I always use a pitchfork; it's way easier than a shovel. And after all is done, keep mulching. That will let the earthworms do the hard work from here forward. They are your best friend. Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    What? You can't plant roses in clay? That's news to my almost 100 rose bushes! In fact, we just dug up a new bed, almost all clay and planted roses.

    It's best if you wait till you've had a lot of rain, or you can run a soaker hose for a day on the soil. Then you take a spade fork, has wider tines than a pitch fork, and break up the soil/clay. They you can till it till all the large clumps are out. You may have to do 2-3 passes with the tiller. It's exactly like mixing a lumpy batter with your mixer and going over it again and again, until it's smooth. It's really kind of fun. Then you can add amendments and till them in. Lastly don't dig holes too deep. Rose roots will not penetrate hard clay down deep. If you get the first 10-12 inches tilled that's enough. Then over the years, you add compost and more amendments to the bed especially around the roses and the rose roots will grow in that. Also you will probably want to mound the roses up a bit to help with drainage.

    When the arborist removed the roots, he probably broke up the soil a bit. We removed two spirea from this bed and that left nice holes which helped use to break up the rest of the clay. I do wind up removing any large lumps of gray sticky clay that will not break up. I usually put them towards the back of the bed where they will not be near anything growing. But orange clay is very good, provided it's wet and not dry. When it's dry it's like concrete.

  • 17 years ago

    Spade, not pitch fork.

  • 17 years ago

    Spading fork, not pitchfork.

  • 17 years ago

    Ok everyone.. spading fork. My gardening brain isn't fully here yet.. couldn't remember the name.

    I have 2 spading forks. One is regular sized the other is smaller. I prefer the smaller one, have bought them from Sears, Depot & Walmart. I also use a 4-tine Cultivator the one I have is from Depot and again a smaller one.

    What we did last year was rented a Kubota, hubby dug the gardens out with it, taking some of the dirt out, we then added our mix. If the OP can't work a Kubota, they might think to pay someone to do it.

    I cannot plant anything unless I add many bags of top soil, sand, peatmoss, etc to fix clay soil.

    Don't buy by the bag. If you know someone with a pickup truck, ask them to bring you 2 yards of topsoil, some mulch and whatever else you need. One thing we do buy bags of is the Miracle Grow garden soil, by the pallet. I also buy a half pallet of the rose soil.

  • 17 years ago

    What mad_gallica said. My garden is planted entirely in heavy clay that bakes into concrete by mid-July. Most of the roses do just fine in it as long as drainage is decent.

  • 17 years ago

    Years ago when I hardly knew anything about planting..I lived in California and the dirt there was hard hard clay. We planted things and they never grew. Well at one point the city had planted 3 Mimosa trees along the walkway..they didn't die, but didn't grow either. The water just sat there and didn't drain. We found Gypsum..cheap and my husband used to drop in in the holes around the trees by the handful. Eventually the ground softened and last time I saw those trees they were big. Also there is a product called WATER In..you attach it to your hose and it makes the dirt softer. I love dirt..LOL. Part of my gardening obsession is working with bad soil conditions. I would start adding things to it..Free coffee grounds..compost..egg shells, bananas.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you people for your help to solve my clay soil problem.
    To be honest, that was rainy day and ground was soaked when arborist worked to remove tree roots.
    My guess is he compacted clay soil with that heavy machine because I even cannot put my shovel in and hard like stone!
    When I threw big chunk of dried up clay, it is just like throwing stone because never breaks.

    If I only knew I had clay soil, I never let him work on soaked clay soil to compace whole area of ground where I want to expand my garden but it is too late now.

    What I need to do is cover concreate like clay soil with about 10 inches of compost and work in clay soil with tiller when gound is moist.
    I am afreid if I break tiller by working on dried concreate like clay.

  • 17 years ago

    Don't get a tiller. They are practically useless. Even a mongo Troy_Bilt can really only work a couple of inches down. That doesn't get you anywhere you need to get down at least a foot. If you spread the compost, then bring in the tiller, the tiller will never even get down to the soil, it will just stir the compost.

    If you happen to have a tiller, and a large family, you can use the tiller to break up the top few inches, then dig all that out, and put the tiller back in the hole. Repeat until you've gotten down a decent depth. This is *not* a one-person job, but is more a way to get the most out of a tiller and a crowd.

  • 17 years ago

    What my garden center sells as bagged "topsoil" is not soil at all but some kind of muck, maybe feedlot manure. What a landscaper sells you as "topsoil" could be anything, maybe a bark-peat mix that will shrink over time and eventually turn into non-draining muck. In most areas it is impossible to buy real loam soil.

    Don't excavate and backfill with muck. Listen to the experienced gardeners here who have decades of successful experience growing roses in clay.

    You might want to get a soil test through the cooperative extension service (agricultural extension service) listed under the county. It is very cheap in most states. This would allow you to adjust the pH with lime, if needed, at the time of tilling. Sometimes these turn up unusual deficiencies or surpluses of nutrients. The test might show that you need to till in phosphate.

    So those things, and organic matter, should give you a decent start for your roses. If there is a drainage problem, add more soil or porous-gravel amendment (see my post above) so the area is raised 4-6" above grade.

    I will start a thread about testing drainage.

    If you want to dig in the dry soil, water it and allow at least one day for it to drain and disperse. Leave it alone until clods break when struck.

  • 17 years ago

    The ultimate tiller is the earthworm. If you are patient, just mulching and remulching with compost, fallen leaves, and coffee grounds will create easily workable soil due to earthworm activity.

    Please consider looking at your garden for the long term, rather than expecting instant results. Your soil didn't get ruined in a few weeks, and it can't be make superb in a few weeks, either.

    Consider the "lasagne bed" aka "interbay mulch" method for improving soil. It takes a little extra time, but you can get excellent results without back-breaking work, without spending a lot of money and without buying expensive equipment.

    Here is a link that might be useful: compost forum article on interbay mulch method

  • 17 years ago

    Get yourself some coffee grounds, tons of coffee ground. Coffee ground and tea grounds to worms are like fruit/wine to the gods.

  • 17 years ago

    Hey, how about a Spork!

    Spork

  • 17 years ago

    Quite frankly I would love this job! I might postpone the planting until you get the soil corrected. When you have accomplished and have a beautiful garden..the people who just shook their heads at your efforts can kiss your petunia!

  • 17 years ago

    Sakura,

    I think everything Michael has written fits your situtation.

    You have to spade the clay when it is slightly moist. When you have worked compost into clay, watering with a sprinkler (or rain) will "melt" some of the clay clods into the compost.
    Usually, clay has everything you need to grow roses if drainage is acceptable. You should be concerned that the trees depleted a lot of minerals, so a soil analysis will tell you if you need to add them back with a product like Milorganite. Tilling large amounts of compost and leaf mold into the soil is the quickest and most effective way to loosen the soil and lower pH as needed.

    My soil is heavy clay. Every Fall, I spade my vegetable garden, use a mower to mulch leaves (the neighbors don't mind me cleaning up their lawns), rototill the leaves into garden area to let them compost over the Winter, then rototill again in late Spring to prepare for planting. Of course, perennials must have the compost work done at or before planting.

    If you put compost (or mulch) on top and expect the worms to do the work, it will take time to get the benefit. If you don't find earthworms when you dig, add them. I love the cotton burr compost that is available locally. The worms love it too, and the robins love the worms!

    Keep us informed on your progress.
    Gary

  • 17 years ago

    I have clay soil and always have had it, but mine doesn't turn to brick like you describe. My personal experience differs from some other folks.
    Firstly, consider raised beds.
    I wish I didn't have all these underground pipes for the sprinklers, as I loved having a tiller in the previous place. It got down quite a bit more than a few inches and really mixed in amendments well. It was good for a veggie garden that got replanted each year.
    In my own experience, peat moss has been wonderful for my clay--the soil stays loose and friable longer than with other amendments that break down in one season.
    Funny how we all have different experiences in our gardens.
    Kathy

  • 17 years ago

    What my garden center sells as bagged "topsoil" is not soil at all but some kind of muck, maybe feedlot manure. What a landscaper sells you as "topsoil" could be anything, maybe a bark-peat mix that will shrink over time and eventually turn into non-draining muck. In most areas it is impossible to buy real loam soil.

    You're assuming that the "top soil" I can get is crap, and after your post, I realize other states might not have the selection of places that I do here in the Garden State; and I guess it was my assumption that the OP might know how to tell crap from decent stuff. We have places that only sell dirt/compost/mulch.

    I also admit that gardening in clay is new to me again, I used to have sugar sand at the old house. I'm not at the OP's house. There are various types of clay soil, what I have now is sandier then the clay I'm used to. According to what the OP is saying, it sounds like she may have the type of clay "soil" I have which is not red but looks like dried concrete.

    Depending on the size of the OP's garden, 2 yards of decent top soil doesn't go far when mixing it with the native clay (if she has someone dig part of it out like my hubby & I did) then adding the other goodies. The "top soil" I was able to buy made a good base when mixed with "my" native soil.

    Don't excavate and backfill with muck. Listen to the experienced gardeners here who have decades of successful experience growing roses in clay.

    There is no way anyone can give the OP exact advice since no one knows where she is and what type of clay soil she has. The best thing for her to do is contact her local rose society as well as having her soil tested.

    Everyone here can post all they want about what to use but the OP has to figure out how much of what to add. You know what works for you. I know what works for me.

    Peat, compost, or bagged manure will help-- a layer 2-3" thick tilled in 8-9" deep.

    Depending on what is available to them it might burn the roses.

  • 17 years ago

    I really have to second the PP who recommended the "lasagne bed" method. Here in NC we have red clay (think bricks). Two years ago I wanted to plant some roses & Gardenia. I did a little research - then I got a bunch of free coffee grounds from Starbucks, a good amount of newspaper, and grabbed an old bag of rabbit food (alfalfa). I sprinkled the coffee grounds, layered the newspaper, added the alfalfa, then watered well & repeated. I then planted straight into the clay, as best as I could since the "soil" was so hard. 4 to 6 months later, the plants were flourishing and the red brick clay was more like soil - I could put a shovel into with NO effort - and the ground was full of worms! I won't ever plant with out using this method again!

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert