Software
Houzz Logo Print
mbat_gw

Vinegar/peroxide to test soil??

18 years ago

Somewhere I read that you could use vinegar or hydrogen peroxide to test your soil's pH. I tried this with some indoor soil: nothing happened with the vinegar -- but the hydrogen peroxide bubbled a bunch -- so I guess the soil was acidic. (It was potting soil, by the way.)

Do you think this is a reasonable way to get a very crude idea of your garden soil pH?? I wonder if you could keep adding lime -- then mmix in some peroxide again to see if you had it about right. (It does seem much easier to get an actual accurate reading from the extension office, so you can get a better sense of how much lime/etc. to add.)

Thanks for your thoughts. MBAT

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    I'd never heard of that myself. I suppose it can give you and idea if you are on the acid or the alkali side but not how far.

    potting soil is usually mostly peat which tends to be quite acidic so the result of your test seems to support that.

    I suppose you could also soak your soil you want to test in water and then run an aquarium pH test on the water but that doesn't really tell you how you should go about liming your garden.

    Here is a link that might be useful: My Garden

  • 18 years ago

    the bubbling peroxide has nothing to do with Ph. Its just releasing oxygen because.................well,........... because thats what it does. I dunno why, just that it has nothing to do with PH.


    sorry, I have a business degree, not a science degree. hee!

  • 18 years ago

    The hydrogen peroxide is reacting with the organic material in the soil. That is the cause of the bubbling; as noted above, it does not indicate pH. Similarly, vinegar will react with some mineral components of soil to sometimes cause boiling. It also does not indicate soil pH, although soils with a lot of mineral calcium in the right compounds (like carbonate) can be particularly active bubblers with vinegar. Some of these soils might tend to be more alkaline, but there is not a relationship between reactions and pH there, either.
    Renais

  • 18 years ago

    I think vinegar is a bad thing to put in the soil anyway, I used it to kill the moss inbetween the patio bricks.

  • 18 years ago

    Vinegar applied to a small soil sample can indicate an alkaline soil if it bubbles, because it is reacting to something that is causing that soil sample to be alkaline. How alkaline that soil is can only be determined by a good, reliable soil test.
    Hydrogen Peroxide will bubble with any soil because it is reacting with the bacteria in that soil. the only time I've not seen H2SO4 not react is when there are no bacteria around, a sterile something.
    To test for an indication of a soil with a low pH mix a bit of baking soda with some water and applie that to your soil sample. If the bubbles that can indicate an acidic soil but again just how low the pH would be requires a good, reliable soil test.

  • 18 years ago

    Vinegar does not tell you if your soil is alkaline or acidic. It tells you if your soil contains lime. Lime and soil alkalinity are often linked but they are not mutually inclusive. It is very common to find slightly acidic soils with pH values in the mid to high 6's containing lime. They are acidic, but they will bubble. It is also very common to find alkaline soils with pH values in the 7's and even 8's with no lime. They are alkaline, but the absence of measurable lime means that they will not bubble.
    Some labs even use this same method (but with sulfuric acid rather than vinegar) to determine lime content in soils. They will usually rate lime content as "low", "medium" or "high" depending on how much it bubbles. It is a bit subjective, but still useful. It is referred to as "qualitative lime content".