Software
Houzz Logo Print
kmac_grower

replacement of backyard soil

17 years ago

I have a 13' X 32' yard in brooklyn, NY behind my 160 yr old house. I have found in the soil, which has virtually no worms or other living things in it, small pieces of glass, porcelain chips, water-saturated wood, rock, clay (has an almost powdery consistency) a small dog wrapped in black plastic and very large bolts and screws. i suspect that through the years a number of outhouses were constructed and then thrown over, eventually being buried. i have dug down approximately 18" in portions of the yard and worked compost and mulch into it, but i don't grow anything in it that i would eat. i have constructed a large box for growing food, but would really like to be using the yard for that purpose. my idea is to have the entire yard dug out and replaced with safer soil. i wonder how far down i'd have to go, 3'? 6'? much of the soil in brooklyn is contaminated by lead which i'd certainly like to avoid. the issue is compounded by the fact that my house is attached on both sides and the only way into the backyard is through the basement, which would necessitate this all being done by hand, both the carting away and the hauling in. has anyone out there replaced their whole yard? ever considered it? what was your experience? and what did you look for in replacement material? thanks.

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    kmac - I live in a similar house. It was built in 1820. It is terraced (ie in a row) and there is no access except through the house. I have just dug the garden thoroughly and removed all the debris I find. I have beds around the sides and paving in the centre. I have a compost heap in one corner and I just add compost to the soil whenever I have a batch. Unless you know for certain that some noxious materials were dumped there I would personally just gradually dig and amend. Perhaps you could get the soil tested before you take the expensive route. I would avoid it if at all possible. When we had a small extension built the amount of earth that had to be bagged and removed was huge and that wasn't even a fraction of the size of the whole plot. The things you describe don't sound worse than just everyday historic rubbish. In fact it can be quite interesting. I have found huge numbers of clay pipes on my allotment and lots of bits of china in the garden. The dog is a bit gross. Why the plastic? It would have composted much better without.

  • 17 years ago

    Very smart to consider replacing the soil. Years of using tetra ethyl lead in gasoline has rendered NYC soil toxic.

    I have replaced large parts of a yard. Hard work.

    You might consider using a conveyor to move the soil. I used a wheelbarrow but I had a flat access to a trailer.

    If that were my yard, I'd dig down two feet and test the soil at that level to see what the lead levels are. My local big-box home improvement store has lead testing kits.

    The potential for outhouses being a health concern is less than the potential for heavy metals in the soil from airborne contamination and from lead-based paint.

    I have ancestors who lived in the Elmhurst area back in the 1670's. Early on it was called New Town and Newton.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with the soil test but it won't be a fertility test. Test for heavy metals. These tests are done by specialized companies and usually not at your local county extension service. You can't go through life afraid of your soil. Rather than digging up the yard, you might need a special tool to dig out a core sample to 3 or 6 feet deep.

    Assuming you find it is okay and within normal, safe, levels, then you can get a fertility test. It is likely that any serious improvement to the vitality of the soil can be done with compost and/or mulch and/or organic fertilizer.

    If the soil is not safe, ask the people who did the test for their ideas as to remediating the soil.

  • 17 years ago

    I would think raised beds and containers would be the way to go It just wouldn't be feasible to remove the soil and carry the new though your basment my hand

    It could just be me but I would be worried hiring a testing company and talking about soil removal I can envision men in hazmat suits handing you a bill for cleanup..

  • 17 years ago

    Throughout Brooklyn are Community Gardens, most built on abandoned lots and most all will have raised beds to grow vegetables for the reasons that you suspect. I would not even bother having your soi ltested because much of Brooklyns soil already has been and been found to be heavily contaminated. Look around for Community Gardens near you and talk with the people that work them.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Kmac --

    If you are still following this thread - would you mind contacting me directly? No worries -- it's all good!

    With best regards,

    Tamara Amey
    GardenWeb Community Manager

  • 17 years ago

    I wholeheartedly agree with raised beds as the way to go for vegetables.

    You should also look into mycoremediation, which is growing mushrooms on contaminated lands. besides being a fantastic ancient plant/animal/fungus, many varieties of mushrooms have successfully been used to remediate heavy metals in brownfields, and also nuclear radioactive sites. they just suck up all those toxins, at which point you collect and send to the garbage, in a much less contaminated state btw.

    Mycelium Running is a great book on the topic.
    http://www.amazon.com/Mycelium-Running-Mushrooms-Help-World/dp/1580085792

    thermophillic composting is also a good remediator and 'healer'. The 'Humanure handbook' has great study stats on how effective composting is for toxic soils. Maybe you could dig up portions of your yard soil to compost with manure and other greens for a period of time?

    Look into 'brownfield remediation' online for ideas. Mushrooms are a top notch way to go.

  • 17 years ago

    13' x 32' is a big yard for most Brooklynites. Talking with others in the area that have been through this before sounds like a great idea. I'm wondering if you might end up having to remediate over time with non-food plants and compost and worms, etc. and then putting in your raised beds. I suggest you check out the web site for NYS Depart ment of Environmental Conservaction (or NYS DEC). NYC also has an ECB (Environmental Control Board).

    Here is a link that might be useful: NYS Dept. of Env. Conserv.

  • 17 years ago

    I would definitely get some tests before spending a lot of effort and money replacing soil you don't know is contaminated, especially after you've worked all that organic matter into it. Heavy metals are very cheap to run, maybe $20 a sample. Look in the yellow pages under Environmental Laboratories or consult your Ag Extension agent for advice, or the state as suggested. But don't make decisions based on no data. If it turns out to be safe you can sieve out the potsherds.

  • 17 years ago

    I have started to replace my soil with soil from the suburbs. I look on craigslist for free dirt from small projects in post 1978 housing, test it ($20) and then if it's good (and if they'll wait 2 days for the test result) I take it home. It's very slow. I have one foot deep 8 x 12 bed done with about 1/2 soil and 1/2 manure. I lined it with 6 mil. plastic because I found old burned trash, batteries and medical products (nebulizer drugs) where I wanted the bed. This was in addition to the ridiculous lead levels. I LOVE having clean, non-toxic "real" soil in my yard. The rest of the yard we're just going to sod and then little by little fill in with clean dirt. Luckily our grade works out that we'll be able to add about 6" of soil to the yard. It's a shame, because the yard has really nice humusy soil compared with the rest of the city and the dirt I've added is really heavy clay. I guess the soil in Brooklyn would be really gross as well. I'd test it for heavy metals.