Software
Houzz Logo Print
kentstar_gw

Soil mix for container roses

16 years ago

What kind of mix do you guys use for your potted roses? I was on the container forum and read about Tapla's (Al's)Gritty Mix. I can't get hold of Turface here (or at least not economically) and all I saw was Pine Mulch with dime sized pieces. I made the mix with the Pine Mulch, the Perlite, MG potting mix (which is just a lot of peat anyways), a small amount of CRF, a very small amount of Garden Lime, and found two small bags of Bonsai Soil which contains Turface. Hope I did ok and don't kill them lol!

I did drill more 3/4 inch holes in the bottoms of each pot (about 6 more holes) and even wicked them.

What do you guys do? Did I screw up? lol

Comments (22)

  • 16 years ago

    I understand the gritty mix is good. I just wish I had the space and time to mix my own, but I do not. So for my 40+ roses I grow in containers, I use commercial potting mix. I have used Miracle grow, Walmart brand, Lowe's brand and this year I found at BigLots, Scotts potting mix for $8 a big bag so that it was I am using this year and the roses are doing great.

    In fact some of them are in their 4th yr in the same mix. I do feed only organic or natural fertilizer and each pot has a wick to help pull the water through the pot.

    Really any good potting mix will work and I guess if I had the room and time I would mix my own. Good that you wicked them. I think that makes a difference and I use the wick as a gauge to see if the rose really needs water. If the wick is wet there is still water in the pot.

    Liz

  • 16 years ago

    What do you use as a wick?
    I had on hand some 3/4 inch cotton rope that my pet birds use when I make them toys. I thought, "hmmm, it's pure cotton rope, I bet I can use that!" lol I buy it at my bird supply store online and can get it in 20 lenths or more for cheap. It's like $3 for 20 ft!
    Thanks!

    Cathy

  • 16 years ago

    i have always used sunshine #4 with a little blood and bone for good measure and have had great results. through trial and error it seems that you can easily have to heavy a soil in containers, but rarely light enough.
    drainage is everything with roses.

  • 16 years ago

    I just use potting soil from Walmart. There generic miracle-grow type.

  • 16 years ago

    I use a combination of Lowes Sta Green Potting Mix, Miracle Gro Organic Potting mix and the regular Miracle Gro potting mix all together. I dump all the bags in a big barrel and stir them together. Sometimes I will add a small bag of Walmart potting soil. Potting "soil" is very different from "potting mix". You should not use alot of potting "soil" in containers, it gets too heavy and clumps together too tightly to where it will not drain good when watering. I add some Rosetone and Epsom salts to the mix too. A good thing to do every once in a while is to lift your pots up a few inches from the ground and drop them down again so the soil can become unpacked and you get out the air pockets. Don't do this with ceramic pots....lol, ..only plastic and do it sorta gently.

  • 16 years ago

    I never use Potting Soil to plant anything in, and you're right it is way too heavy for pots. My half barrel is too heavy to lift and drop lol. So I guess I'll just have to water well so the soil settles some. I've tried to prepare the pot now, so when the roses come the soil will be somewhat more settled. I just wish I could have gotten hold on the Turface instead of the Bonsai Mix. The Bonsai mix is gritty enough though I think, but too expensive to buy in bulk.

  • 16 years ago

    What do you expect, i'm a container virgin. lol
    I think i'll stick to in ground plantings. lol

  • 16 years ago

    I just used Scott's moisture control potting mix in mine. It retains water really well, almost as well as peat. I only chose it because it helps prevent the large pots of large Austins I have from going dry so fast in the summer heat.

  • 16 years ago

    Cathy

    For my wicks, I buy a roll of the cotton clothes line that I purchase from the Dollar General up the street.

    Liz

  • 16 years ago

    Clothesline, good idea. I might have to check into that. It might last longer too. Thankyou!

  • 16 years ago

    Cotton for wicks will rather quickly rot. Some sort of plastic clothes line is better. A wick helps somewhat but something like Tapla's mix is better as it is designed for good drainage. There is so much written about drainage in pots most of it wildly misleading. All that stuff in the bottom or bigger holes is worthless. A local "expert" in a lecture on the subject recommended several inches of pebbles in the bottom. Tapla would have fun with that. He of course has written endlessly on water movement in pots.

    Some commercial mixes use vermiculite which from what I've read is not as good as perlite. Well what do I know I'm just starting to grow roses in pots. Mainly because of the lack of hardiness of a lot of roses. Fortunately I have a large greenhouse so can over winter them in it. I also have made an area on the bench for mixing the stuff.

    Now as to Turface I've just barely checked into that.

  • 16 years ago

    I potted a few bareroots in the 5:1:1 mix before planting them in the ground.
    It worked quiet well and the potted plants which I planted in the ground are doing well.
    One thing you will have to be wary of is watering.
    You may have to water them quiet frequently especially in the heat of the summer.
    I was using 5 gallon buckets and I lost a couple of plants before I changed my watering schedule.

  • 16 years ago

    Good particentral!
    I wish I didn't have such a cold zone. Our winters get so frigid and snowy. Hopefully my rose in the wine barrel will be ok. It's too, too heavy to lift even onto a flatbed. It has to stay where it is I'm afraid.

  • 16 years ago

    Well all of my Austins pulled through this winter A-OK. However, I am located in downtown Columbus. I used 20" pots and I suppose the Scott's moisture control soil is more dense so it probably works as a subtle insulator as well. My potted Austins are:
    Bishop's Castle
    Abe Darby
    Pretty Jessica
    Evelyn
    Sharifa Asma
    Winchester Cathedral
    Golden Celebration
    Christopher Marlowe

    All of them were brand new last year and some of them were even bands that I purchased and planted in early August and they still pulled through the winter without a hitch and barely any dieback. With that said, I live in the city and we have less wind and it's typically warmer, so in a rural/country area it might be a different story.

  • 16 years ago

    I hope people are still following this thread!

    Ok, so I live under a rock. I never heard of Tapla before but enjoyed reading his Dave's you-know-where article on potting mix - lots of fluid dynamics going on here! Made a lot of sense once I got that he was talking of particle size vs PWT in his experiment with different heights of the same 'soil' having the same PWT.

    Sooooo, my question is, where does one locally find bark fines to mix ones own potting mix???

  • 16 years ago

    Do a search here under the container growing forums for gritty mix ingredients. You'll find a slew of info on places to try for the pine fines. If you have a John Deer Landscaping Co. around, they sell pine fines. They are usually sold as soil conditioners I believe.

  • 16 years ago

    I found them at Lowes in the garden center in a bag labled SOIL CONDITIONER.

  • 16 years ago

    I went to our Lowes and also online and no soil conditioners! Bummer...

  • 16 years ago

    I have been using Kellogg's Patio Plus the last few years. Dunno if Kellogg's is available in the east. Contents (of course without proportion) are:

    Composted forest products
    Canadian peat moss
    Composted chicken manure
    Rice hulls
    Horticultural sand
    Perlite
    Bat guano
    Kelp meal
    Worm casings

    I like it pretty well, but I think for larger pots I will do well having read this thread and Taplo's elsewhere to start adding more aeration as the big pots do get heavy. Haven't looked for pine bark fines yet but big bags of perlite can be gotten...

  • 16 years ago

    I did find that Bonsai soil has the Turface in it, but the bags you can buy are small and would cost quite a bit to get enough.

  • 16 years ago

    I would stay away from peat as much as possible. Soil conditioner(Lowe's Home depot etc usually has it) is a good basic material to use it mixed with other things.