Software
Houzz Logo Print
farfrae

Digging in wet soils, bad idea?

18 years ago

This might be really off base, but is digging into a wet soil, say after 1-2 days of rain, bad for the soil structure? I thought I had read this somewhere....

We just got a load of compost and spread it out over the beds yesterday. It is supposed to rain today and tomorrow. So, is it ok to go out and dig it in as soon as we get a clear day? Like I said, this question may be way off base.

While we are on the topic what things actually are bad for soil structure? We recently removed some overgrown shrubs and want to rejuvenate the planting area.

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    You should allow the soil to air dry because the molecular struture could be damaged and besides when transplanting the odds of getting out the air pockets with wet soil is slim. Walking or driving on damp soil is bad for the structure.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Propagating Perennials

  • 18 years ago

    Farfrae asks:

    "So, is it ok to go out and dig it in as soon as we get a clear day?"

    IMO, it is not a good idea to walk on ones bed when the soil is wet. The major concern is compaction of the soil thus driving out air, which is important to plant growth. And too, digging/tilling in the soil while it is wet causes the soil to clump together into what is called "hard to work soil". I always let the soil dry out somewhat before getting back out in the beds. One thing I have done is make all my lasagna beds narrow enough that I can reach into the middle of the beds without stepping on them. This allows pulling of any weeds that have popped up through the mulch, even when the soil is wet. Keeping it simple, soil structure refers to the different layers of the soil (i.e. mulch, topsoil, root zone, humus).

    Another thing to keep in mind is that as one continues to add organic matter the level of humus builds in the soil. Humus is the ultimate goal when working with compost, and each year that compost is added the level of humus increases. This humus level, even in the early stages of accumulation is invaluable for ones plant growth. As time passes and careful gardening continues, walking on the beds is a non-issue due to the fact that the soil is so "springy/fluffy/wonderful " from all that special treatment. However, even then IMO, one may want to think twice before working the soil while wet. I trust this helps in some wayÂ

    Blutranes

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your answers. Ok, this is probably hard to answer but, how long is long enough to wait for soil to dry out? If we have 2 days of rain, then wait 2 days?

  • 18 years ago

    Farfrae then asked:

    "Ok, this is probably hard to answer but, how long is long enough to wait for soil to dry out?"

    That is indeed hard to answer, for I am not familiar with your location. One of the benefits of having a profile and including your general location/state is that those members who live within your growing community/state are more familiar with you growing conditions; thus they can offer past experience in how they deal with rain.

    In general, depending on the amount of rain that fell, I usually wait two days before going out. Please remember I live in a sub-tropical zone, at times the soil can be dry in an hour after a shower. Again, those members who are your neighbors (per se) will be of greater assistance. I trust this helpsÂ

    Blutranes

  • 18 years ago

    From a farming standpoint, if it's dry enough to put a tractor and equipment on, then I would. There is an optimum time to be seeding in order to catch as much soil moisture as possible in the spring. While soil compaction is an issue, it is not the only issue and not everything will be perfect. I try not to obsess about it.

    Lloyd

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your help. I live in Lancaster county Pennsylvania; it is zone 6. Actually the rain held off so I went out and dug in the compost. We are looking to plant shrubs and perennials in this bed.

  • 18 years ago

    You wrote: "Ok, this is probably hard to answer but, how long is long enough to wait for soil to dry out? "

    Actually, that's easy to answer.

    The test is this: Squeeze a fistful of soil. If water comes out of it -- either a stream or drops -- it's too wet. If so, wait a day or so, then repeat the test.

  • 18 years ago

    To my way of thinking the only way you can really form compacted soil is to work all the air out of it. And that can only be done by working with wet soil. You can have hard soil that is not compacted but if you work wet soil and drive the air out, that is my definition of soil compaction.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Jean. If you squeeze it and it doesn't crumble, it's too wet to work. Woring wet soil will cost you for the entire season. Don't do it. When the soil dries up you can plant right through the compost you spread.

  • 18 years ago

    It depends. What is your soil type? How well does that soil drain? You could work sandy soils much faster than you can any clay soil and good loamy soils will be ready sooner than clays soils will be. Working a soil that is too wet can result in a compacted soil, again depending on the soil type.
    To determine when your soil is ready to work take a handfull and squeeze it tightly to make a firm ball. Poke that ball with a finger, and if it collapses, falls apart, that soil is workable, if it does not fall apart it is not workable, and if it will not ball up it is beyond workable, because soil needs some moisture to be workable.

  • 18 years ago

    I have gotten away with transplanting saplings and shrubs during and after very heavy rains but it is not reccommended. When you dig in saturated soil you tend to get a structure that is not very useable for a while.