Software
Houzz Logo Print
belgianpup

Another post on human urine in compost

18 years ago

I just couldn't stand it, okay?

And I didn't want to hijack another thread, so here we are.

YES, there is salt in human urine. There are also a lot of other valuable nutrients. We've all been bombarded with info that says sodium is bad, but it's only EXCESS that is bad. The human body will deteriorate without salt, and so will plants.

There are many soils that are lacking in sodium, which is a necessary nutrient. Is yours one of them? If your table beets, broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, apples or potatoes aren't doing well, you might have a deficiency. What does your soil test say?

The western states generally have a higher sodium content in the soils than other places (overall). I'm in a western state and the sodium in my soil is 1%, which isn't deficient, but not high, either. I could go higher without any problems.

If you have good calcium/magnesium levels, your soil can tolerate a lot more sodium than if they're poor. If you don't have a soil compaction/hardpan problem, having enough calcium in the soil will flush excess sodium right out. If you have excess sodium with good calcium/magnesium saturations, you may be short in sulfur, and adding some will also move the excess sodium out of your soil. What does your soil test say?

The people who are afraid of salt in urine are probably the same people who dump loads and loads of manure on their garden. Do they think that the horses and cows only poop out the manure and then run to a urinal to pee? Sorry, but all that animal waste is tromped together. There's salt in horse and cow urine, too, and even more in chicken poop. Why draw the line at human salt?

Some people flat out refuse to test their soils, and they don't know what they've got in excess or what their soil is deficient in. Maybe they're afraid they won't know how to read it, or that it will be so bad that it will give them nightmares, or that it will just be a waste of eight or ten whole dollars. Maybe they're just afraid and don't even know why. Feed fear and it grows; shake it out in the sunlight and it goes away.

What's the point in living in fear? Get the darn soil tested and find out where you stand. Maybe you NEED sodium, and all this time you were afraid to add urine to your compost pile. You had a free nutrient (among many others) and you squandered it with a bunch of nice, clean drinking water. Where's the sense of that?

Soil tests just don't cost that much. Personally, I would have a local lab test it, and then have another lab test it. Compare the results, just for fun. Compare the recommendations, for even more fun. (Neither will probably ever match.)

But DON'T cross the results of one with the recommendations of another, as they all tend to differ to some extent, and some by quite a bit. And don't bother to ask one lab to analyze the results of another lab, another recipe for disaster.

In fact, it wouldn't hurt to get your soil tested every year. Try to do it at the same time of year. Apply some of the nutrients the lab says to apply. How is it doing the next year? Is it okay? Did you go overboard? Did bringing your calcium/magnesium rates into line suddenly make other nutrients more available?

You won't know without a test. You can dump on all the manure and compost in the world and still be short of something crucial. But you won't know without a soil test. And all the second-guessing in the world isn't going to change anything.

Okay, I'm done. (pant, pant!)

Sue

Comments (16)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry, just can't help but tell you how much I wish you had resisted posting this.

    There is never going to be a consensus. Do it or don't do it. Each person's choice.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: 149 discussions on using urine in compost

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That's okay, Dave. A hundred and forty-nine, huh? How many were fact and how many were opinion?

    If my post encourages one person to get their soil tested, it was worth the effort.

    Sue

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "How many were fact and how many were opinion?"

    All of them.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Not that I'm going to get involved in the pros/cons of the topic, but leaves have sodium. An average of .22 lb/ton. Who knew!

    Click on the "download PDF" on the link below for da actual numbers.

    Lloyd

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rutgers Plant Nutrients in Municipal Leaves

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Sue,

    (Stepping up on the empty soap box)

    Your logic and knowledge about human urine is sound and valid, yet we humans are some really strange creatures. You see, my issue with using my urine is a matter of disclosure; please let me explain.

    Last year there was a hot conversation about using fresh horse manure on growing crops; long story short one member stated, "I hope you are telling everybody who visits your dinner table that those tomatoes were grown in hot steaming horse manure before they eat them. You can at least give your visitors a choice on weather to eat them or not." From that day to this, I make sure people know I use animal manures fully composted and cured for at least a year before I use said compost in my garden. People drive many miles for my vegetables and compost. I make no judgment about those who choose different as well as those who attacked the member for saying such a thing; but in my heart I knew she was right.

    Now comes my mother and my daughter. Do I really have to state what they would do if I were to disclose I have been "letting er rip" on the compost piles every chance I get? My mother travels over 800 miles to eat from my garden each year; it is not worth a few minerals to deceive her in such a manner. Yes, it is silly on her part; she grew up on this farm and complains about her father making her shovel out mule manure on the garden, but what is a son to do, save respect his mother? My daughter is her clone and a snitch; I rest my case.

    As it relates to a soil test, there is the issue of what I have learned in my readings and from members I trust. As you may realize, I garden with humus, and for a reason. My soil is red Georgia clay loaded with Georgia rocks. Until I started gardening with compost we could not grow anything but nut grass on this soil. I learned what I had to do to turn this soil fertile; humus was the answer, and humus is what I put on my beds. Every esteemed historic icon that I have learned to respect and emulate repeatedly states that testing soil that is rich in organic matter is a waste of time and money. I understand that plants are not like people (greedy), they only take from the soil what they need, and leave the rest. If every nutrient known to man is in the soil, the plant will give those nutrients back in the form of harvest. Our food today is severely lacking in nutrition, as we both know. As long as all those nutrients are in my soil they will be in my food for my family. I understand a living soil cannot be tested, those soil tests are for dead dirt, not living soil. I could explain it clearer, yet I am trying not to be too long winded on the matter.

    Those who use soil tests and human urine on their gardens have a right to do so; on this matter I truly understand. Yet what I have learned has stood and is standing the test of time, of this there is no doubt. And still, I remain open-minded to what you have said, for your posts are to be appreciated IMO, and will be held in the esteem they deserve. However, if man cannot define humus, how can he test it? We both know man cannot, he can only pretend like he can, so he estimates. I prefer to test my harvest by weight and at the dinner table. Now, let me get off this soapbox, my knees are starting to hurt. Thank you for your time and post

    Blutranes

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't test my soil because I don't care. I use as much organic material as I can get for my lawns and flower beds. If a plant isn't happy on my property, it can leave!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If my post encourages one person to get their soil tested, it was worth the effort.

    Well this is hardly the way to go about it. If that is truly your goal, then start a thread titled something like...oh, maybe...The importance of soil tests.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think its funny someone would think to say that you should tell people if you used manure to grow veggies. People really dont care what their food is grown in or where it comes from when they buy it from the store. Its just funny.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here is a study from a reliable source on the use of urine and feces as fertilizer (NB they don't mean sewage sludge aka biosolids). Interesting reading! Salt is mentioned 3 times, never at length and nothing about it being a serious hazard, just that dilution is sometimes recommended.

    Is it reasonable to assume that what can be applied directly to the soil can safely go on the compost pile? I think so. Applying urine directly to the soil may be more effective, though, in some circumstances.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Informative and thoughtful posts, Sue and Blutranes. Thank you. :)

    If I was the only person eating what I grow, I'd have no hesitation about adding pee to the garden. But, I give away food all summer long and well into the winter.

    My friends already think I'm a tad strange when I haul home 50lb bags of alfalfa and weekly loads of UCG and pile them up with leaves raked up in the park and yard waste bags scrounged from the street after dark, then cover up the lasagna layers with cardboard, paper, and burlap. They tend to look at me rather askance, when I ramble on about the crucial importance of the microherd and how to encourage diverse bacteria and fungal growth.

    Part of my own faith as an organic gardener is to spread the word about how it works. I want others to see and understand the process, as well as the product. When I can demonstrate the clear visible difference in soil which has been improved by organic materials -- and show the results, in increased plant growth and productivity -- I like to hope it will encourage others to try to do the same.

    However, if I told them I was achieving these results by peeing on my compost heaps, I think it would have a more negative impact. And I don't want to lie to my friends about what I'm doing. Or lie about what goes into the food I give to them.

    Like Blutranes, disclosure is a major issue for me. Perhaps if (when!) people grow more familiar with the many sides of small-scale organic gardening, folks will be more accepting and understanding of composting with pee.

    For now, for me -- I'd rather not piss them off. :)

    All the best,
    -Patrick

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I use urine all the time on my compost pile and have no diseases so why even worry about it. Pee away!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Great topic. The science and reasoning behind not doing it have been discussed pretty heavily. Not sure if we've covered the legal issues or where this all leads in the end. There may be ordinances in some locales that prohibit compost wetting or outdoor urination in general. I suppose city and apartment dwellers using the sawdust litter box methods might want to check into that.

    Either way, outdoor peeing or more accurately, "non-toileting" is more about the pure fun and sport of it than anything else. The Internet is chock full of folks into these activities. Capturing the diluted portion of N and saving a flush make it more acceptable to a "mainstream" gardening board such as this.

    The end result is that we begin indoctrinating children in kindergarten that each individual's "liquid gold" is wonderfully special. Then we begin to teach about the various alternative urination lifestyles & activities.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Words that might come in useful in threads on this subject urophilia, micturation, urolagnia, micturiology, compiss (obsolete), micturient, prycophants (obsolete), urinalysis and eschatological.

    And of course jumentous.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This thread needs stimulation. What would be the effect on compost of female urine containing estrogen and progesterone from women who take birth control pills?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think that is a wonderful idea. I wonder if some would do it if it was actually sold under a name in the garden stores. They seem to not care about the endless chemicals and poisons they put on their food. Or the ground insects that's been on it, or the manure that was urinated on countless times prior.
    If standing there doing the "trick" is the problem, do it into a cup discreetly in your home and take it out and pour it on. Very logical.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting