Software
Houzz Logo Print
ladycraft

Soil ?? Very basic

17 years ago

We have clay and rocks. I want to buy soil but am really confused as to what to get. I'm thinking raised beds. I see cheap top soil, potting soil & garden soil. I also see it sold by weight and cubic ft. Please help me decide which is the best buy. I know I will need to get compost/manure to go with it. I'm reading that there are alot of pros and cons on the mushroom compost. Opinions? I am thrifty (cheap) so what is best for my dollar? I don't mind spending the money if I'm getting what will work. Kathy

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    Soil is a mixture of minerals, eroded rocks and stones, and organic matter. More than likely what the soil you already have, that clay and rocks, just needs organic matter added to it. There is nothing magical about what the stroes sell as "topsoil" or "garden soil" except some of it may have a lot of organic matter mixed in while some will be nothing you would ever really want to add to your soil.
    If you do not make your own compost you should look for that and spend you money there and accumulate more organic matter (in Missouri each fall there are lots of leaves that fall off trees that make an excellent addition to almost any soil) from the vegetative waste that is generated.
    Forget the "soil" sold anywhere since that will simply be most of what you already have (the mineral portion) and very little of what you need (the organic matter).

  • 17 years ago

    ladycraft - are you near any of the larger MO fishing lakes? If so then ask around for what we down here call "creek bottom" soil and mix it with a good quality compost in your raised beds. Check it out by eye and hand first. It is very dark brown, nutrient rich dirt - very different from what is sold as 'topsoil' - and it crumbles in your hand.

    If you are in the Ozarks part of the state then like us you don't have dirt - you have fist sized rocks encased in clay because we are nothing but glacier scrub. So it won't help you grow anything unless you want to hand pick rocks for eons and raised beds is your only real option.

    As to mushroom compost? It isn't the best by far but it is better than nothing. Try to find a local source of manured compost - farms, ranches, etc. to mix with your dirt in a 50/50 mix if you can afford it or at least a 20/80 mix of 20% compost.

    Good luck.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Kimmsr, I guess I hadn't thought about the just needing compost. I do need some soil also but will work towards getting compost. I started composting last fall but didn't shred the leaves so kind of ended up with a mess. I'm working on getting that straighened out.

    Dave, I am in the SW of MO. Real close to Branson. I did call a guy that hauled lake something but was kind of sandy. The neighbor got alot of the silt stuff that was cleaned up after all the flooding last yr and his garden seems to be growing well. I should of got some of that. I need to look around to see if I can find manure. I don't know very many people around here but we have a employee classified section at work so will give that a try first. Thanks for helping me with the percentages.
    Kathy

  • 17 years ago

    You can often get "fill dirt" from construction sites but I don't reccommend it at all since it often does more harm than good. I like the ideas above much better. Your unshredded leaves will break down eventually. Someone on a previous post suggested daikon (sp??) radishes to help bust up clay. Some companies also sell "clay busting" seed mixes. Pond and stream silt can be very rich stuff but, as usual, it's good to know the source (silt from a detention pond for a parking lot might have petroleum, etc.).

  • 17 years ago

    Dave, I am in the SW of MO. Real close to Branson.

    Kathy - ahh I know exactly what you have to work with then. We are on the south side of Bull Shoals Lake. ;)
    Yeah the lake bottom stuff from after the floods last year is very sandy but good stuff if you can still get some but the stuff they dig out of the Tanneycomo/Table Rock feeder creeks is even better - but costs more too. With lots of good compost added either will work well.

    I hauled in a load of stable cleanings from one of the horseback trail riding places just outside of Branson a couple of years back (Bear Creek Trail Rides on Hwy. 65). Check the Branson.com website for a list of the stables around you and call them. Some will give it away free if you can haul it.

    And if you can explore the Reeds Springs/Branson West/Kimberling City area you'll also find some horse ranch sources. Just make sure that whatever you get from them is either well-aged or compost it yourself for awhile before using.

    Good luck.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I am really slow. I was thinking cattle but I know where the horse ranches are. I would really like to do the dump truck load but decided that is a lot of back breaking work. I'm thinking if I can unload at the correct location it will be easier. So the horse ranches sound less labor intensive. I hate getting old and having parts that don't work like they use to.

  • 17 years ago

    I hate getting old and having parts that don't work like they use to.

    Tell me about it. Especially when all the non-working parts get together. :^)

    Dave

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting