Software
Houzz Logo Print
v1rt

which dirt for pots?

13 years ago

I have an 18 inch wide, 12 inch deep pots. I used it last year to grow hyacinth bean vine. Unfortunately, the Schultz Potting Mix that I bought from Menards was so crap. If I remember correctly, I saw tons of dead yew like looking leaves or grain shells.

Which one should I buy from Home Depot or Lowes? I saw topsoil but not sure if I should buy it. I am planning to mix my soybean meal. I use the soybean meal for fertilizing the lawn.

Thanks!

Neil

Comments (6)

  • 13 years ago

    Pots need potting soil - not topsoil, not garden soil, not compost. Growing plants in pots/containers is very different from growing them in the ground and one cannot expect good results from following landscape gardening practices for container gardening. It is important to use a good quality, durable potting soil. It should have a good textural component, like bark, perlite or pumice or coarse grit. MiracleGro or Schultz and similar products tends to be too moisture retentive and too fine in texture.

    You will also find that using your soybean meal for container fertilization will not give you the same results as you could expect from it in the ground. That's because the necessary soil biology required to process and convert the meal into plant accessible nutrients are just not present in a container growing situation. You need a water soluble fertilizer. It can be slow release, like Osmocote or a fish emulsion or a "blue water" product like Miracle Gro or Schultz (ok for water soluble ferts....not ok for soils!!)

  • 13 years ago

    You should check out the Container Gardening Forum.

    also soybean meal has been shown to inhibit seed germination.

  • 13 years ago

    Gardengal is right on as far as my reading goes.
    You might want to go over to the container gardening forum to read some more. Nancy

  • 13 years ago

    A good potting soil will be one containing peat moss, finely ground bark, Coir, or a combination of those materials and they will not contain any soil. Good potting soils can be purchased for much less then what Miracle Gro and Schultz products sell for, although you may need to buy fertilizer as well.
    Some of us have used our compost as potting soil without any problems, but my compost more than likely is coarser then the bagged stuff in the stores since I do not grind it.

  • 13 years ago

    I have no doubt that the recommendations on the Container Forum would be the very best advice you can get for a 'potting soil recipe'. However I think for most amateurs who only have a few pots it's far easier to purchase a mix for the purpose.

    I've had very good results with "Sunshine Mix #4" for my containers. Haven't yet bought one this year but the price quoted on that site is $10. higher than my local supplier.

  • 13 years ago

    FWIW, I frequent the Container Gardening forum as well. Making your own potting soil is certainly feasible and there are many recipes available (2 of the best are Al's mixes from the CG forum). But that is not always practical for small usage or for an individual container. If available in your area, look for Farfard's Professional Potting Mix. It is probably the closest commercial mix to Al's recommended 5-1-1 recipe.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio