Software
Houzz Logo Print
jbird_in

Compost / Peat Moss Question

17 years ago

We decided to go with raised beds in our vegetable garden this year and were all set to order a load of compost from a local company. When I checked the company's website for prices, I found that the compost was described as "aged manure and peat moss". Isn't this just wrong? How can they call this compost? I don't think I want this stuff in my garden. I've noticed a lot of pros and cons about peat in previous discussions on this forum. We had a soil test done and our PH is 7.1. Any comments and / or help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

jbird in Southeast Indiana

Comments (15)

  • 17 years ago

    Sounds like good stuff if the price is right.

  • 17 years ago

    We have a local compost company that makes compost using locally generated cow manure and city landscape waste. Its too bad you can't find compost with local ingredients.

  • 17 years ago

    I have several raised beds made from aged manure and peat moss. Good stuff. The plants will grow very well it it.

    If the manure has been mixed with peat moss (a brown) and aged, a lot of people would call it composted manure. I've noticed a lot of varying opinions on what is considered "compost" but personally I think animal manure can be a compost if it's not fresh. As long as the plants will grow well in it, that's what matters to me.

  • 17 years ago

    If there is any one near you that has compost made from the tree leaves, a renewable resource, and manure purchase that. Using peat moss to make compost out of manure is a waste of a non renewable resource, especially when there could be readily available a better, renewable resource that when currently handled becomes a source of pollution. However, if this is the only compost available locally you may need to use it while strongly urging the person that made the compost to switch carbon sources.

  • 17 years ago

    It is a common misconception that peat moss is not renewable!

  • 17 years ago

    I agree w/greengardener07. I saw on the tv that peat is being harvested sustainably but you need to check the label to see. Some is strip mined in the everglades and that's not good. Some peat is harvested in a way where they only take a small amount in a given area and when its timed right it grows back by the time they harvest there the next time. Any way that's what I heard on the tv.

  • 17 years ago

    In order to try to keep this thread under 100 posts, I'll provide a summary:

    Peat is not renewable.

    Yes it is.

    Not it's not. Here are some links.

    I don't like your links. Here are some other links.

    My links are better.

    No. Mine are.

    Did you read my links?

    Yes. Did you read mine?

    I lost track of which side I'm arguing, so I'll generalize. Your links point to industry/environmentalist shills. My links are good. Yours are bad.

    Sigh.

  • 17 years ago

    The amount of peat used in gardening is insignificant and renewable. Most of the peat bogs that are loss are loss to development. But to answer the OP, a compost made up of manure and peat would be excellent. I've had great luck with that mix. In my sandy soil I've noticed that compost gets burned up quickly, especially in hot weather. Peat is a low octane slow release form of carbon that greatly improves my soil and stays there a long time. All my plants seem to love it.

  • 17 years ago

    A meeting of horticulturists in Iran in the 1970's issued a statement that peat moss is a non renewable resource.
    The British Hortucultural Society is asking its members to cease using peat moss because harvesting of it is unsustainable.
    Unless you live in a desert, or the plains, where few trees grow there are better, renewable resources that can be used, often at less cost, to improve soil.
    I watch people aound here diligently rake up, bag up, and actually pay to have these leaves that fall from trees every year, hauled away every fall and then in the spring go to the garden center and buy bags of peat moss to replace the organic matter they threw away the previous fall. I watch people around here diligently collect the grass clippings when they mow, bag them, and pay someone to haul them away so they can go to the garden center and pay for a few nutrients to repalce the thousands they just tossed out. Like buying white bread made from flour that has 25 nutrients removed during milling and has 10 nutrients put back in and is called "enriched".
    In Indiana there should be no good reason for someone to buy peat moss to compost manure.

  • 17 years ago

    The British Hortucultural Society is asking its members to cease using peat moss because harvesting of it is unsustainable.

    Something I completely agree with here.

    If you live in Britain, please do not use locally harvested sources of peat moss. Limited supplies along with mismanagement of peatlands and years of overharvesting have led to dwindling peatlands. Try to use a local alternative, or peat moss supplies from Canada, Russia, or other northern european countries. Most of those sources harvest less peat moss each year than is created, and have sustainable management plans in place.

  • 17 years ago

    Nutritionally, using peat as a carbon for composting would probably be close to the equivalent of using sawdust, wood shavings, wood chips, paper or cardboard. All of these items could be used, but would add little in the way of nutrients for the finished product.

    If the intent is to compost the manure just to get rid of it, any of these items would suffice. If the intent is to produce a better grade of compost then other carbons (leaves being my favorite) might be a better choice.

    If a company is composting to be the most environmentally correct, then that is a different issue again and a whole bunch of parameters would have to be examined to know for sure which might be the "best" carbon.

    If a person has an objection to using peat from a values standpoint, I would suspect there ought to be other companies around that could fulfill their requirements.

    Lloyd

  • 17 years ago

    adding LOTS of PEAT MOSS is WAAAAAY NOT ECO/PLANET FRIENDLY. Try to find other ways.

    check out the following web pages for more options/info:

    http://www.extension.org/pages/Raising_Soil_pH_and_Soil_Acidification

    http://www.gardenrant.com/my_weblog/2009/04/ken-druse-dishes-the-dirt-about-peat-moss.html

    add pine needles or pine wood chips to your compost maybe oak leaves?

    ALSO test your WATER pH!!

  • 17 years ago

    Bpgreen, you are priceless.

  • 17 years ago

    "Bpgreen, you are priceless."

    My teenage daughter thinks I'm worthless. Priceless and worthless are the same, right?

  • 17 years ago

    Go Ken Druse.