Software
Houzz Logo Print
esobofh

Soil Test Results

19 years ago

Ok so I decided to spend $70.00 to have a lab run a complete soil analysis on my garden. I have soil that was a sand/clay mixture under my lawn and into that I've worked a mixture of mushroom manure, composted bark mulch and river sand. This is in my beds, a total depth ranging from 15-20".

The folks I bought the compost/manure mixture from assured me this would be top-notch garden soil and I would have fabulous results from a vegetable garden. In order to approximate the mix of soil in my yard, I took equal parts of the original soil and the new compost mixture to the lab to be analyzed.

Now, I'm hoping some of you more expereinced folks out there can tell me what I am looking at here, and make some recommendations.

Imagine my suprise when I see my "fabulous" soil is deficient in all three of the "main" fertility areas; Nitrogen, Phosphorous & Potassium.

Now - I've seen organic fertilizers that have NPK numbers in the decimals.. but I've heard that it just means they are available to the plant differently and are equally strong and effective as chemical counterparts. Does this mean my soil is good, or is the lab report pretty much saying that I need to augment with alot of fertilizer?

Near as I can figure from the recommendations listed here, for my 144sqft of garden beds presently, I'll need about a half pound of nitrogen - does that sound right?

Where can I get a half pound of nitrogen?! hehe

The link below is a picture of the new soil resting on the existing soil in the bed.

thanks for your help!!

Here is a link that might be useful: A look at the new soil on the existing soil

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    I wouldn't be surprised that it's low in N. N leaches out of the soil easily, so you'll almost always show a need for N in a soil test.

    I think your math is correct in determining the amount of N you need, but that seems pretty high if they mean for you to apply it all at once. I suspect you're supposed to do three applications.

    Are you trying to stay organic? If so, you could get 1/2 lb of N from about 30-35 lbs of coffee grounds (10-12 lbs at a time). Starbucks has a corporate policy of providing used coffee grounds for free. Since you're fairly close to Seattle, do you have Starbucks, or is it still Tim Horton's country? I don't think Tim Horton's has that as a corporate policy, but I've heard they tend to be pretty willing to help out. One caveat with coffee grounds. Don't spread them too thickly, because they can repel water.

    Other organic sources of nitrogen include various grains (I don't know the N content of these), blood meal (expensive, and high enough in N that it can burn), manure.

    If you don't care if it's organic, any fertilizer will work. Just divide .5 by the percentage of N (the first number) then multiply by 100 to get the number of pounds of fertilizer you need. For example, if you have 10-10-10 fertilizer, divide .5 by 10 to get .05, then multiply by 100 to get 5, so you'd need 5 lbs total (I'm thinking over the course of the year).

  • 19 years ago

    i'm not an expert, but i have vegetable gardened (organically) for 25 years now, and have tried several different approaches. almost all of them have been successful in producing nice, healthy crops. i've rarely done professional soil tests. people here will tell you there's no sense amending your soil until you test it, and that's a good point. anyway, what i have done is use products like bone meal (P), blood meal (N), kelp and wood ashes (K), greensand (K), and rock phosphate (P) in recommended quantities, mix them together, and scatter them over the soil. then i sort of chop it in with a garden rake, to get it into the top couple of inches. these are slow release, natural powders. i did this for many years, tho i've moved away from the blood and bone meals in the last few. this always produced healthy crops, but it didn't enrich the soil texture. more recently i've relied on putting compost on the planting areas, mulching with chopped leaves and/or straw, not tilling at all, and amending the soil every other year. the crops are still very healthy looking, and the soil has never looked better. you'll get more informed advice from others, but this method has always done well for me.

    hope this helps,

    debbie

  • 19 years ago

    Nitrogen availability is very dependent on soil temperature so very few labs bother testing for that today. What the lab is testing for is readily available nutrients, which give an indication of what is totally available, and the recommendations for balanced crop nutrition are really quite low, so while it might appear just looking at the numbers there might be a problem those results may be simply because you sent in the sample too soon after mixing them. While I would be a bit apprehensive about the soils pH, high neutral, I would concentrate on adding more organic matter, less of the mushroom compost, and test again in 5 years to see how things are in comparison unless "stuff" has a real problem growing. You know for sure something about your soil that those that never have a soil test do not know, the nutrient load.

  • 19 years ago

    I was surprised at the pH, since you're in western BC, until I saw that you added mushroom compost. I think if you test again in a month or so, the pH will be lower.

    Mushroom compost tends to be high pH, but your native soil is probably somewhat acidic, so I don't think it'll cause a problem if you use it in moderation. If the pH stays high, I'd cut back on it or skip it when adding more organic matter.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the great tips all - Fortunately the west coast of Canada is all starbucks country (actually we have an intersection in vancouver that has a starbucks on two corners). I will get a load of grounds and try that, I definately want to stay organic.

  • 19 years ago

    esobofh I looked at the slide show of your gardens. I'm totally amazed. Stunned. Envious. Speechless. Congrats.

  • 19 years ago

    Jbann23 - Thanks!! :)

    It's a load of work. But it turned out nice. We still have to complete three remaining 4x12 beds and a 12x20 greenhouse but, in time :). It's amazing how much time you *don't* have when you start a project like this. 3 Beds are up and growing now, and doing well so that gives me incentive to press on. I'm glad you like it!

  • 19 years ago

    If you grow legumes be sure to inoculate them--facilitates nitrogen fixing. You can order garden quantity inoculant from Johnny's Seeds.