new to OGRs, need basics
I have grown about 10 HTs in the past and 1 climber but never an OGR. Are there any differences other than the aesthetics? i.e, are they easier or more difficult to grow than HTs? Are there any other considerations?
Is Antique Rose Emporium a favorite vendor or do you look for them elsewhere?
Any information would be appreciated.
Comments (39)
- 19 years ago
Stay away from the ones described as for beginners as they will lose their appeal in a few years and you will be stuck with a big healthy plant taking up far more room than you really want to give it.
I am serious-been there,done that.Do a lot of research as to what thrives in your area and go for some with lasting appeal.It takes quite an impressive Ogr to hold its own amongst the Hts.Something to consider-the knockouts can hold their own.I saw some at Walmart that look like LaMarne-wow. - 19 years ago
For specifics I'll have to defer to members in your zone, but as for general info, the aesthetics are a big part of the appeal for me.
The age of the rose, the history, the bloom form of OGRs, and especially the fragrances, are all part of the appeal.
Added to that is the fact that I have not sprayed anything (anything) this year, and nearly all the old roses are clean and healthy, with not a speck of rust or blackspot or mildew. I figured that if they were introduced without the need for chemicals, they would fit into my own needs for organic gardening - with kids and pets, I'd rather forego stuff that requires testing on living creatures.
Since I'm in CA, I get my roses from Vintage. There are many other fine OGR vendors around the country.
Did I mention fragrance?
Andrea
Related Professionals
Athens Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Morgantown Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Newport Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Longview Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Edison Landscape Contractors · Anchorage Landscape Contractors · Sarasota Home Builders · Greenfield Home Builders · Niles Home Builders · Grand Forks Home Builders · Superior Home Builders · Sacramento Home Builders · Roswell Home Builders · Ogden Home Builders · Spanish Fork Home Builders- 19 years ago
I totally disagree with Pete...I say get some of the bulletproof OGRs. Success breeds success. Some of the simplest of the OGRs are still the most beautiful.
OGRs are, to me, infinitely easier than hybrid teas. I don't spray anything either, and mine are doing just great. They have to be treated differently from HTs...e.g., most don't want to be hard pruned. Many will like to get big, and some can become small climbers quite easily...I train mine on rebar.
Start with some of the easiest (full proof for your area)...hopefully Olga will offer you some suggestions.
Robert
- 19 years ago
Sorry-did not mean to infer there is anything wrong with Ogrs/antiques in general.Some such as MvH are a true thing of beauty and just keep growing on you.Others can get to be very blah so keep in mind that you want to be picky about what you choose same as with moderns.
- 19 years ago
redsox:
Did you email me yesterday? I got a mail from "you" that was flagged as spam and had an attachment that I trashed, but I answered the mail as best I could.
- 19 years ago
Two weeks ago in another of your threads I suggested a visit to the huge rose garden in Lexington KY. That suggestion gets doubled re your question about OGRs. The collection there shows what grows well and wonderfully in KY.
(Add me to those who disagree with Pete's advice.)
As to sources, I prefer to buy from folks in the east. Lower shipping costs and their proven roses survive in a climate more like ours.
Some suppliers:
Appalachian Rose in Tellico Plains TN
Ashdown Roses in Landrum SC
Roses Unlimited in Laurens SC - 19 years ago
I started looking into OGRs last year. There is so much to learn. I have added a link below that will give a basic description about the different classes.
Each of your questions can be answered any way. It depends what plant you choose and what you are looking for. Some plants only boom once a year, others will bloom in spurts. Some will grow up to 20ft and then some. Some are finicky and others like to be left alone.
I have ordered from Chamblees, Roses Unlimited, Ashdown, Pickering, Countyside Roses and Heirloom Roses.
Whatever you are looking for I'm sure there is an OGR that will fit the bill.Here is a link that might be useful: Rose Classifications
- 19 years ago
Oh I should add that ordering from a nursery close to you can be quite useful: same climate conditions so less of a shock. Also if you buy grafted, they may tend to use a rootstock more suited to your area.
Of course, if that fails, you just buy from whatever nursery has the roses you are looking for.
Also you'll want to think about own-root versus grafted roses. With HTs you don't really have a choice. For OGRs, some roses do better with grafting onto a stronger rootstock and some do better on their own roots. Some (mostly Gallicas) will sucker on their own roots, some more vigorously than others. Just another thing to think about!
- 19 years ago
Time is a very effective filter. For a rose to last through the ages there usually has to be a very good cause. Fragance, beauty and heath being 3 such factors.
It would be hyperbolic to suggest that OGRs are disease and pest free. But if well chosen for your area (very important) they can give you an opportunity to garden "with nature" rather than the resort to toxic chemicals that is so often associated with trying to grow Hybrid Teas in places where they are really unsuited.
However, do research your conditions. There are OGRs that will mildew or blackspot like crazy, if these conditions are prevalent in Kentucky, look for roses with good disease resistance. Some classes of roses need winter chill, some perish in extreme cold. Again research what roses are appropriate for your area. An OGR label is not a "free pass" to healthy plants, but can open huge opportunities to grow roses which can "naturalize" to your conditions.
Because the habits of Old Roses are much more variable that HTs, there are far more options in how you might use them in a garden.
Paul Barden's website "Old Garden Roses and Beyond" has wonderful photographs and information on selected OGRs (and some reproductions) by class. You may want to check it out.
Good luck on the adventure !
Bill - 19 years ago
Like everyone else has said, there are many different kinds of old roses: you can't lump them together in one group. The tea rose 'Clementina Carbonieri' is totally different from the Alba 'Maiden's Blush', for example. You may have the advantage in your zone of being able to grow at least some of the warm-climate old roses--Teas, Chinas, Noisettes--as well as the kinds that need winter chill like the Gallicas, Albas, Damasks, etc. One quality that most old roses share is that they are much more shrubby plants than Hybrid Teas. Hybrid Teas tend to be spare, bold, striking, and sometimes harsh in the garden, if they're grown for garden effect at all and not exclusively for their blooms. Most of the old roses are far softer in effect; some kinds--Albas come to mind--are luxuriant and noble, and at the same time modest, in a fashion no modern rose can offer. In the case of the old roses the plant is definitely not just a support system for beautiful flowers: the loveliness comes from the foliage, form...everything about the shrub. Many old roses are very thrifty, easy to care for plants, at least in my garden, though disease resistance in a given variety depends on the location. Not all classes are equal either: I believe Hybrid Perpetuals, for example, have a reputation as a class for being disease-prone and generally fussy.
I hope this helps. I love the Old Roses, and hope you'll have a wonderful time with them.
Melissa
- 19 years ago
One technicality is the verbal distinction between "OGR" and "antique" roses, which doesn't actually make much sense. Classes of roses that were developed in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries are not called OGR. These include very good groups for Kentucky-- hybrid musks, rugosas, polyanthas, and old ramblers, which include a lot of easy-care roses that repeat. Rose classes are described in the forum FAQ.
Consider putting up a good-sized structure to hold a rambler. If you have nondescript shrubs in the yard, replace them with hybrid musks, albas and gallicas. Once-bloomers that don't need much if any spraying are a winning proposition, and they make several times the impact of a hyrbid tea. If I had a big yard, I would grow lots of them.
Most damasks, bourbons, and hybrid perpetuals would probably need spraying in your area. You would need local advice about how teas, chinas, and noisettes perform. Contact a rose society in the area (see ARS.com) and see if anyone is growing them.
redsox, I asked on another thread if you emailed me a couple of days ago.
User
Original Author19 years agoIt sounds from the last 2 posts that the Reine des Violettes that I had my heart set on would be a big pain in the neck!
- 19 years ago
Don't assume that; do some research. 'Reine des Violettes' is a popular rose. Do a find in this forum on it and see what comments come up. I know I've seen at least one major thread on it.
Melissa
- 19 years ago
We are just generalizing about bourbons, HPs, centifolias, etc. being more disease susceptible. There are exceptions and gray areas. If you want Reine des Violettes, get it. I haven't grown it, but I haven't heard anyone say it's a difficult rose. The SdlM group of bourbons is fairly resistant to blackspot.
- 19 years ago
I've mostly head good things about Reine des Violettes and it is on my "to buy" list. I think it gets a little larger so you'd want some space to grow it in, or train it as a small climber or on a pillar.
The thing to watch for with this rose, I believe, is that there are versions available for sale. Make sure you get the ones that is nearly thornless. That is the good one, and nearly thornless is almost always a plus when choosing a rose anyways :)
- 19 years ago
Ok, how about some specific roses? Recognize that these roses may be "old", but not necessarily fit the American Rose Society definition, which lists "OGR" as those existing before 1867. Also, many do get blackspot, but with an otherwise healthy bush won't kill it, and it will keep on blooming. I really like the Buck roses such as Carefree Beauty. Quietness is another that is closer to a hybrid tea form. Some Chinas may be borderline for your climate, but ones like Cramoisi Superior and Mutabilis will give years of healthy foiliage and blooms without spraying. I think a lot of these roses are best when integrated into the landscape without the formal rose garden thing like you may be used to. I don't spray mine, but some on this forum do. Many get very big- something a lot of Hybrid Teas have trouble doing. Antique Rose Emporium is one of many excellent sources, and has lists of attributes to help get you going.
- 19 years ago
It sounds from the last 2 posts that the Reine des Violettes that I had my heart set on would be a big pain in the neck!
*** Actually, RdV is a rose who is good over a wide variation of conditions. We grew her here for 20 years, and I know she's grown well in other areas with far different conditions.
Redsox, I see that you are in KY. I may be able to put you in touch with some experienced Old Rose people in your area. Contact me privately, and we'll see what we can do. I'd love to rhapsodize over the Old Roses I love best, but they might be the wrong things for you, and I'd rather not steer your wrong.Jeri Jennings in Coastal Southern California
(Just back from the Celebration Of Old Roses) - 19 years ago
REINE DES VIOLETTES is a M-U-S-T have! I'm not kidding. Mine is 3-4 years old, grafted from David Austin Limited, and trained around an iron tuteur. Grown in partial shade (which is a killer for most roses) she is in full, and I do mean FULL, flush right now. Gorgous purply pink flowers all over the canes, which BTW have no thorns. Both flowers AND foliage are fragrant. Yep the leaves smell like roses and spice. As a specimen this plant puts off a lot of fragrance. Lastly, she is much more resistant to black spot than any Hybrid Tea, Grandiflora or Floribunda that I've ever grown.
Don't bad mouth RdV. She is an EXCELLENT rose.
- 19 years ago
The mistake that I made at the beginning was reading about roses in books written for the East Coast or England, and buying them based on descriptions. Some bored me stiff (Hermosa,for example, has no appeal for me), while others didn't do very well.
If you can, it's good to look at roses growing in your area, or in reasonably nearby areas, and to talk to local rose people. Don't know about Kentucky - Ohio has a great garden in Wooster, the Garden of Roses of Legend and Romance. There's also an OGR portion in the Columbus rose garden.
Anita - 19 years ago
CEMETERY ROSE SAID:
"The mistake that I made at the beginning was reading about roses in books written for the East Coast or England, and buying them based on descriptions."*** That should be graven somewhere on stone. It is a profound truth.
Jeri
- 19 years ago
The same could be said for books written by authors who garden in California (which accounts for approxiately 99% of the rose books written in the USA). That is why this forum is so useful. Most roses behave differently depending on region and climate. My advice is to place more weight on those replies from rosarians who live closest to you.
You are USDA zone 6. The good news is that you have a lot of options: Albas*, Bourbons, Centifolias*, Damasks*, Gallicas*, Hybrid Perpetuals, Mosses* and Portlands can all be grown in your zone. The "new" English Roses, shrub roses, and some climbers also do well here. The bad news is that you'll experience the worst black spot (a fungal disease) in the country. If you want to grow a wide range of OGRs (especially the repeat blooming Bourbons, Hybrid Perpetuals and Portlands) then a spray program is highly recommended. I use a single application of Daconil in early-to-mid spring followed by Mancozeb at 2-3 week intervals.
In all honesty I'm relatively new to OGRs. I only started growing them myself about four years ago and so far have limited my choices to the repeat blooming classes. Three that I recommend for you are Marchesa Boccella, Reine des Violettes and Souvenir de la Malmaison. The first is a nice shapely medium sized shrub, the second has long flexible thorn free canes that are best grown wrapped around a garden support of some kind, and the third is compact petite bush that is perfect for the front of a flower border. Trust me, once you see the decadent flowers on these Grand Dames ... well, I'll let you find out for yourself.
* Once blooming
User
Original Author19 years agoThe RdV is a must must have. I will look up the other two but I do really like the Mrs. John Laing. It is stunning. These are so addictive. I need more full sun! A good part of our property has mature trees and you know what that means!
- 19 years ago
A good part of our property has mature trees and you know what that means!
A new chain saw????
- 19 years ago
Mrs. John Laing isn't much out here in California, but it was wonderful in Wooster, Oh. The manager of the Roses of Legend and Romance garden was propagating it, and using it to fill in empty spaces, because it was so beautiful and bloomed so well.
Anita - 19 years ago
Reine des Violettes can be a bit of a pain to get started but once it's going, you'll love it forever. Leda is also a must have. As for vendors, I heartily recommend The Uncommon Rose.
- 19 years ago
Did Michael's question get answered?
RdV handles cold well here with graft and canes protected so it would survive your winters well in zone 6 - my first one was an Austin version. Blooms shatter fast - a good HP rose to have to start out - it is the first HP I tried and more examples have been added since 7 years ago.
- 19 years ago
I agree with the others that if you like the look of Reine des Violettes, GO FOR IT. It is a wonderful rose in my garden. Thornless & consistently fragrant ... and has the fine bloom form of a gallica. Get one from The Antique Rose Emporium to ensure you have a virtually thornless specimen.
I don't mean to pick on Pete, and he did back-track a bit, but the beauty of many of the antiques is timeless, and never gets old to me. Many of them have a look and fragrance that can never be duplicated. You might be warm enough to grow some of the china's ... at least I hope so. I highly recommend Spice & Cramoisi Superieur. I love the look of antique china roses growing in a garden along side David Austin English roses and lots of perennials, annuals and other shrubs. The very best of both worlds, in my opinion.
Randy
- 19 years ago
The beauty of many antiques is timeless but beauty is also in the eye of the beholder.I did not back off one wit.My point was do some research and choose an antique that will be timeless for YOU and not just settle for what the nursery people recommend for someone new to antiques.
The lady at the nursery sold me spice,old blush and blush Noisette my first time there.After five years I finally admitted to my wife that she was right . The Old Blush and Blush Noisette were sort of boring and took up way too much room.That was to us-others may very well love these two.We yanked them and planted two other antiques which we are quite fond of.
That was my point- You can benefit from those of us on this forum .You want to make sure if you are going to plant large antiques in the south try and make sure they are going to grow into your favorites-lol.
Love my spice and MvH,Slaters Crimson and Lamarne and would heartily recommend all of them but others may think they are blah.
I should not have confused the issue with knockouts.Wasn't thinking.I meant some love them and some hate em -thats true of different antiques. - 19 years ago
RdV is wonderful, but be careful. There are imposters out there. The real RdV is thornless. I had it up north and stayed pretty clean as long as I sprayed it at least once a month. It has a huge number of blooms in June and then a few more a couple more times in the season. It was pretty cane hardy for zone 4/5 but it did better if we had some snow cover.
Stick around this forum and go to the Antique Rose Gallery to see what tickles your fancy and enjoy these wonderful old roses. :-)
User
Original Author19 years agoForgive my ignorance...what is the difference between David Austins and other OGRs? Also I know some are once bloomers and others repeat but what makes chinas different from HPs or Chinas?
- 19 years ago
> > what is the difference between David Austins and other OGRs?
*** David Austin roses are NOT Old Garden Roses.
"Old Roses" are the sorts of roses that were grown before the onslaught of the Hybrid Tea Rose.
David Austin's roses are MODERN ROSES.
They're every bit as modern as the newest Hybrid Tea or Floribunda, or Miniature or the nifty new Shrub Rose or Climber from Tom Carruth.It's like the difference between a piece of antique jewelry, and a modern reproduction.
Both are pretty. Both are made of gold, and have a nice diamond or pearl. But one is genuine, and the other is NOT. - 19 years ago
"This forum is for discussion of antique, Austin and old garden roses."
It's probably confusing to have 'Austin' right smack in the middle of antique and OGR in the header for this forum!
As I understand it, the reasons that Austins are included here, as opposed to the regular rose forum, is that they almost always have an 'antique' style bloom form, and their heady fragrances are more reminiscent of old roses - thus they are more likely to appeal to OGR enthusiasts.In addition, for myself, David Austin roses were the bridge from modern to antique. It was when I started reading about his breeding program, in which he took modern roses and crossed them with antiques, that it dawned on me that these antique roses were still available!
As for the other classes, you can get some nice thumbnail descriptions of them at the Vintage Gardens website.
Andrea
Here is a link that might be useful: Vintage Gardens
User
Original Author19 years agoAre the David Austins more disease resistant than the OGRs? Do they require spraying in most BS areas?
- 19 years ago
Some of the DA's have pretty good blackspot resistance, Heritage and Willie2000 in my experience, and others. Those may or may not need spraying in Kentucky, depending on your tolerance. Other DAs are about as susceptible as the average HT, which could also be true of many long-cane bourbons, HPs, damasks, and centifolia.
- 19 years ago
I think disease resistance - for any class - is best considered on a rose by rose basis. You will hear different results from different parts of the country. If a variety in particular catches your interest, there is usually someone on this forum that has experience. I start off with a forum search first, and go from there. As some posters have alluded to, your taste in roses will evolve with time. So there's lots to choose from- if a particular one doesn't work out, that just makes room for a new one! I put up with some sickly OGRs (e.g. Zephirine Drouhin- drops all its leaves a few times per year) because they can be wonderful when in bloom.
- 19 years ago
> > > I think disease resistance - for any class - is best considered on a rose by rose basis.
*** WOW is that ever true!
Over 20 years, we've grown almost every sort of rose, and we know that:MOST HTs don't really thrive here.
MOST Teas, Noisettes, Chinas, and Polyanthas DO thrive here.
MOST Austin roses don't really thrive here. (In fact most of them seem not to respond well to a cool coastal climate.)
MOST Northern European once-bloomers need chill hours we do not have, and do not thrive here long-term.
MOST Hybrid Perpetuals and Bourbons are "iffy" for us.But a few HTs are fine here, and a few Teas, Chinas, Noisettes, and Polyanthas are not.
A handful of HPs are reasonably good here.
A handful of Austins are reasonably good here.Look first at classes of roses, seeking groups that, on the whole, thrive in your climate. Then look within those classes to choose the best of them for your microclimate. Remember that even people in a similar plant-hardiness zone may have very different conditions from yours. Local advice is ALWAYS most accurate.
If I'd had LOCAL advice when I began, I might have spent a lot less money on the wrong roses for my garden.Jeri Jennings


cziga