Software
Houzz Logo Print
steve_g21

Soil temperatures -- overwatering

19 years ago

Hi everyone. I've learned a lot reading posts the past couple months and have gone from not knowing anything to gaining enough confidence to feel I can actually landscape and garden our property myself.

We have one very ugly area about 200 sq feet in plain view of our patio that doesn't seem to support life. When we bought the place two years ago, some workers cut down several scraggly-looking trees and left the stumps and roots just below the surface. A gardener just planted around them -- a few ficus trees, bouganvilleas and several different varieties of perennials. They all have struggled and/or died. I wondered if the stumps and roots were rotting and toxifying the soil, but in digging around the soil today, I think I've worked out the primary problem. It's clearly clay, and after I get through the virtually impenetrable surface with a mattock, the soil is moist, wormless, really hot and it just plain smells rotten.

I dug out my darkroom thermometer and checked the temp. in several spots about 8 inches below the surface. It ranged from 100 to 120 degrees. This seemed ridiculously high, but having no idea what range might be considered ideal, I checked soils where the plants were doing fine. Those temps were anywhere from 68 in shady areas to 80 degrees in sunny spots. We live at the coast, and our average daytime ambient temp the past month has probably been around 65. I figure we have overwatered the problem area and it hasn't drained. But is the elevated temperature a typical effect of this? Would the decaying stumps and roots contribute to the heat? Should proper soil temp reflect an average of day/nightime air temperatures?

I think we'll have to change the nature of the clay soils with sand and other amendements, and mulch well this time. I'm debating taking the stumps and roots out as it is a big job, but even if it doesn't impact the soil temp/quality, they definitely are limiting our planting abilities. Thanks for your help.

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    Just do lasagna beds on top of the area. If you don't know what that is, do a search on here or google.
    Leave the stumps and rootes if you can do the bed high enough anyways, because they will rot and make great compost and you won't need to be digging that deep anyways. Let the worms spread out the matter.

  • 19 years ago

    Where on the coast? Which coast?

    It sounds like there's something going on in there. Most likely some sort of decomposition of something. I wouldn't think the trees that were removed would be the cause of that much of a temperature change, especially not two years after the fact. Is it possible that there's a sewage or septic leak somewhere?

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for both responses. We're in Southern California, just south of LA and about a half mile from the Ocean. It's been socked in with a marine fog layer much of this spring, so we've had generally cool days. The lasagna beds idea is indeed a new concept for me, so I'll have to investigate it. I had already mixed in a lot of compost with the soil, and as it's an elevated section behind a 2' retaining wall and threatening to overflow the banks, I'm not sure how much higher I can make it. If I end up adding some sand, I'm going to have a lot of excess soil and will have to figure out what to do with it.

    I doubt there's any sewage as there are no pipes or drains, to my knowledge, passing underneath (there is a giant oil refinery just a few blocks away that always arouses suspicions, but I'm quite sure that's not the culprit in this case). As much as I would love to have it dug out to see if there's anything obvious, I don't think it's feasible. I suppose if we were completely desperate and scraped together the cash, we could have the soil swapped out, but that seems rather drastic. Does anybody ever do this?

    Sending the soil in for comprehensive testing might be a good start.

  • 19 years ago

    You might try contacting your county extension service. They should be able to provide an inexpensive soil test, and they may also be able to help if you bring some of the "offending" soil in for them to look at.

    The fact that you added some compost may be a clue. If you added compost that wasn't finished, it may still be composting, and that could be hiking the temperature.

  • 19 years ago

    Certainly a soil test will be useful. You may also want to dig down where you measured those high temps for a visual and feel with your hand to see if you can figure out what is going on. Look, see, feel, & smell.

    The soil should be close to the ambient air temp unless you have some decompostion going on. Or you are living on a volcano? Lava would be much warmer, no? But I am sure you will be able to feel it if the temps are truly that high.

    Good Luck,
    Gumby_CT

  • 19 years ago

    "Or you are living on a volcano?"

    Geothermal activity crossed my mind, as well, but it's not usually so localized, is it?

  • 19 years ago

    Unmulched soils exposed to the sun can get quite hot, hot enough to give you superficial burns. Start with a good, reliable soil test, Contact your local office of the University of California USDA Cooperative Extension Service to find out where and how to do that. Doing the "Lasagna" bed thing may well be the best way to deal with this and that will be a mulch that will help shield the soil from the sun so it will be cooler and the Soil Food Web will start to work.

    Here is a link that might be useful: UCAN CES

  • 19 years ago

    The geothermal angle is an interesting one but I suspect the cause is more mundane. I added the compost and soil conditioner last year -- it was commercially prepared and bagged so I'm assuming it was no longer active. The similarly sized bed next to it is doing much better. There were no trees to take down there, so that is what got me thinking initially the stumps were the problem. The soil is not as caked and seems to drain better. It actually receives a little more sun than the problem soil.

    I think the culprit was combining dense soil with excess watering and not mulching. The sprinklers are poorly positioned, dousing the one area and probably delivering appropriate amounts to the the other. I didn't recognize this until too late, and, in fact, when I saw the plants suffering, I plied them with more water from the hose thinking they were drying up (the surface was hardpan and struck me as desert-like). The water could not drain all the way through, and it seems somehow the moisture, trapped with no air, caused some kind of anaerobic heat releasing decay. But I'm no scientist, so I'm really just guessing. I'll contact the local extension office to see what they think and where I might go for testing if it's necessary.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions