Software
Houzz Logo Print
dragonflyfarm_2007

Help choosing a new Garden Tractor...

19 years ago

Hello,

I need to purchase a new riding mower for the property I take care of. Currently have an old Gravely that has served us very well but is needing repairs often.

We have aprox 7 acres to mow every week...some of which is done with a push mower. I would like to be able to mulch the grass but also have the option to bag it occasionally as needed. I have another small riding mower for hauling a cart or spreader as needed, an old Steiner that I plow snow with, and a bigger John Deere Tractor with a bucket loader for moving mulch, turning compost etc.

My question is what is the best machine out there for mowing this much grass? I need it to be dependable and easy to maintain (I'm female)...also want it to be durable and not fall apart. I've heard John Deere is the best but don't you pay a premium for the name?

Any help and suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

Comments (21)

  • 19 years ago

    I suggest you use what you have - use the John deere that you have and get a mower for it. probably a rear 3pt finish mower would be the best bet - 7 acres is a good size plot to mow, so getting a large deck will cut down on the time to mow, depending on obstacles. at least a 60" to 72" would work. If you get the rear 3 pt mower, Im sure it will be the least expensive option compared to another machine. I think this is either first choice mower price or midwest brand 3pt, just to give you an idea
    GM30-60" $1,350
    GM30-72" $1,450
    GM30-84" $1,750

  • 19 years ago

    How about getting gang mowers for the large Deere tractor you
    already have? If it's a diesel, that will save money on fuel.

  • 19 years ago

    7 acre's is a formidable area to mow. The worst thing you can do is under-buy and end up tearing up a machine not meant for that kind of usage.

    I think you are easily in the range of a Cub 3000 or 5000 series, or the equivelent JD.

    You will not find what you need at Sears or a box store. You need to visit a real tractor dealer for what you need.

    -Larry

  • 19 years ago

    BTW... That's enough to consider Diesel IMHO.

    -Larry

  • 19 years ago

    7 acres is a lot to mow. I once had a summer job as a teenager mowing a little over 5 acres with a push mower. It was a fulltime job, I would mow about an acre a day and just startover again the following week. If I was going to do that now a would want a commercial ZTR.
    steve

  • 19 years ago

    "I once had a summer job as a teenager mowing a little over 5 acres with a push mower."

    sadixon49 is my new hero! (LOL!)

    Bill

  • 19 years ago

    I'm with ervie and ducati. Get a deck for the JD. if you need to get close or in a small area, thats where you get off the deere and hop on a riding mower.

    You can find decks pretty much anywhere from Tractor Supply to your local JD dealer, although the ones from TS aren't that pretty green color. (you could always paint it green I suppose)

  • 19 years ago

    I strongly agree with the above messages about getting a 3-point 6-foot or 7-foot mower to mount on your big tractor. That will be the fastest way of getting it mowed with the least wear and tear on your equipment. The other alternative would be to buy a commercial ZTR mower with a 60" deck or larger, but you're talking big bucks ($7,500 and up).

    Depending on how bumpy the 7 acres is, a ZTR might beat you to death compared to your big JD with a pto-driven mower behind it. You won't get as good a cut with the rear-mounted mower as you would with a ZTR or lawn tractor, but that's a trade-off I'd make any day of the week.

  • 19 years ago

    7 acres = ZTR many good ones - pick the one you like.
    I sold a slightly used Woods RM990 this spring, I used it behind a JD 2040D. It would not begin to stay with a 'bota ZD28 with a 72" deck in acres or quality of cut. Just my experience.
    Still have the JD 2040, use it for loader only now(again), well the good thing is I only have about 11K in the JD and FEL, I see I have a couple of hydraulic hoses leaking they will only be $200-300 if I do the change out, maybe they will last the summer - - -

  • 19 years ago

    Hey dragonfly you still around? or your stuck in some tree sap? we gave you some good advice - the least of which you should acknowledge with a reply back - you might want to tell us the types of machines (Deere) you already have -

    Geesh....

  • 19 years ago

    Passthegravy said
    "You won't get as good a cut with the rear-mounted mower as you would with a ZTR or lawn tractor"

    That"s why gang mowers are made. They are reel type mowers and
    give a beautiful cut. Pro Mow gold series 5 gang mower cuts a
    97 inch swath. It sells for $2695. If that Deere tractor is in
    running condition I'd get the Pro Mow to tow behind it.

  • 19 years ago

    Reel type gang mowers...I see these for sale on e-bay all the time, big 8-ft. plus Toro's with diesel engines for not that much asking price. But, I can't imagine having to sharpen every one of those cutting edges, making sure they are all straight, and having to align the cutting edges to the shear edge in order to get a good cut. I remember doing this with a simple walk-behind push type, and motorized, reel mowers. Took some time to get the cutting edge clearances just right without leaving uncut grass behind.

    Bill

  • 19 years ago

    Sorry, ducati996 for delay in responding :

    Parts of the lawns are not perfectly smooth and have rocks scattered thru out...part of the CT landscape look. Others are very smooth and manicured looking. Some are sloped and a bit hilly. It's definitely lawn, not a pasture with an irrigation system thru out.

    I have a John Deere 955 (diesel) with a 70a Bucket loader... I also have a 413 Rotary Cutter for it. I was told this was mainly a brush cutter for mowing down a field or pasture and in the 7 years I've been here, it's never been used.

    I don't think the John Deere would be good due to it's size and manueverablity...bronze sculptures, trees, rocks, slopes, and slightly rolling lawns.

    The Gravely 50" Promaster has been a great machine but I wanted to investigate other options. I know I'm looking at a $10-15k investment so I want to make sure I make the right choice. When I talk to the tractor salesmen, they of course want to sell me their machine whether it's the best or not :P

    Thanks so much for all your input :)

  • 19 years ago

    First, I'm not sure why any homeowner would want to keep 7 acres mowed. Me thinks your crazy ;^) Anyway the rocks prevent any reel mower usage. In general though you have to determine how long you want to spend mowing (every 5 days) and get an appropriate width deck(s). Definitely look at gang mowers. I have no affiliation with these guys, but think you need something like this...

    -gh

    Here is a link that might be useful: Large gang setup

  • 19 years ago

    If I had 7 acres to mow, I would want at least 9' of mowing width. Here's another option.

    Trail Mower

    Check out the video in the upper right hand corner. The video shows the 44" model. For 7 acres, I'd get the 66" deck.

    You can pull trailmowers with any GT. Run your GT deck and pull the trailmower at an offset.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    It's an estate that I manage...weekend home for NYC folks :) There are almost 90 acres so I'm lucky only 7 acres are lawns! I have 2 full time men (50 hours a week) who work with me from April thru November just maintaining the grounds and it usually takes all three of us 2 days a week to mow and trim the property. Rest of the week is spent weeding, pruning, trimming shrubs, and maintaining the gardens.

    I don't think I should go any bigger than a 52 inch deck due to the unevenness of the lawns and the manueverablity needed as mentioned before. I just wanted some input as to which mower would be best. All the different brands confuse me and I want to make sure I get a good, dependable mower that will last for a long time :)

    Is there a place that compares different features and gives honest reviews about the different mowers out there?

  • 19 years ago

    Three men working 10 hours/day for two days is 60 man-hours. Heck, you can easily mow those 7 acres with push mowers...maybe even with weed-wackers.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    Sounds like money is not an issue for those homeowners (to say the least!!!). If that's the case, I'd look at the best commercial ZTR you can find. Probably a Scag, Gravely, Hustler or perhaps a Wright Stander. I looked at a Toro commercial model at my John Deere dealer on Saturday while buying some JD parts, and it looked like a well-built machine also. Or, if you really want the ultimate manicured look, the Walker is supposed to be the ultimate. (I've never used one).

  • 19 years ago

    "I want to make sure I get a good, dependable mower that will last for a long time :)" You said garden tractor and not much
    wider than 50".

    The highest quality garden tractors are built by Kubota, Deere and Simplicity. Which one has a dealer nearby? You can't go wrong with these brands.

  • 19 years ago

    A Kubota GR2100 54" deck,diesel,glidesteer for no turf damage in tight turns and 36" uncut circle,and handles like a go-kart.The three of you will be fighting each other to get behind the wheel..:-)

  • 19 years ago

    dragonflyfarm_2007 ,

    I was only being a wise arse earlier - it was meant (only if you saw it) to post more info on what you have. It Succeeded but hopefully you saw the humor in my response ?

    Anyway I have a much better perspective and I still think you can do the finish mowing with a Rear or side discharge finish mower of at least a 60" (72" most likely better) on the 955. Its a big machine but it can do finish mowing as long as its not in 4wd. I would find a rental yard and try one out for size first. Then you can judge if a new mower will do the trick or just the rear mower. I think your employer will give you kudos if you say I only need $2k for an attachment, instead of a $7500 (good ZTR) or sub-cut/CUT for $14k and higher. Just my opinion - even very wealthy folks dont like to spend alot of money everytime ;)

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz