Software
Houzz Logo Print
diggerdee

Not sure what to do with this bed...

Help!

{{gwi:238467}}

This used to be a shade bed, or a mostly shade bed. It's hard to tell from the photo, but the land drops off fairly steeply just behind it. There was a tree behind it, down the hill, and between the tree and the bed were lots of scrub shrubs - wild rose, wild grape, those big chokeberries(??) and just lots of stuff. The stuff that's there now is nothing compared to the jungle it was!

The homeowner had the tree removed (it was dead), and had big equipment in to clear out the shrubs, including a long row of it off to the left out of the photo.

So now I have two dilemmas. One, there doesn't seem to be any reason for this bed. I know that sounds corny, but it just seems to be in the middle of this area now.

Secondly, there was a row of huge hostas in this bed that, after more than 7 years, have just disappeared. (Some lilies and daffodils also did not return after this winter.)

So now the bed is empty.

We had been thinking of putting in a row of short (5-6 feet)evergreens behind the hostas anyway, just as a visual barrier to the mess below, and also to kind of set off the bed. The bed is at the entrance to a driveway, so I think something taller and evergreen would help.

Now the big question - what to put there? It's a quite sunny area now, and quite dry (even though right down the hill is that bog garden I put in for my friend, if anyone remembers).

Here's a shot from the side:

{{gwi:238468}}

We had lots of extra woodchips last fall, so I spread them behind where the bed ended, as a buffer between the bed and all the junk.

Already in the bed are geranium biokovo, iberis Autumn beauty, some hardy mums, a few daylilies that are barely hanging on, some vinca, few trillium, and that's about it.

Any suggestions would be of great help. I'm drawing a blank on this one.

Thanks!

:)

Dee

Comments (24)

  • 17 years ago

    Dee, do you have any idea why some things recently disappeared? I'd be hesistant to buy expensive evergreens without an idea of the cause.

    Otherwise, it sounds like a good fit. Something with a little height to become the "main attraction."

  • 17 years ago

    I'd plant native wildflowers in it. Asclepias, Echinaceas, and other plants like them that butterflies love and that return each year.

  • 17 years ago

    I see it planted with some taller grasses in the back where the land drops down. Many varieties to choose from...and less costly than evergreens and they will be okay with the drier contitions. Left uncut they will add winter interest and after spring cutting will quickly fill in again.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the quick replies!

    Sienna, no, I have no idea. I'm really puzzled why daffodils and hostas disappeared - two of the hardiest things going.

    The bulbs I would normally think drainage, but I'm sure that's not an issue here. As for the hostas...? There is one coming back now, but the other four or five are just gone. There doesn't appear to be any animal damage. Puzzling, especially since the iberis, mums, and geranium are okay. The daylilies are struggling but they were newly planted last fall, so maybe that's an issue.

    I'm actually beginning to wonder if I did something wrong by spreading those woodchips. The bed was fine until this winter.

    Gazania, I'm a little intimidated by grasses, I'm afraid to admit, lol. I'm worried I'll pick something too agressive, or I'm worried I'll pick something too hard to deal with (I've heard people complain about doing battle with grasses when it's time to cut back or divide or something like that. They would look nice here, though, I suppose, and different from much of the rest of the neighborhood...

    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    I would put in one or two smaller evergreen (like a Picea Glauca maybe) and then a mixed ornamental grasses border with your perennials in front. It would be gorgeous in fall and winter and a nice contrast to your flower beds.

    I have quite a few ornamental grasses so I can suggest a few of my favorites that are also very well behaved for you to look at if you'd like. I just tie a string around the grasses in the spring and cut them down, the rest of the year they get little to no attention and they are beautiful. (Which is good since my roses take SO much attention.)

    The largest/tallest and would be really outstanding on that raised berm would be Miscanthus Gracillimus which I have mixed in with spruce. The are large and flower in the late summer/fall and the stalks are strong enough to withstand winter snow and ice which look beautiful on them.

    A few other of my favorites would be Pennisetum Karley Rose (my very favorite), Miscanthus Morning Light, Pennisetum Hameln, Panicum Shenandoah and Miscanthus Adagio.

  • 17 years ago

    I think you need more structure than grasses or perennials can provide. How about kalmia or rhoddies? The soil looks like it could use some serious amending for moisture retention? If you used the lasagna technique this summer...next spring you could plant & with a top dressing of leaf mold/manure the bed should retain moisture much better than it does now. If the area's large enough you might consider anchoring it with a small ornamental tree? Then, a mass planting of the same perennial underneath the tree/shrubs would tie the bed together as well as shade the soil. Staggering bloom times for a tree, 2-3 shrubs, & the perennials would give you a long period of interest for the drive entrance.

    Using kalmia or rhoddies would take a little longer for growth to block out the view beyond but looking out 5 years...I'd be happier with blooms than just evergreens.

    /tricia

  • 17 years ago

    My first thought was Lavender, since it is now sunny with good drainage. Echinacea would be pretty behind that, then maybe some tall ornamental grasses. It looks like a lovely spot.

  • 17 years ago

    I was thinking soil amending, too, as it sounds like all the nutrients have been sucked out of it. Hostas like a lot of water.

    I like the rhodie idea but they're expensive and hard to get established, plus I'm trying to get two Nova Zemblas going, winter was very hard on them, and I need to water them quite a bit; the leaves curl down. Azaleas would be pretty there, too, but both take acid soil. Maybe amend the soil and plant tulips and daffodils overplanted with wildflowers and poppies.

    Then you could build on that and still get a little color going in there.

    Is it possible there was a chemical spill or leaching? Roundup shouldn't be a problem mixed and applied properly, but there are others that have more lasting effects. It doesn't look like that's what it is. Could the neighbor have used something in the gully that drifted?

  • 17 years ago

    Actually, the soil here has been amended every year for the last four years. It's really not *bad* soil, it's just a very dry area because of the hill, I think, and now having all that extra sun doesn't help. Yes, we could probably mulch better, but trust me, I'm a soil fanatic and while I'm still working on it (as it's an on-going process, IMO)and will continue to amend every year, the soil is decent. Not great, but certainly not bad enough to contribute to plant death, lol.

    I had been thinking of rhodies, but she has several in front of her house, as well as some kalmias. We were hoping to go with something different, although I would love to have something blooming.

    Tricia, I forgot to add that both I and her father have been trying to talk her into replacing the dead tree with an ornamental tree. We're still working on her, and she's cracking, lol. I really feel that would anchor that whole area, and then if we had some mid-size evergreens it would look good.

    Diana, thanks for the list of grasses. It's good to have some names of ones that are well-behaved for others. I hadn't even thought of grasses, and now I think they might look nice there, perhaps mixed in with some evergreens.

    Aliska, I don't think there was any kind of chemical damage. She's got wooded lots on several sides, and the house across the street does absolutely no landscaping, lol. They cut their grass and that's about it. I guess we just had a bad winter. It is a somewhat exposed site, and now that I think about it, it's really exposed since all that stuff is gone.

    I'm also loving some of the ideas for perennials to go in front of whatever evergreens I choose. Thanks!

    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Diana on Pennisetum Karly Rose. A great grass, the color is outstanding in the sunlight. It is not as sturdy as the two Miscanthus that she named. Karley Rose won't hold up as well through the winter and does tend to 'swoon' in heavy summer rain, but stands itself back up within a few hours. In my experience with both Miscanthus, they tend to spread more than Karley, and harder to dig up to rejuvinate, but not so difficult that I would be hesitant to plant them. Of all my many grasses, I think that M. Gracillimus would work best.

  • 17 years ago

    Here is P. Karley Rose. She is 4 to 5 feet tall here. Blooms early. This pic was taken on June 25 last year. She will continue to send up plumes till frost. Like diana, this in my favorite grass, but not as sturdy/tidy as the Miscanthus grasses. Sorry that I don't have any decent pics of them.

    {{gwi:238469}}

  • 17 years ago

    The area looks like it could use a small tree, or large specimen shrub as a focal point. I was thinking of something like a Serviceberry (Amelanchier arborea), or in your part of the country, maybe a redbud or dogwood. Once you have an anchor there, the rest of the bed should come together easily.

    Bonnie

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Bonnie. Appears the problem is dry soil. diggerdee, you say you amend every year. How do you do that without churning it up again? I have two huge bags of peat we didn't use when tilling my strip, what can I do with that? It blows away if on top, I could pile some compost over it but have already used a lot of my (precious) bags there already this spring. I say precious because it's cheap but inconvenient to haul and hard for me to lift.

    But this is about you. I don't know why your daffs didn't come back, must REALLY be dry. I had some for years and all of a sudden they would fall over and not bloom, still haven't nailed the problem, entirely different situation than yours.

    I'm thinking since your spot is dry and looks quite a ways from wherever your house and water supply are, maybe you should plant for dry soil. But something still is not adding up if you've been amending the soil right along.

    Maybe, and I hate to bother with this myself, but you should send some samples in to your state university for analysis, doesn't cost much in Iowa. Before I put much effort in that spot unless a couple of things take off, I'd want to know if the problem is just dry soil. My logic is it must have been dry before and things did ok there. What happened to make it change?

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, a dogwood was what I was thinking for behind the bed.

    Aliska, I amend the bed (and every bed I have) every fall with a layer of compost or composted manure, and a layer of finely shredded leaves. The beds get another layer of shredded leaves in spring, and some of the more visible and/or formal beds get a mulch of cocoa hulls (too expensive to use everywhere!). In the fall, the compost and leaves go right over the cocoa hulls or old leaves, and the cycle starts again. I never till any beds. I feel it destroys the soil structure.

    I wont argue that the soil is dry, but I know that's not the reason why I lost hostas, daffodils, lilies and some daylilies. Like you said, it was dry before and things did okay. If anything, the soil is better now than it was five years ago, so I'm sure the dryness alone is not the culprit. Also, I should note that the photos you see were taken in April soon after our four-day-long 90-degree spell. I think the creek at the bottom of the hill was dry that day, lol! Seriously, I do think it was, if I remember correctly! But perhaps the suggestion of a soil test is not a bad idea

    But anyway, back to the original question - evergreen suggestions. I've gotten a suggestion of picea glauca and rhodies and kalmias. I really do like the idea of a grass here - and the Karly Rose is beautiful! - but if anyone has any ideas for any other evergreens here, I'd appreciate it. Again, I'm looking for mid-size, maybe 5 to six feet tall. Flowering would be a bonus, but not necessary.

    Thanks to everyone's help, I'm starting to visualize some nice things here - I just still can't picture the backdrop!

    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    It sounds like you did everything right. One other idea that was suggested to me, I balked, then decided it was worth it. Next time I get to the nursery, I'm getting a ph tester. I'm having some problems, too.

    Just a couple more things. I loooooove dogwoods and have never successfully grown any. No room really or something else takes priority to try again, know they like acid soil. I dug up a little juniper, softish and not stickery and put it in my pit by the front door, take too long to explain how that is. It looks kind of nice even though slow growing.

    But I'm not real big into evergreen with a small property. Larger and I'd like some like Colorado Blue Spruce, not more yew thank you! My neighbor was showing me his new plants and plans, and he had this most beautiful, soft evergreen plant, don't know the name of it, how big it's supposed to get, but it was that gray green, very full, lays kind of lower, needles are about the length of a um Douglas fir? Maybe 3/4 in?

    I'll find out what it was. Maybe I could make room for something like that. And a Butterfly Bush or two or three . . .that's enough. He's also got two baskets of multi-colored million bells on his front porch. They're sure pretty. I spent so darn much on this and that, I don't want to spend anything more on baskets, but sure would like to hang a couple up somewhere.

    I got so cold, I had to turn the heat on. It's rainy, low 60's and damp here.

  • 17 years ago

    Maybe you can plant a shrub that will give you winter interest such as Ilex verticillata or a native Viburnum. Birds will love the berries too. An American Dogwood will be nice as well. Or you can plant a Red Twig Dogwood next to your evergreen.

  • 17 years ago

    Will the planting area remain in front of the wood chips or does it include the wood chips? I'm sure you know that wood chips deplete nitrogen from the soil. Not sure if they can deplete beyond their bounds??? probably not.

    I think a soil test is definitely in order. I would do two. one exactly where a hosta was and another a combination of a few areas (which is what they generally recommend). Daylilies "barely hanging on" is similarly suspicous.

    A thought on hosta disappearance was voles, because they love freshly mulched fall areas and hosta. However, that doesn't explain the daffodils,daylilies. And I'm sure you would have seen their telltale signs.

    I am also wondering if the first picture is the view from the house. I definitely see evergreens there. In particular, I see a gorgeous blue spruce. Two to consider are 'Fat Albert' and 'Sester Dwarf'. They are both slow growing, the latter more so. Or Oriental spruce 'Skylands' is a nice focal point evergreen.

    Is this a low-no-maintenance area? ("no" in homeowner thinking... we know that there is no no) If it is out of the way, it probably should be.

    for low-no-maint, I envision a specimen spruce and several virburnums, winterberries, Kolwitzia 'Dream Catcher' (great chartreuse foliage), some other foliage-centric shrubs and maybe a mass of low ground cover rhodies like purple gem for spring color. and possibly some perennials for summer color. Maybe another evergreen middle layer shrub too. Oh, a threadleaf japanese maple would add a nice pop. I like tamukeyema (sp?) and inaba shadira (sp?)

    I don't picture grasses with this vision. To me, the shrubs are woodland, the grasses are prairie.

  • 17 years ago

    also physocarpus 'diablo' or 'summer wine'

  • 17 years ago

    Wow guys, thanks for all those suggestions! I am off to do a bit of googling, lol.

    Wendy, good question about the woodchip area being part of the bed or not. I haven't yet decided. Obviously that area was not part of the original bed. However, depending upon what we decide to put there, we may expand the bed back into that area.

    However, if we do that, we will have to add soil, and I'm not sure if we want to attempt to fight the topography of the hill or not. I know that woodchips mixed into the soil depletes it, but on top is okay, as a mulch.

    The other option is to leave the woodchip area as is and expand the bed out toward the street - which, by the way, is where the photo was taken from, or at least from the street direction. There is a driveway to the right of that bed, and then farther to the right is the house. So the bed is not out-of-the-way per se, since it's the first thing seen when coming in the driveway. It is, however, far enough from the house to make it desirable to be a low-maintenance bed.

    Thanks again for the suggestions!
    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    My doggie just decided to pose in front of Fat Albert, so I thought I would share:

    {{gwi:238470}}

    She never sits on that rock. I thought it was so funny.

    This tree has gotta be at least 15 years old. It was one of my first acquisitions and I've been here 17 years. Its just starting to get a little opened up, but probably because the d%$@%$ pine trees in the area are getting bigger and creating more shade, even though it faces south,southwest.

  • 17 years ago

    dd,i have lots of ideas but you must tell us the dimensions of the bed plse!\\is it crescent shaped? L? D at deepest point?
    mindy

  • 17 years ago

    Mindy, yes, the bed is roughly crescent-shaped. I'd say at it deepest point it's maybe six feet, tapering to about two feet deep at the ends.

    The length, off the top of my head (and I'm really bad at estimating stuff like this) is possibly 20 feet long.

    We could expand the bed both in both depth and length, if need be.

    Thanks,
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    If it makes any difference, I forgot to add, in case it's not clear in the photo, that the bed slopes down the hill, to the right of the picture, so one end (the right side) of the bed is lower than the other (he left).

    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    Well, after all this, my friend told me she was thinking of putting in some fencing in this spot, lol!

    Actually, I don't think it's a bad idea. I never even thought of that, to be honest. But she was walking in the neighborhood and saw, near the entrance to the driveway of a house, a section of white picket fencing with a bench, and liked the way it looked.

    So maybe the next step will be to find a nice flowering tree that can go behind the fence. Have to find something that will tolerate wet feet, since a few feet down the hill below this very dry bed is the start of a swamp, lol. Talk about extremes.

    Thanks all!
    :)
    Dee